Rick: Jason, thanks as always for interacting with us fans. Now after all the roster dust has settled and Cullen in MN, do you think JR regrets not signing Nick as 3C at the price Nashville paid? Hindsight is always 20-20 but would team like a "do-over" on letting him go? Or do you think that price is still too high for a 3C getting great matchups thanks to 87 and 71?
Jason Mackey: Hey Rick. My pleasure. I say this often, but it bears repeating: I absolutely love these things. It's mutual. ... Anyway, I don't think GMJR regrets the Bonino "miss" at all. I use quotes because on no planet was Rutherford comfortable going four years for that $$$. Maybe 1-2. But Rutherford told me -- and others -- at the time that he was wary of saddling the Penguins with bad contracts 3-4 years down the line. Made more sense to let Bonino walk.
Rahn: Is Will Butcher visiting the Penguins?
Jason Mackey: He is not. I reported a couple days ago that, barring something huge, they're not among the favorites to land him.
Rahn: We know about the prospects that are on the tips of most people's tongues: Sprong, Aston-Reese, Jarry, Adam Johnson and maybe Prow. Name a guy that scouts/personnel on the team are eager to see progress this year. My pick: Freddie Tiffels.
Jason Mackey: Good choice, Rahn. I won't argue. Have seen TIffels skate some this week in Cranberry. Looks very good. You might think I'm insane for this and maybe I am, but I'm starting to be convinced that maybe Derrick Pouliot figures it out this season as well.
Read More
Pat: Saw GMJR say he's considering giving Horny an extension? Surely that means we'd have to trade Kessel after next season if that's the case? Would be little to no cap space for the free agents.
Jason Mackey: I think it makes plenty of business sense to look at dealing Kessel after this season, provided he scores in a way that aligns more with what he's done throughout his career. I get they're 2 for 2 in Stanley Cups with Kessel here, but individually, he had his lowest goal output since, I believe, 2007-08. Why not wait another year, let Sprong and Aston-Reese knock down the door, then look to do something? And you're right: Money would get a little funky if they held onto Kessel for a number of years, but I really doubt they will. As for Hornqvist, he's a separate entity. The Penguins love what he brings, sure, but Hornqvist's agent could and probably should advise him to seek one last big payday via free agency. He'll have one heckuva resume built up by then, I know that.
Steven: Hi friend, as is the commonly asked question, any update on the timeline/targets for 3C?
Jason Mackey: Hi friend. No. Ha. I know that's the question everyone wants answered, and I totally understand why. Things are, to quote Mike Sullivan, status quo. Rutherford is shopping, waiting for a couple dominoes to fall around the league. Until they do, he's completely comfortable slow-playing thing, similar to what he did with Kessel. Truthfully, too, August is a very, very quiet period league-wide; many of his fellow GMs are on vacation.
#66: Can I come out of retirement to play PP and a few minutes on 4th line C? Problems solved!
Jason Mackey: Mario, let's be honest here: I think you would have a slightly greater role than that.
Joe: Jason, on the list that came out where a writer was speculating as to five centers the Pens are looking at, Nick Bjugsted was at the top. Do you agree that the Pens are interested in him? If so, a roster player will have to go to take on his $4.1 mil salary. Do you think JR is willing to shed a roster player to get a 3C he likes. You guys seem to think he doesnt want to trade someone off the roster.
Jason Mackey: Do I think they would be interested? Yes. Do I think it's realistic? No. Florida would be nuts to deal Bjugstad, in my opinion, and I don't care what the return would be. And heck, if they're dealing Bjugstad -- and pretty much setting fire to their season -- I think personally I would rather have Vince Trocheck. But again, I don't see Florida doing this. Is Rutherford willing to do? For the right player. I think he would prefer not to. And I think they can get away with only losing, say, Tom Kuhnhackl. But if there's a young guy with speed and offense with a friendly cap hit, etc., etc., I think Rutherford would be willing to talk. Maatta or Sheary would likely be the tradeable pieces.
Joe: Chances the Pens go into the season with Rowney as their 3C?
Jason Mackey: Not good, in my opinion. I think he's their 4C, but I think GMJR will do a deal -- at least one -- to get a legit 3C. If Rowney's your 3C, who's your 4C? That's scary, and there's a lack of depth immediately. You get a 3C, Rowney's your 4C, then you can see what you have with Blueger/Dea/Simon/etc.
