FORWARDS

There were times throughout the playoffs when the Penguins’ big-name forwards — Evgeni Malkin, Sidney Crosby and Phil Kessel – needed to come through, and more often than not, they did. It’s no coincidence that they finished 1-2-3 in the postseason scoring race, or that Crosby was named playoff MVP. Rookie winger Jake Guentzel led the playoffs with 13 goals, and blue-collar forwards such as Matt Cullen, Nick Bonino and Scott Wilson, among many others, produced solid efforts on a regular basis. And in case anyone had forgotten, Bryan Rust gave regular reminders that he does his finest work in high-stakes games.

Grade: B+

DEFENSEMEN

Advertise with us

You can’t win a Cup without a stud defenseman. That was the conventional wisdom before these playoffs, anyway. Well, with Kris Letang sidelined because of neck surgery, the Penguins put that logic through the shredder. Justin Schultz was the closest thing they had to a go-to guy on the blue line, and he’s more of a complementary guy than a cornerstone. Didn’t matter, though, because this unit consistently was better than the sum of its parts. Sure, just about everyone on the defense had some bad games along the way, but they also did more than anyone could reasonably have expected. And they’re going to get rings to show for it.

Grade: B

GOALIE

Matt Murray didn’t allow a goal during the final two games against Nashville, but the Penguins might never have gotten anywhere near the final if Marc-Andre Fleury hadn’t performed so well after Murray was injured during warm-ups before Game 1 of the first round. Between them, Murray and Fleury went 16-9 and recorded five shutouts. Whether Fleury deserved to lose the starting job when he did likely will be debated for a while, but Murray’s work the rest of the way makes it hard to second-guess coach Mike Sullivan’s decision.

Grade: A

Advertise with us

SPECIAL TEAMS

The Penguins surely would have liked to get a power play or two in Game 6 against Nashville, but the referees didn’t see it that way. Nonetheless, they scored on 20.5 percent of their chances with the extra man during these playoffs, which is a reasonable conversion rate. The penalty-killers had a pretty ordinary success rate of 83.6 percent, but usually seemed to come through in the clutch. Game 6 was a great example of that, as the Penguins killed all four of the Predators’ power plays, including a five-on-three, in what clearly was developing as a low-scoring game.

Grade: B+

COACHING

Sullivan and his staff surely had a few missteps over the course of four rounds, but they were neither numerous nor significant. It’s impossible to quantify, but Sullivan seemed to push the right buttons just about every time he had to make a personnel decision or tactical adjustment. Exhibit A: Sunday night, he gambled by using his timeout after the Penguins were guilty of consecutive icings late in second period, with the goal of getting tired players some rest. He lost the ability to challenge plays for the rest of the game, but his team needed that rest more than it needed a challenge that, as it turned out, never would have been used.

Advertise with us

Grade: A

Dave Molinari: Dmolinari@Post-Gazette.com and Twitter @MolinariPG