Now that Sidney Crosby has secured his third Stanley Cup title and second Conn Smythe Trophy, the conversation has turned to his place in the pantheon of great athletes.
Two questions have dominated thus far:
1. Is Crosby the best Penguin ever? (Paul Zeise thinks so.)
2. Is Crosby one of the greatest NHL players ever? (Yes, if you ask Ron Cook.)
Those history-centric questions have obscured another, more modern query: Is Crosby officially the best player in North American professional sports?
That is to say, of the top players in the main four professional team sports leagues — the NBA, NFL, MLB and NHL — where does Crosby rank?
(For this exercise, the underlying assumption is that Crosby is the best player in the NHL, which, given his accomplishments, is not exactly a stretch.)
The best players in the NBA and NFL are easy to identify: Cleveland Cavaliers star LeBron James has held that title for a decade, and New England Patriots quarterback Tom Brady erased any doubts about his dominance during Super Bowl LI.
Baseball is a bit trickier, because postseason success is less dependent on the transcendence of one particular player. The crown would probably go to Los Angeles Angels center fielder Mike Trout, though he would be squarely at the bottom of this list of four given that he has yet to win his first playoff series.
The real competition here is between Crosby, James and Brady for the title of Best Player in North American Professional Sports.
Let’s lay out their resumes and see how they stack up against each other:
LeBron James, age 32

• 2004 Rookie of the Year
• Three-time NBA champion
• Three-time NBA Finals MVP
• Four-time NBA MVP
• 13-time All-Star
• 11-time All-NBA First Team
• Five-time ALL-NBA Defensive First Team
• 2008 NBA scoring champion
• Two-time AP Athlete of the Year
• Two-time Sports Illustrated Sportsperson of the Year
Tom Brady, age 39

• Five-time Super Bowl champion
• Four-time Super Bowl MVP
• Two-time NFL MVP
• Two-time NFL Offensive Player of the Year
• 12-time Pro Bowl selection
• Two-time First Team All-Pro
• Two-time NFL passing yards leader
• 2009 NFL Comeback Player of the Year
• 2005 AP Athlete of the Year
• 2005 Sports Illustrated Sportsperson of the Year
Sidney Crosby, age 29

• Three-time Stanley Cup champion
• Two-time Conn Smythe Trophy-winner
• Two-time Hart Memorial Trophy-winner (MVP)
• Three-time Ted Lindsay Award-winner (Peer-voted MVP)
• Two-time Maurice Richard Trophy-winner (Goals leader)
• Two-time Art Ross Trophy-winner (Points leader)
• Six-time NHL All-Star
• Three-time Lionel Canadian Press Conacher Award-winner (Canadian male athlete of the year)
• Two-time Olympic Gold Medalist
• 2016 World Cup of Hockey Gold Medalist, Leading Scorer and MVP
Those are three unassailable, impressive resumes. A few things jump out immediately.
Crosby is obviously younger than James and significantly younger than Brady, putting his achievements this early in his career into more perspective.
His injury history is probably what prevented him from making more NHL All-Star Teams and racking up more individual honors.
The Penguins’ captain also has more international accomplishments than either James or Brady, though it is worth mentioning that James helped lead Team USA to gold medals in the 2008 and 2012 Olympics, and there aren’t many international football competitions.
The one factor not listed here is each player’s history of losing. For example, in addition to his three championships, Crosby lost to the Detroit Red Wings in the 2007-08 Stanley Cup Finals.
Brady lost to the New York Giants in two separate Super Bowls, one of the strangest aberrations on any legendary players’ resume. James has lost five times in the NBA finals, which is the main counterpoint to the argument against him versus Michael Jordan as the best NBA player ever.
That black mark on his resume also is why Crosby has officially jumped him on this particular list. Crosby’s earned accolades are comparable to James’ at this point in The King’s career, and at this moment in history, his playoff record is less marred than James’.
But Crosby has a little more work to do to leapfrog the GOAT, aka Brady. The man is currently in the conversation for being the greatest ever at the most valuable position in sports, and it is really hard to argue against those five rings.
Of course, if Brady finally begins to show his age and Crosby continues winning, then we will have ourselves a serious debate as early as next summer.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.