Joe: Do you think JR has gotten himself between a rock and a hard place with the Pens center depth? There is not many prospects in the pipeline and he's been unable or unwilling to pull the trigger on a trade likely because everyone knows he needs a center and want overpayment from him. Did he play his hand wrong? Just seems to me he didnt have a good plan going in to replace Bonino
Jason Mackey: I don't. And if you want to call what GMJR has in front of him a rock and a hard place, then I think 30 other GMs would love to be between a rock and a hard place. I can't say too much here, but what I know I'm safe saying is this: Trust me, Rutherford absolutely has/had a plan. Was it to wait until September? Probably not. But sometimes that's what the market dictates. I think it would be a bigger crime to overpay now simply to say that he got someone. He's looking for the right fit, in a lot of areas. That doesn't always happen quickly.
Dan: Jason do you feel the Pens will make a "splash" in their effort for a number 3 center and realistically what would the cost be..i.e. Masts Sheary Number 1 all of the above or is it a fix type of player ?
Jason Mackey: I don't know if I'm cool with "splash" and No. 3 center in the same sentence, but do I think GMJR will get someone you've heard of? Yes. I don't believe he'll part with Maatta or Sheary, knowing what I know now. Of course, things can change, so I would never say never. But I don't think it's necessary at this point to get someone who fits.
Dan: Brian Dumoulin and Daniel Sprong to Boston for Sids buddy Brad Marchand...thoughts ?
Jason Mackey: Did you just pull three names out of a hat, or are you day drinking? Both are cool. Not judging. But those are my thoughts on that trade suggestion.
Guest: I've seen a lot of comments from reporters saying some players heights are listed "generously" or, once, flat out saying "maybe he's that tall when wearing skates". This seems to be related to players of shorter heights (obviously), like Sheary; is the same said of Sid or is he, in your best guestimate, actually 5'11"? Are the players over 6'0
Jason Mackey: I know what you mean. Although with Sheary being listed at 5-8, I think that's fair. Sid 5-11? I'm not a human tape measure, but I think that's fair, too. I remember Marty St. Louis being listed at something like 5-10 or similar and thinking, 'No way.' Even Guentzel. I have a tough time believing he's 5-11, 180 pounds.
copall: Think the Pens will offer a professional try out to any of the veteran players out there currently unsigned?
Jason Mackey: No, I don't. They're the two-time Stanley Cup champs. They don't need to go shopping at those stores, in my opinion.
Jimmy R: ZAR seems highly regarded yet I did not have much competition in signing him? What gives?
Jason Mackey: Part of it, I think, was how Zach knew he fit into the Penguins' system, in addition to their history with American-born college players. I remember talking to ZAR in a Philly hotel room -- by phone, of course -- after the deal was announced, and, man, I still think about how excited he sounded.
Schall: DK said you backstabbed Molinari in a chat. What is he talking about?
Jason Mackey: Knew this would come up. One, Dejan is wrong. As I tweeted, I don't make hiring or staffing decisions at the Post-Gazette. My bosses do, and I do what I'm told to the best of my ability. That's not a crime or "stabbing someone in the back." I also could never imagine my bosses feeling the need to comment on what DKPittsburghSports.com or the Tribune-Review do with their hiring and staffing decisions. I have the utmost respect for Dave. He's in the Hall of Fame. I grew up reading him. He's long been one of my idols and one of the primary reasons I got into this business. That he's doing more Penn State isn't at all my decision or my doing, and I respect Dave and the folks who make such decisions at the Post-Gazette too much to get into it here. I do hope that after Penn State finishes Dave will again have a voice on Penguins, but again, that's not going to be my decision to make.
Eugene M: When I return to the motherland each summer, why does Vlad let me escape yet again? Just curious.....
Jason Mackey: Eugene? That's a good one.
Mario: Who are the most likely candidates to get packaged in a trade for a 3rd center? Wilson, Kuhnhackl, Archibald, Rust, Maata, Cole? Which teams have the worst salary cap issues and might be willing to trade away a contract?
