Penguins Prospectus is an offseason project by Post-Gazette hockey writers Jason Mackey and Sam Werner that each weekday through Sept. 15 will examine 28 parts of the organization. Players and team personnel will appear according to when they played, coached or managed their first game with the Penguins, starting with Antti Niemi and ending with Sidney Crosby. For the full list of entries, click here.

Jim Rutherford, general manager

Age: 68

Date of Penguins debut: Oct. 9, 2014 (Hired June 6, 2014, after Ray Shero was fired)

Advertise with us

Notable 2016-17 transactions: Acquired Ron Hainsey in late February and Frank Corrado and Mark Streit at the trade deadline. Brought Matt Cullen back before the season, one of only a couple moves during a rare, quiet offseason that preceded a second consecutive Cup run. This offseason has been a mix of signings — Matt Hunwick and Antti Niemi, plus extensions for Conor Sheary and Brian Dumoulin — and key departures.

HAT TRICK (THREE KEY NUMBERS)

4: Active general managers since 1967 who’ve won three Stanley Cups. Along with Rutherford, Stan Bowman, Ken Holland and Lou Lamoriello are the others.

907: Games played by Ron Hainsey, acquired by Rutherford on Feb. 23, before he got a shot at the playoffs, which the Penguins provided.

12: Of 25 players used in the postseason by the Penguins who were Rutherford acquisitions.

Advertise with us

WHAT WE LEARNED

The summer of 2015 involved the marquee trade that made Phil Kessel a Penguin. Fast forward 12 months and ... not much of anything, really.

Rutherford was able to retain pretty much his entire team, but what he didn’t get to enjoy was a run of good health. Injuries, as have become the norm around here, hit the Penguins hard, especially on the back end when Kris Letang was hurt for much of the year.

The trade deadline gave Rutherford a chance to add some defensive depth, but there’s no replacing Letang.

So far this offseason, we’ve learned that Rutherford hasn’t had an easy time keeping key players around, though it’s been through no fault of his own.

Advertise with us

There’s a reason the Penguins have won. They have good players, guys other teams want. Hainsey, Trevor Daley, Chris Kunitz, Marc-Andre Fleury, Cullen and Nick Bonino will all work elsewhere next season. Rutherford is counting on younger players to step up and address those needs. Should that happen, cool. That’s how it’s supposed to work. But if it doesn’t, then the Penguins could potentially regress.

We’ve also learned that Rutherford isn’t going to be pressured into a deal when it comes to a third-line center. He’s in quite a staring contest with the rest of the league, one that has lasted the entire summer, and it will be interesting to see how and when it ends.

2016-17 HIGHLIGHT

This one isn’t a specific moment, more something that unfolded over a number of days, weeks and months. Also, it wasn’t so much a move Rutherford made as one he didn’t.

The highlight of Rutherford’s 2016-17 was very likely his decision to not trade Fleury. It would have been perfectly understandable for him to do so, especially at the trade deadline, knowing the Penguins wouldn’t go into the expansion draft with both Fleury and Matt Murray on their roster.

Advertise with us

But Rutherford didn’t like the possible return, and a deal was never consummated. It mattered when Murray was hurt with about 8 minutes to go before the start of the playoffs and Fleury was the Penguins’ best player through the first two rounds.

WHAT’S NEXT?

Because of Rutherford’s age, the retirement questions will continue, but all they’re going to do is elicit more terrific one-liners from someone who might have the best sense of humor in hockey.

Rutherford isn’t going anywhere. He’s also well-aware that, in a couple years, he’s going to need to shell out some bigger contracts — to Jake Guentzel and to pay Murray like an elite netminder, which he is — and has operated with the necessary prudence this offseason.

In the immediate future, Penguins fans are going to wonder what Rutherford’s doing with this extended wait to acquire a third-line center. The wait could stretch into the season, but there’s little doubt that, before a third consecutive postseason run, the Penguins will have to have someone in place.

Advertise with us

Rutherford also faces a few shakeups with his lieutenants and how the hockey operations staff conducts business. His new director of player development is Scott Young, replacing Mark Recchi. Meanwhile, Jason Botterill — Rutherford’s salary-cap expert the GM of the Penguins’ farm team in Wilkes-Barre — now is Rutherford’s equal, in Buffalo.

The Penguins didn’t backfill that position, and they also lost their director of amateur scouting, Randy Sexton, to the Sabres. Continuing to find and develop top-tier talent while also winning isn’t easy, but it’s something the Penguins have done remarkably well. It will be Rutherford’s goal to keep that going despite a few new faces in key places.

Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.