As the Penguins spend these days and weeks celebrating their second consecutive Stanley Cup, they do so knowing that at least a few players key to both championship runs won’t be back in the locker room next season.
Five players who played in the final against Nashville will be unrestricted free agents this summer. One, Matt Cullen, is widely expected to retire. The other four — Nick Bonino, Chris Kunitz, Trevor Daley and Ron Hainsey — could very well be playing elsewhere next season.
The Penguins will get some salary cap relief when they clear Marc-Andre Fleury’s $5.75 million off the books, likely in the expansion draft. But they also have to negotiate deals with restricted free agents Justin Schultz, Brian Dumoulin and Conor Sheary, all of whom are expected to re-sign with the Penguins for healthy raises.
General manager Jim Rutherford knows the Penguins likely won’t have very much wiggle room with the salary cap, and that could lead to some tough conversations with the unrestricted free agents this summer.
“All the unrestricted free agents, I’ve met with them and told them that we’re not going to close the door on any of them,” Rutherford said. “But with the cap the way it is, it’s tight fitting guys in. We’re not going to be able to fit everybody in.”
Essentially, Rutherford said he told the unrestricted free agents they should test the waters on the open market once free agency starts July 1. Then, if they want to come back to Pittsburgh, bring those offers back to Rutherford and see how close the Penguins can come from a financial perspective.
Read More
“Come back and say, ‘Here’s what we’ve got. Can you get to that number? Can you get close to that number?’ ” Rutherford said. “Then they can make a decision.”
Both Kunitz and Bonino — the only two of the four who spoke at the team’s locker clean-out day Thursday — expressed interest in at least trying to strike a deal with the Penguins.
“I think I’ve made it pretty plain, I love Pittsburgh, love the team here,” Bonino said. “We’ll see if we can get something done.”
Bonino, 29, may be the toughest of the four for the Penguins to bring back. His previous contract brought just a $1.9 million annual cap hit, but he’ll almost certainly get free agent offers that more than double that. If a team is willing to offer Bonino a long-term deal north of $4 million a year, that might be more than the Penguins can comfortably swing.
Bonino admitted that, from a pure winning perspective, it’s hard to beat the situation in Pittsburgh. But as a guy who has been traded three times in his NHL career, he’s looking forward to having some options for the first time.
“You take everything into account,” Bonino said. “Family, team, money. I think at the end of the day, I’ve never been in a situation to choose where I play, which is nice as a player. For most of our careers, we don’t have much say in that. The chance to choose is obviously alluring, but there’s a reason that we have 14 days here to see what happens. Like I said, I really like it here.”
Kunitz, too, said he planned to keep his options open over the next few weeks. Well, except for one.
At 37, there was some thought Kunitz could opt to retire after back-to-back Cups, but he emphatically shut that down Thursday.
“I feel pretty good out there, to be able to go out and compete and have fun,” he said. “I’d be extremely disappointed if that wasn’t going to go forward.”
If Kunitz does end up coming back to the Penguins, it would likely have to be on a short-term, relatively low-money deal — similar to the one-year, $1 million contract Cullen had this season.
Other teams could sweeten that pot by offering more years, more money or a bigger role. But Kunitz doesn’t sound like he would leave Pittsburgh just because another franchise tried to sell him on a second-line role.
“People can always promise you the world,” he said. “You never know if it’s going to turn out unless you go out and perform. I don’t think that the grass is always greener on the other side. You have to go out there and understand it’s a change. Going somewhere else, it’s going to be a different world than you’ve been extremely accustomed to the last nine years.”
Kunitz said his comfort level in Pittsburgh is “through the roof,” and that will certainly be a factor in his decision-making process.
“It’s something that you have to definitely think about,” he said. “It’s not about whoever’s going to come calling, it’s about how it’s going to fit for you and your family and life going forward.”
Kunitz also has one very important backer hoping for his return to Pittsburgh. Captain Sidney Crosby said Thursday he was “trying to think positive” that Kunitz, his long-time linemate, will be back next year.
“He’s the ultimate teammate, for a lot of different reasons,” Crosby said. “The way he treats people. The way he handles himself. The way he plays every single night. I think that’s no fluke that he’s won four Stanley Cups.”
The two defensemen ready to hit the market, Daley and Hainsey, seem poised to be moving on this summer. Daley, 33, will probably receive offers for one more long-term contract, which the Penguins wouldn’t be able to match. Hainsey, 36, will also likely be able to get a better late-career contract elsewhere.
Those two guys weren’t with the Penguins for very long — Daley for one and a half seasons, Hainsey for only half a year — but for all these pending free agents, it’s still tough to say goodbye.
“It’s going to be tough to see guys go,” defenseman Ian Cole said. “Unfortunately that is the business side of things. We know that, but I think looking back you can look back on pretty fond memories of what we have accomplished. We’ll be seeing each other for the Cup reunions, so that’ll be a plus.”
Sam Werner: swerner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @SWernerPG





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.