Jason Mackey: I don't think the Penguins would be willing to give up Rust in this sort of trade, although obviously I could be wrong. It also wouldn't provide them with much cap relief. ... The Leafs need a top-four D. It wouldn't net any cap relief, but I could potentially see Maatta-Bozak there. Or the Red Wings need cap relief. I wonder if the Penguins could pry Riley Sheahan from them?
King of the North: Who's tougher , Ryan Reaves or the Hound?
Jason Mackey: Reaves.
Birdie : Do you know how VGK can be seen in yo Ohio can't get answer from vegas an want to watch Fleury. Would appreciate any info thx
Jason Mackey: Hey BIrdie. If you buy the NHL package for your computer, that should include Vegas games.
Diego: Any news of Lukas Bengtsson, is he healthy to start the season?
Jason Mackey: Good question. I believe so, but I can't confirm 100 percent.
Bryan: Can ZAR play center? Any chance he can anchor the 3rd line?
Jason Mackey: He could. Or at least he did in college. They've developed him almost exclusively at wing, though. I could see them giving him a chance to do it in camp, but I think that's asking A LOT. Probably not something they should count on.
GMJR: Atta boy, Mackey. Talk up Pouliot. Maybe write a glowing article about him. Keep it up.
Jason Mackey: Just being honest, Jim. But thanks.
John: I head you mentioned zemgus girgensons for 3rd line center, was that speculation on your part or something you heard from your sources?
Jason Mackey: Speculation, to be perfectly honest. I would reported it and attributed to sources if that was the case. However, I think it's interesting from a hockey standpoint. Could work out with $$$ and the Rutherford/Botterill relationship.
dave: Do you think Frank Corrado has the potential to be a full-time NHL player?
Jason Mackey: I do, yes. However, as I understand it, I think he will benefit from more time developing. I don't think he's going to be ready to nail down an NHL job out of camp, but in January if something happens? I think he would be OK with that.
Kevin: There are many names we have heard in the third line center rumours. Any dark horse candidates in your eyes?
Jason Mackey: Two are names I already typed, but they're highly speculative: Sheahan and Girgensons. But, let's be honest, GMJR has a policy of not commenting on opposing players so names they're targeting are often tough to come by.
Steven: How far along the Butcher sweepstake did the Penguins get? Was it the lack of possible playing time this season that swayed him away?
Jason Mackey: I can't speak for what factored into the Butcher camp
Jason Mackey: 's decision, although I would think it has something to do with how prominent of a role he can have, not so much playing time. On a D with Letang, Dumoulin, Schultz and Maatta, he's only going to rise so far. They expressed interest, and talks were had. But nothing more than that.
Lukas: Are the Penguins looking to bring any players in on a PTO?
Jason Mackey: Not that I'm aware of. And I'd be surprised if they go this route given their success of late.
Lukas: Are there any players GMJR is trying to extend early before they hit FA next summer?
Jason Mackey: They haven't started yet, but a deal for Rust probably isn't far off. Aside from that, I have a tough time seeing Rutherford finish any other contracts. Or needing to for that matter. He could try with Hornqvist, but if I'm Hornqvist, I'm going to free agency and cashing out on one last big contract.
Derek: Sam Bennett, Ryan Spooner, and Drew Shore. What do you think about their potential fit as Pens 3C? Bennett and Spooner are both rumored to be on the block, and Dallas has about 5 capable top 9 centers (Seguin, Hanzal, Spezza, Faksa, Shore). All 3 are relatively cheap, young, and have some potential upside.
Jason Mackey: Believe it's Devin Shore, one. Two, I worry about Shore and Spooner and penalty killing. With Cullen and Bonino gone, this is absolutely something the Penguins have to address with any 3C acquisition. Bennett would be a good fit, in my opinion, although I'm not sure Calgary is ready to cut bait yet.
Brian: Do you see a hagelin or maata trade happening in order to make room for a 3rd line center coming our way? Also, do you feel that kessel/ hagelin will be gone after next year too make room for contracts later on such as rust, guentzel, hornvquist, cole? Thanks for taking the time!
Jason Mackey: I think trading Hagelin would be awfully tough given his limited offensive production this past season. I think Rutherford would prefer to keep his young assets here as a general rule. If Kessel and Hagelin have outstanding seasons, yes, I could see them getting traded. You don't want to do it with either right now because you're selling low. Do they need either in the long run with the number of young forwards they have coming up? Probably not.
