Mike Sullivan has faced tougher decisions.

Surely for Game 4 of the Eastern Conference final, when he chose Matt Murray over Marc-Andre Fleury. Or the over-arching direction he’s determined for this team. Or swapping goalie coaches — Mike Bales for Mike Buckley — this offseason.

But who Sullivan — and let’s not kid ourselves, it’s his call — selects as alternate captain to replace Chris Kunitz will be fascinating to watch.

Expect an announcement soon, and the smart money is on Kris Letang.

Advertise with us

“He’s targeted a guy who he feels is the right fit,” general manager Jim Rutherford said Thursday. “I agree with him. He’ll announce that at the right time.”

Asked in Buffalo at the Prospects Challenge about how he’d go about selecting said player, Sullivan described it as more of a group effort.

Really, though, it’s not that complicated. Toss out every forward except Hornqvist, whose credentials we’ll examine shortly. Your runner-up, honestly, is probably Phil Kessel, but laying low has been great for Phil these past two years.

Nobody else on defense comes close to Letang.

Unless, of course, we’re talking about alternate captain as some sort of drinking game. In which case, go defense all the way.

Advertise with us

One off-the-board pick could be selecting Murray, a two-time Stanley Cup-winning goaltender at a mature-beyond-his-years 23, but he is a goaltender; there’s not a ton of precedent for such things.

Another could be selecting Letang and Hornqvist, but Rutherford said Sullivan has targeted “a guy” and not a group of them. Plus, Sullivan does have an old-school approach to some things, stuff like this falling into that category.

So, Letang.

The defenseman who’s downright maniacal about his workouts. The player who’s universally respected by his peers, even if they seem to close every statement about him with the qualifier — if he stays healthy.

The guy drafted by the Penguins in 2005 (third round, astonishing by itself). The guy who has played 603 games, could’ve played so many more and a guy who should — with a good run of health — challenge for the organization’s second Norris Trophy behind Randy Carlyle in 1980-81.

Advertise with us

“Letang is a heck of a player,” legendary coach Scott Bowman said by phone Thursday, in a quick detour while discussing another topic. Seriously, Scotty brought it up unprompted.

“Those defensemen are very scarce,” Bowman continued. “He’s a player made for the NHL the way it’s played now.”

Hornqvist has a leadership role, and that won’t change. He’ll remain the Penguins’ emotional leader, the dude on the bench who may or may not be a little insane. He’ll rip shirts. He’ll run into the showers screaming at the top of his lungs. He’ll swear at Sullivan.

But as much as Hornqvist is loved by his teammates, he’s also a free agent after the season and should command plenty on the open market. Committing to Hornqvist in that spot could turn into a one-year thing.

Letang isn’t going anywhere. He’s one of the Penguins’ pillars, a group that’s down to three and searching for a fourth with Fleury gone.

Advertise with us

Given what Letang has been through — a stroke, concussions, you name it — who among the Penguins would ignore Letang when he felt like there was something that needed to be said?

The answer: Nobody.

Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.