Penguins Prospectus is an offseason project by Post-Gazette hockey writers Jason Mackey and Sam Werner that each weekday through Sept. 15 will examine 28 parts of the organization. Players and team personnel will appear according to when they played, coached or managed their first game with the Penguins, starting with Antti Niemi and ending with Sidney Crosby. For the full list of entries, click here.
Ian Cole, defenseman
Shoots: left
Height/weight: 6-foot-1, 219 pounds
Age: 28
Date of Penguins debut: March 4, 2015 in a 3-1 loss at Colorado
How acquired: Via trade from St. Louis, in exchange for D Robert Bortuzzo and a seventh-round pick.
2016-17 stats: Had five goals and 21 assists in 81 regular-season games. Played in all 25 playoff games, with no goals and nine assists.
Contract situation: Entering final year of contract, with a cap hit of $2.1 million. Set to be an unrestricted free agent after the season.
HAT TRICK (THREE KEY NUMBERS)
26: Points for Cole, a career high.
194: Blocked shots by Cole this season, a Penguins’ record since the NHL began tracking the stat in 2005.
3.7: Increase in Cole’s Corsi For percentage (CF%) this season when playing with Justin Schultz vs. without Schultz, from 47.1% to 50.8%.
WHAT WE LEARNED
Ian Cole is willing to do whatever it takes to win and make himself a valuable part of the Penguins’ blue line.
Cole sacrificed his body again and again and again to stop shots from getting to the Penguins’ net over the course of this season and seemed to really solidify his role on the team in the process.
In many ways, Cole’s season mirrored that of his normal defense partner, Justin Schultz, even if their styles of play are very different.
Cole came into the year battling for playing time toward the bottom of the Penguins’ defensive rotation. But as he and Schultz were able to continue their strong play together from the 2016 Stanley Cup run, Cole saw his ice time start to creep up. By midseason, those two were effectively the Penguins’ best defense pairing.
Once the playoffs started, Cole’s steady, physical play became a real strength of a banged-up defensive corps. He led the league with 62 blocked shots in the postseason (including a whopping eight in Game 1 against Washington) and was a key cog on a Penguins penalty kill that often found itself in key situations
Whereas 2015-16 saw some speed bumps in Cole adjusting to Mike Sullivan’s system, this season he seemed to really effectively mesh his physical style with the Penguins’ up-tempo, puck-movement philosophies. He’s a bit different than just about every other defenseman on the Penguins’ roster, and this year he was able to make that an asset rather than a detriment.
2016-17 HIGHLIGHT
Even though Cole set career highs in offensive numbers, it wouldn’t really feel right to put an offensive highlight in this spot. The eight blocks in Game 1 against Washington are tempting, as that road win gave the Penguins a pretty significant mental edge to start off that series.
But instead, let’s go with a sequence that pretty much sums up Cole’s season, and his importance to this team: The Penguins’ 5-on-3 kill in the third period of Game 6 against Nashville. Cole came out to kill Olli Maatta’s initial tripping penalty but ended up staying on for more than two minutes, blocking a shot and killing 28 seconds of 5-on-3 to keep the game scoreless.
WHAT’S NEXT?
Cole’s immediate future certainly seems more secure than it did a year ago. He’ll start this season with a firm spot in the Penguins’ defensive rotation, likely paired with Schultz.
The Penguins defense lineup, with the addition of Matt Hunwick, is a bit hard to figure out of the gate, and will certainly bear watching in training camp, but right now Letang/Dumoulin, Cole/Schultz and Maatta/Hunwick seem like the most likely pairings, at least to start out.
If a guy like Derrick Pouliot makes a serious push for playing time (I know, I know. I said “if”), it’ll be interesting to see who the odd man out would be. A year ago, I would’ve said Cole. But he really seems to have firmed up a role on this team that makes him difficult to replace in the lineup.
Cole should make himself particularly valuable on the penalty kill, where he figures to be the anchor of a top unit that lost a good deal this offseason.
The bigger question for Cole might be whether or not he can establish some even-strength consistency with someone other than Schultz. Cole has really only been at his best when playing next to Schultz, which isn’t necessarily a knock on him — finding that sort of chemistry with a defense partner is rare and there’s no reason the Penguins shouldn’t try to ride it for as long as they can. But if Cole can develop that same kind of rhythm with, say, Olli Maatta, that would go a long way towards giving Sullivan and the Penguins some flexibility in their defensive lineup, especially as guys get hurt throughout the season.
Long-term, there’s a good chance this could be Cole’s last season in Pittsburgh. If he plays as well as he did in 2017, he’s probably due for a pretty hefty raise from the $2.1 million he’ll make this year (especially with the current going rate for NHL defensemen). Given the Penguins’ perennially precarious cap situation, there’s a really good chance he’s out of their price range next summer, especially as a guy who, for as well as carved out a niche this year, isn’t really a prototypical Mike Sullivan defenseman.
That said, though, Cole has certainly found a comfort zone in Pittsburgh, and that could make it a bit more enticing to take a small pay cut to stay. He wouldn’t be cheap, but if the Penguins don’t re-sign Patric Hornqvist, that’s $4.25 million more in cap flexibility. Plus, it’s not like the organization has a bevy of NHL-ready defensemen coming down the pipeline, so maybe they find a way to keep Cole in Pittsburgh beyond 2018.
Sam Werner: swerner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @SWernerPG





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.