Sven: Did the Penguins make any effort to sign Jussi Jokkinen this offseason? He seems like a bargain considering his production and what he signed with Edmonton for.
Jason Mackey: No, definitely not. Zero fit there.
Mario: Which teams are tightest on the salary cap and might be willing to trade a center to the Pens?
Jason Mackey: Detroit, maybe Dallas, maybe Toronto. That would be my top three anyway.
Derrick: Why do you suppose Butcher is not interested in the Penguins organization? I'm a biased fan, granted, but what could other teams have that the Penguins do not?
Jason Mackey: Ha. A solid top-four on defense that he would have a tough time cracking? I think that was probably the issue, honestly. How many prominent minutes would be available here.
Jerry: I have a strange feeling, Sutter will be returning as the third line center? Am I crazy?
Jason Mackey: I don't think you're crazy. I think it makes sense on a lot of fronts. However, Vancouver would have to take back money. There's no way the Penguins are going to pay $4.375 million for Sutter for the next four seasons. If they take back $1 million, maybe. Even that would be a little far-fetched. For both sides.
Mark: When will the Penguins visit the White House? Does it happen before the season starts, or on a trip to DC?
Jason Mackey: We don't know yet. Those plans typically aren't finalized until closer to camp.
Lukas: Any reclamation projects you see the Penguins targeting for 3C? Similar to Justin Schultz.
Jason Mackey: Honestly, no. I'm having a tough time coming up with one. My sense is that they want someone to come in and stabilize things there, whenever it does happen, not to be a work in progress.
Steve: Hi Jason, I haven't seen anyone ask this yet in any of your chats, but I'm wondering what the plans are for the third line center.
Jason Mackey: Well played, Steve.
Ryan: Do you think the pens should attempt to offer sheet Andreas athanasiou?
Jason Mackey: Not at all. Not worth it for that.
Jaromir Jagr: Hey man
Jason Mackey: Jags, you coming back? Please say yes.
Phil: Do you think hagelin or maata could be dealt for a 3rd line center? Bozak mainly im wondering
Jason Mackey: Everyone wants to trade Carl Hagelin, it seems. When you score six goals in 61 games and make $4 million ... that's not the most transferable situation. Maatta could go, but I really don't think that's the direction GMJR wants to go.
TK: I know you've covered both the Steelers and Pens during your career. Would you say that hockey players are easier to deal with than football players? To me, hockey players seem much more humble and down-to-earth.
Jason Mackey: I wouldn't say "easier" to deal with. They're just ... different. Hockey players are more humble, but that also means they're usually willing to say less; football players aren't afraid to have an opinion on matters and will probably more so resist the cliches. One thing I love about hockey takes the niceness and squares or cubes it: The culture around the sport. It's accepting of media and value our role. That more than anything, for me, makes hockey a ton of fun to cover. You're dealing with a bunch of good humans who love the game, respect it and want to see it do well.
Pete: Do you think ZAR or sprong will be in on opening night?
Jason Mackey: No, I don't. I think the best thing for either of them will be to develop a little bit more before coming up midseason.
Birdie : Did you get ? From birdie on VGK or should I resend
Jason Mackey: I got it. Check out NHL Center Ice. That should solve your problem.
Devyn: What would a Bryan Rust extension look like? Do you think the Pens re-sign him when the time comes?
Jason Mackey: Yes, I think they re-sign him. I'm not even going to guess on dummying that thing out. I'm not an agent.
Mark: Hi Jason - i know its early but which teams in the Esat present the biggest challenges to the Pens. Caps seems to have lost alot also and the Rangers made some strange moves. Thoughts!
Jason Mackey: Caps have made some strange moves, too. I like what Tampa did this offseason. I think Toronto will be right there as well. In the Metro, I like the Penguins to win it, but I think Columbus will be there along with the Rangers. I think the Hurricanes will take a sizable step forward. I know the Caps will be there, but how effective remains the biggest question for me. I still don't see them making it out of the second round.
guest: Hi Jason,
Jason Mackey: Hello.
John: Do you think A trade for 3rd line center will happen before training camp begins.
Jason Mackey: Maybe not before. But I do think before opening night they will have done something.
Mark: Am excited to see Ryan Reaves play against Tom Wilson of the Caps - maybe now he'll stop taking runs at the Pens. Thoughts?
