There are a couple of numbers that Guy Costa, the city of Pittsburgh’s chief operations officer and longtime crowd estimator, would like to emphasize.

Number of Pittsburgh Penguins Stanley Cup championships: 5.

Number of arrests at Wednesday’s Stanley Cup parade: 0.

Then there is one that is “just a number”: 650,000, also known as the number of people the city says attended that parade.

Advertise with us

“We know we didn’t have a million, we knew we didn’t have 200,000, and we knew we had more than last year,” he said Thursday. “So it was a guesstimate.”

Estimating crowds is difficult, which is why the National Park Service has been prohibited from doing so by Congress since 1995, when it pronounced that only 400,000 had attended the Million Man March.

It is a topic debated in scholarly journal articles, with talk of grid systems, remote sensing, satellite imagery and photo angles.

“There are ways to scientifically figure it out,” said Mr. Costa, “but when you’re dealing with Downtown Pittsburgh, it’s kind of difficult. We had people in every nook and cranny along the way.”

So what does the city do? Mr. Costa walks along the parade route and “every once in a while,” counts how deep the crowd is. A member of the Penguins organization who was in the parade counted as well. At one point on Grant Street, Mr. Costa said, he counted the crowd to be 30 to 40 people deep on one side of the street and 15 to 20 people deep on the other side. They also account for people packed into public plazas, people in parking garages and people in Point State Park.

Advertise with us

They then use a figure of 2 square feet per person to come up with a number — say, 650,000.

A little math indicates that along a 1.2-mile parade route, 650,000 people at 2 square feet per person equates to a crowd 102 people deep on each side of the route.

Yes, children take up less room. No, that calculation doesn’t account for toddlers on their parents’ shoulders. Or people on top of buildings. Or hanging off parking garages. Or massed in Point State Park. Or standing on a dump truck.

“I don’t think anyone can come up with an accurate number,” said Mr. Costa. “I can confirm it’s the largest crowd ever.”

Critiquing crowd estimates is a time-honored tradition, from the presidential inaugurations to Tiananmen Square to right here in Pittsburgh. In 1991, the city held a parade in June for veterans returning from the Gulf War and estimated that 250,000 people attended. "I don't believe 250,000 were at the parade,” then-city councilman Gene Ricciardi told the Pittsburgh Press. “Maybe if you add the viewers who watched it on TV."

Advertise with us

The city estimated last year’s Stanley Cup parade at 400,000. “We had people where we didn’t have them last year,” said Mr. Costa, noting that the parade route was also longer, and allowed for people to gather in Point State Park.

And Stanley Cup parades tend to be bigger than Super Bowl parades because they are in the summer, he said, when the weather is more hospitable and many kids are out of school. “It’s more of a family event,” he said. “A lot of parents brought their kids to work. It was a big family day.”

With talk of a three-peat, is there a limit on how much parade attendance might rise? Sure. At least there is elsewhere.

“We didn’t overexaggerate,” said Mr. Costa. “We weren’t like Cleveland. Cleveland said they had a million people” after the NBA championship last year.

Anya Sostek: asostek@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1308.