The first two games between Sidney Crosby and Connor McDavid reflected the common perception of the two players, widely considered the best in the NHL.

McDavid had the points, outscoring Crosby, 4-0, individually, but Crosby and the Penguins came away with wins  in both games against the Edmonton Oilers.

That played out in the season as a whole, too, as McDavid won the Art Ross Award and Hart Trophy, but Crosby lifted the Stanley Cup for a second consecutive season, taking home the Conn Smythe Trophy as the playoff’s  most valuable player.

The league’s best scorer vs. the league’s best winner. That’s the storyline, anyways.

Advertise with us

“There’s always matchups, storylines and things like that,” Crosby said. “We sit here and we talk about them, but then you have to go out there and play.”

That’s exactly what the Penguins and Oilers will do Tuesday night, as Crosby and McDavid go against each other for the third time. The individual storyline might be on the two superstars, but the team narratives are interesting, too.

The Penguins and Oilers both harbor realistic Stanley Cup aspirations, but both have stumbled at times in the early season.

The Oilers, especially, have failed to live up to expectations. They sit at 2-5-0 going into Tuesday night, above only dismal Arizona in the Western Conference.

The Penguins are certainly in better shape than Edmonton, but do own the third-worst goal differential in the Eastern Conference thanks to a few blowout losses. Their goaltending and forward depth have been questionable, although they made moves to address both issues in recent days.

Advertise with us

“We’re trying to take each game as it comes, we’re trying to get better every day when we come to the rink,” Penguins coach Mike Sullivan said. “We’re not overly concerned at this point with who our opponent is. Every team in this league is a big challenge. There’s just that much parity in the league and there’s a lot of good players, there’s a lot of good coaching staffs that prepare their teams the right way.”

But even Sullivan admitted that Tuesday night will be a bit different.

“Obviously, there’s some added interest because of the stature of the players in the game, and that’s always exciting for everybody involved, and we understand that,” he said.

Within the game, the big question will be just how often Crosby and McDavid go head to head. Crosby said he matched up with McDavid early in the first meeting last year, but did so less as the game went on and the Penguins rallied for an eventual 4-3 win.

“He was flying around pretty good early, and I think they were up,” Crosby said. “I started off playing against him and then I think we got down a bit and kind of played against anybody at that point.”

Advertise with us

That could very well be the case Tuesday night. Sullivan was quick to remind reporters Monday, though, that putting Crosby on the ice against McDavid isn’t him trying to help the NHL’s marketing department.

“We play Sid against other teams’ top lines all the time, and he’s a very competitive guy,” Sullivan said. “He’s a good, solid, two-way player. I think Sid’s play away from the puck is very underrated. I think it flies under the radar because he’s so dynamic offensively.”

Crosby will be hoping for a bit more offensive dynamism Tuesday night than his two games against Edmonton last year, but he also would settle for a similar result on the scoreboard.

Sam Werner: swerner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @SWernerPG.