Jason Mackey: I don't think Ryan Reaves is going to stop Tom Wilson from being Tom Wilson. But, yes, it should be an entertaining fight. And you know they will go first game.
Kevin: Coming in with one more, thoughts on Ryan Nugent-Hopkins availability and fit? Since Edmonton will soon be in a cap crunch and I saw an article saying Chiarelli is prepared to trade him below his trade value
Jason Mackey: I like the player, but I think $6 million per season, for that position, isn't a smart contract for the Penguins to take on.
guest: I loved your article on Matt Murray! That makes me pull for his continued success even more. He seems like a great kid!!
Jason Mackey: Thanks so much! Matt was a really good sport about all of it. I can't thank him enough for how candid he was. And yes, I agree with you: There's a really wonderful person in there, and I hope that came through in the piece.
Carl H: I could put up more points if I was on the right team. Is there a team out there who would trade for me?
Jason Mackey: Don't think so, Carl. And to be fair, you had plenty of opportunities in 2016-17.
TK: Do you think there's any friction between Kessel and Sullivan?
Jason Mackey: None at all. Does Phil require some extra effort? Absolutely. But Sullivan is no dummy. He knows what Phil can bring, and, like any good manager, he wants to get that out of him. Phil's just a different cat. It's one of the reasons why Tocchet was important. He's hardly a cancer or anything like that. He just doesn't have much of a filter, so the assistant acts as a buffer. But I know for a fact that Sullivan likes Kessel ... while also recognizing that he comes with his own set of challenges, the same as many great players.
Pope: Ok, now that all of the departures are mostly finalized and barring any trades for a 3C, what are your starting 4 lines on O?
Jason Mackey: Guentzel-Crosby-Sheary // Rust-Malkin-Kessel // Hagelin-3C-Hornqvist // Wilson-Rowney-Reaves. Note: That middle six is fairly interchangeable in my opinion.
Kevin: When we lost Kunitz, bonino, etc I was a little concerned. Now Cullen is gone & I'm really concerned. The difference between these pens & the pens that choked from 10-14 was an ability to control emotions & just play. Do you think they still have the leadership to turn the other cheek & stay focused with all the departures? I'd hate to see the retaliation garbage which is better left in the past
Jason Mackey: Absolutely they still have that. That much is attributable to Sullivan more than any one player. If you're concerned over losing Bonino and Cullen and replacing them with nobody, I get that. Or maybe the depth on defense with Daley and Hainsey gone. That's fair. But the mindset will, by all accounts, stay. Other guys will grow into those leadership roles.
Dino Ciccarelli: Who scores more regular season points in 2017-18? Penguins or Capitals? And does that team win the highly un-coveted Presidents Trophy?
Jason Mackey: I see the Penguins finished ahead of the Capitals in the regular-season standings. However, I don't see them winning the Presidents' Trophy. Because of injuries.
Lukas: Is renting Bozak really worth Maatta or would we get something else back in the trade?
Jason Mackey: I question whether Bozak would be worth it. It's one year. I don't love that. If I was GMJR, I would definitely insist on getting something else in the deal.
Steven: Could you shed some light on Jason Karmanos for me? His Eliteprospects page has him as the assistant GM in Carolina since 1998, but as he's only 42 now, that would have been an extremely young person to give that role to.
I believe when he came over with Rutherford from Carolina, he worked on an analytics department, and just moved into assistant GM as Botterill left. Do the Penguins have big plans for him given he's young and has plenty of experience?
Jason Mackey: Jason Karmanos is an extremely bright guy. Just saw him today, as a matter of fact. I think they absolutely view him as someone eventually capable of running him own team. For the time being, though, he handles a lot of analytics, yes, but also scouting and evaluation, the same as everyone. Jason knows Rutherford probably better than anyone on his staff. Granted Carolina wasn't a cap team while they were there, but Jason also did a lot of numbers-crunching down there. He can wear a lot of hats.
Lukas: Would Maatta and a pick for Kadri be a more balanced option?
Jason Mackey: It could. But why would Toronto do that?
Gary Bettman: September is here soon - are the NHL fans missing the World Cup of Hockey? Can we do it again soon?
Jason Mackey: Thanks, Gary. Honored you're participating in my chat.
