Because it’d be boring if all the Penguins did in the next week was retain their key free agents, it’s now time to talk about Matt Duchene.
Duchene, who spent last season circling the drain with the rest of the Avalanche after a career-high 30 goals in 2015-16, wants out of Colorado — as he should. Duchene had three goals and nine assists after the All-Star break, which directly coincided with his public mental prep-work to get moved. The Avs finished dead last in the league, then lost the draft lottery as badly as they could lose it.
So, given that Duchene is the Avs’ best, highest-paid player, trade talks have swirled for weeks. Enter, potentially, the Penguins, according to this bit from Sportsnet über-insider Elliotte Friedman:
Low-key Matt Duchene possibility: Pittsburgh. The Penguins have circled around him before. Both Glen Sather and Phil Jackson (before he decided to ruin the Knicks) talked about adding new players to championship teams. You prevent a staleness, and if the newcomer is popular, the group rallies around them so they can win, too. Everyone’s frustrated: Colorado GM Joe Sakic, Duchene and agent Pat Brisson. Could Olli Maatta plus more pieces get the Penguins into this?
OK, then. Here are some thoughts on all that.
1. Duchene is good. He wasn’t good last season, but that certainly seems like more of an indictment of the atmosphere than his own ability. The Avs were abysmal, and Duchene was on the trading block. He has to take some responsibility for the way it played out, but people are people. If you were working for a failing company that was looking to fire you, odds are you’d struggle a little, too.
Did he lick the stamp on the season? Probably. He’s also 26 years old and one of the fastest players in the league. He’s had fewer than 23 goals in a season exactly twice in his eight-year career. It’s probably best to chalk this up to circumstance and move on.
Read More
2. What would that mean for the Penguins’ hole at third-line center? That it’s filled, maybe. Duchene has ping-ponged between center and wing throughout his career. If you’re of the mindset that the Penguins are set with top nine wingers — and some combo of Phil Kessel, Jake Guentzel, Bryan Rust, RFA Conor Sheary, Patric Hornqvist, Carl Hagelin and Scott Wilson would seem like enough — Duchene as the 3C would make a lot of sense.
Then, remember that Nick Bonino, bigtime a playoff performer as he may be, is also a prime candidate to get overpaid. Bonino has averaged 0.46 points per game with the Penguins and was a consistent drag on possession in 2016-17. If he gets $4 million a year — which is eminently possible, given that he’s at worst the third-best option in free agency behind Joe Thornton and Martin Hanzal — the Penguins would be wise to thank him, shake hands and say “best of luck.”
The only real justification to paying Bonino that much, really, is that the potential options to replace him are so poor. Unless Duchene, who makes $6 million against the salary cap, is one of them.
3. Maatta could be a centerpiece for the Avs, but he wouldn’t be the whole package. Nor should he be. Maatta’s weak points are a matter of public knowledge; he continues to struggle with his footspeed, which overwhelms his hockey sense too often, and whether he’ll improve there is a valid question; skating isn’t generally an area where players, 23 years old or not, tend to get drastically better. It’s an easy thing to write off when a guy is young, cheap and has the “he wasn’t healthy” excuse. Maatta is still young — but he isn’t cheap ($4.08 against the cap through 2022), and the worst of his injuries are a) far enough in the rearview and b) unrelated enough to his skating to make you wonder.
So, if we’re spitballing, you have to assume it’d cost the Penguins something like Daniel Sprong and a first-round pick to get it done. As we heard ad nauseam after the Ryan Reaves trade, a late first-round pick is a crapshoot, and the Penguins’ overall goal for the next few years should be winning more Stanley Cups. Duchene furthers that goal to a significantly larger margin than Bonino, Sprong and a theoretical prospect.
4. How would they replace Maatta? That’s probably the trickiest question of all. Adding Duchene’s salary and shipping out Maatta’s would leave the Penguins with a little less than $17 million to sign Justin Schultz, Brian Dumoulin and Sheary (per Cap Friendly). It’s safe to assume that’ll cost about $10 million.
Then, they’d have to fill out the roster and, most importantly, find a viable left defenseman to take Maatta’s spot in the lineup behind Dumoulin and Schultz. The closest thing to in-house options they have are Cameron Gaunce, who’s a UFA, and Derrick Pouliot, who is Derrick Pouliot. Would they trust one of those guys? Would signing someone like Michael Del Zotto be a better bet?
Really, though, the bigger question is something we hit on earlier: Would the trade make the Penguins more equipped for a three-peat than currently constituted? Yeah, it would; Duchene is a significant upgrade on Bonino for what’s likely to be a minimal price, and Maatta has slid to the point where moving him out for a cheaper alternative wouldn’t be a bad idea on its own, let alone as part of Friedman’s package.
And hey, if nothing else, it’s something to talk about.
Sean Gentille: sgentille@post-gazette.com. Twitter: @seangentille





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.