The Penguins-Predators Stanley Cup final unfortunately is turning into something of a referendum on advanced hockey analytics.

Popular new-school metrics like Corsi and Fenwick say the Predators have been the better team through two games as they’ve dominated possession, shot attempts and the like.

The scoreboard, obviously, is telling a different story, as the Penguins have been opportunistic to outscore Nashville, 9-4, in the aggregate to take a two games to none lead as the series shifts to the Music City for Game 3 Saturday at Bridgestone Arena. This after they’ve been outshot and out-possessed more than a few times in the playoffs, especially by top-seeded Washington.

Consequently, the true believers in the so-called “fancy stats” are taking something of a beating. If they’re so smart, how have the Penguins made it this far, the skeptics ask?

Advertise with us

The simple answer — and this is something we should be able to wrap our minds around in 2017 — is that big-picture statistical trends tend not to manifest themselves very well in two games or even a short series of seven maximum games.

Consider: The Chicago Cubs were baseball’s dominant team last season with a 102-58 regular-season record, and FiveThirtyEight.com’s statistical models still gave them just a 26 percent chance to win the World Series at the outset of the playoffs. Of course, they ultimately did, beating the Cleveland Indians in seven thrilling games. But the odds of it happening, according to number-crunchers, weren’t a whole lot better than their name getting picked out of a hat with the names of the playoff field of 10.

The reason is that randomness reigns the further a sample size is compressed. As it was, those Cubs had a period in late September when they lost four out of six to the St. Louis Cardinals and lowly Milwaukee Brewers.

That didn’t affect their perception as the World Series favorite for good reason. Six games account for just 3.7 percent of the schedule. We had lots of other data points to prove that the Cubs were, in fact, pretty good at point.

The postseason, however, structurally removes the volume of data points necessary to weigh too much in the outcome. It creates an environment in which a single home run or gorgeous save by a goalie can have a disproportionately larger impact on a game and thus a series than it might in the regular season.

Advertise with us

Such as it was with the Penguins and the Capitals. Such as it is with the Penguins and Predators.

We have a cultural obsession with the idea of the postseason being the ultimate test, regardless of sport. It’s why all of our major pro leagues have playoffs when English Premier League soccer, for example, decides its championship entirely with regular-season results. It’s why we have sports debate shows that boil seemingly every argument down to “How many rings?”

This is not a problem, in and of itself. As we just established, postseasons are such statistical maelstroms that every championship is its own miracle. It’s natural to get caught up in the drama of that, and it’s natural to judge great players and teams by how they perform in those thunderdomes over time.

It’s just stupid to apply that same level of scrutiny to stats-based projections. Their job is to tell us what’s more likely to happen. Not what will happen.

Right now, they’re telling us the Penguins have bucked some unfriendly odds with a couple spellbinding sequences of goals amid generally excellent Nashville defense.

Advertise with us

This is fine.

It doesn’t invalidate their run as lucky. It doesn’t mean that analytics are BS. It just means that the impact of their big plays have been amplified by a format designed to do exactly that.

Adam Bittner: abittner@post-gazette.com and Twitter, @fugimaster24.