Lukas: Would Andreas Athanasiou be a trade candidate or would Detroit rather see him off to the KHL for a year and keep his rights?
Jason Mackey: I'm not aware that the Penguins are thinking seriously about trading for Athanasiou.
Stella Blue: Are you excited for the regular season to begin? Seems like you probably didn't get a lot of down time.
Jason Mackey: Not a ton, but I'm not the type who functions well with down time. I love my job. My bosses probably think I'm nuts and maybe they're right. But I know that I run on a better speed whenever I'm active with this stuff. That said, I'll still get some time before the start of the season.
Brian: If you dont see maata or hagelin being moved then who do you see being moved for the 3c? Also chances on pens getting bozak?
Jason Mackey: I wouldn't peg them as good. For the deal the Penguins are probably best-served to make, you're looking at Wilson and Kuhnhackl. Or even nobody getting moved. I wouldn't rule that out, either -- keeping everyone on the NHL roster.
Brian: You know the top 9 has to be crosby, malkin, kessel, hagelin, sheary, guentzel, rust , hornvquist, (3c). But what will the 4th line look like ? Rowney, reaves , wilson/kunhackle? Or perhaps does archibalt move in to add speed?
Jason Mackey: I would go with Wilson, Rowney and Reaves. But, yeah, I'd be open to using Archibald. I like his game a lot. If they are somehow able to trade Hagelin, I'd be just fine replacing him with Archibald. They're similar players.
Jaromir Jagr: I've been working on face offs
Jason Mackey: Would be the greatest third-line center acquisition in the history of third-line center acquisitions.
Steve: Are you able to filter the questions you get here? Maybe take one or two questions about the third line center instead of 50?
Jason Mackey: I believe in answering everything I get -- as long as it's tasteful and not going to get anyone in trouble. If you take time out of your day to participate in this, and ask something respectfully, I'm going to answer it. I'm sorry it's been a bit third-line center heavy today.
Gus: Do you think a defenseman will be moved? Hard to have Letang, Schultz, Dumo, Maatta, Hunwick, and Cole all making above $2 million. Then you still have Ruhwedel and Pouliot + Corrado as extra options
Jason Mackey: I would be hesitant to do anything there because you don't know what you're getting with Pouliot and Corrado. They could be excellent, but that's no guarantee at this point. I see a very slim chance Maatta goes, but I have my doubts whether that's the best move to make.
Lukas: Toronto would trade Kadri for Maatta to strengthen their D and give more room to their rising stars up front. It would also save them a little bit of cap space which they'll be needing in the next few years.
Jason Mackey: I don't agree with you that Toronto would be willing to make that trade.
Kevin in Punxsy: I've seen a number of people mention that Wilson has played center before, in the AHL. Could he be the #3 center for the Pens?
Jason Mackey: In an emergency, maybe. But I don't think that's something the Penguins want to be counting on for any length of time. It's just too hard, especially with the PK responsibilities Wilson would inherit.
Joe Schmoe: Do you think there's enough water under the bridge now that Jagr will get his number retired when he hangs them up? He's certainly worthy.
Jason Mackey: Yep. I absolutely think that will happen. Believe Mario said it at the NHL 100, too.
Kevin in Punxsy: I've seen you mention Jagr returning to the Pens on numerous occasions. I don't see it! please provide your thoughts as to why it would be a great move on the part of the Pens. Thanks
Jason Mackey: I didn't mention it. I got asked about it. There's a difference. No way it's ever happening. In a million years. Do I want it to happen? Sure. It would be fun. But it makes zero sense.
Mark: I find it funny that so many fans want to trade away defensive depth for a center considering the state of the blue line during the last Cup run.
Jason Mackey: Fair point. Olli Maatta is an extremely polarizing figure among the fan base.
Lukas: Thanks for answering my questions! Until next time
Jason Mackey: Anytime, pal.
Steven: Scott Wilson never played C in the pro game. Blame EA NHL for that one listing him as a C for a long time.
Jason Mackey: Ha. I will. Although I do believe he has some background as a center growing up. But, again, it's way back. Not something he's going to do now for any length of time.
Jason Mackey: OK, folks. That's going to do it for today. Thanks so much for participating. I'm on vacation next week. Sam Werner's your guy. Be good to him ... and everyone else.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.