NEW YORK — When asked whether or not the Penguins’ win against the Rangers Tuesday night was how he and the coaching staff drew it up, Mike Sullivan just offered a smile.

“No,” he admitted. “It wasn’t.”

The process? Not great. The result? Sullivan will take that for now, as the Penguins overcame a mostly sloppy effort to pile on the struggling Rangers, winning 5-4 on Evgeni Malkin’s overtime winner.

“That's kind of the way we've played so far this season,” winger Carl Hagelin said. “We haven’t really been able to put 60 minutes together, and we didn’t really do it tonight either. We’re happy with the two points, but that’s not the way we want to play.”

Advertise with us

That wasn’t the case early, though, as the first 20 minutes went about as well as the Penguins could have hoped for. They dominated an overwhelmed Rangers team that came into the game 1-5-0 on the season. Phil Kessel broke his four-game goal drought with a signature snipe from the right side, and Hagelin got his first goal of the season.

“I thought we had a great first period,” Sullivan said. “I really liked how we played in the first period. We controlled momentum, we made good decisions with the puck, we had numbers back, we stayed on the right side of the puck and the right side of people for a lot of the period.”

Then the second period came. And with it, the parade to the penalty box. The Penguins were whistled for four infractions over those 20 minutes, including Sidney Crosby’s four-minute high-sticking penalty that led to tying and go-ahead goals for the Rangers.

“You never like being in the box and seeing a couple go in,” Crosby said. “It’s not a great feeling.”

The Penguins are second in the league in penalty minutes per game, averaging 17:08 per contest. They had 16 Tuesday night.

Advertise with us

“We know what the rules are, but we took some stupid penalties, myself included,” Hagelin said.

By the time the second period started to wind down, the Penguins were probably lucky to only be down one goal.

“This game is all about momentum and when the [other] team gets momentum, they can’t have it for more than 2-3 shifts,” Patric Hornqvist said. “They had it for probably 10 shifts there and that’s what happened, they scored three goals.”

Both Hornqvist and Sullivan, though, pointed to the Penguins’ 5-on-3 penalty kill at the end of the second period as a turning point. It lasted a full 1:44, with the Rangers barely sniffing a scoring opportunity.

“That’s huge for us,” Hornqvist said. “Right there, the bench was fired up.”

Advertise with us

A few seconds later, Hornqvist turned that energy into a game-tying goal, this time with the Penguins capitalizing on a power-play chance.

“For me, those are the types of moments that good power plays show themselves, when you score in those situations,” Sullivan said.

The Penguins entered the third period with plenty of momentum (and even a little leftover power-play time) but David Desharnais’ second goal of the game put them down, 4-3, 8:00 in, and Mike Sullivan said — even if it was better than the second period — he didn’t necessarily like what he saw.

“I think in the third period, we were pressing to try to get that tying goal, and sometimes when you do that, you become a high-risk hockey team,” Sullivan said. “We gave up a number of real high-quality chances because we were pressing. I think the lesson is I don’t think this team has to press. We can score a goal, we had plenty of time to score a goal.”

He was right. The Penguins did have time to plenty of score a goal, and they came pretty close to using all of it. Eventually, though, Crosby did what only Crosby can do, banking a puck off Rangers goalie Henrik Lundqvist and into the net from behind the goal line to tie the score with less than a minute remaining.

Advertise with us

It’s not the first time Crosby has scored a goal like that. It’s not by accident, either.

“He works on it every single practice,” Hornqvist said. “Every time the rebound goes in the corner, he goes and gets it and tries to bank it off the goalie. He’s the best player in the world, and it’s crazy he can do that stuff, but I’m not surprised.”

By that point, all that was left to do was Malkin and Kessel capitalizing off a bad Rangers turnover in overtime, and the Penguins escape New York with their second road win of the season. It might not end up on any season-ending highlight reels (except, perhaps, Crosby’s tying goal) but it counts for two points in the standings just like the rest of them.

“Fortunately, what I love about our group is we have that stick-to-itiveness,” Sullivan said. “We just stay with it. It was an ugly win, but it’s a win.”

Sam Werner: swerner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @SWernerPG