There are plenty of reasons the Penguins are two wins from another Stanley Cup. Jake Guentzel’s presumed stint in the bacta tank is toward the top of the list. So, too, is the fact that the Predators are playing without their best forward.

You shouldn’t kid yourself, though; the reason we’re headed to Nashville in this particular situation is, largely, because of one guy. Pekka Rinne, after three rounds’ worth of Conn Smythe-caliber play in net, has turned into a pumpkin. A yellow, Finnish pumpkin, but a pumpkin all the same.

How do you follow up, literally, the worst statistical game ever by a goaltender who didn’t get pulled? Play poorly enough to get pulled. That was Rinne on Wednesday night during the Penguins’ 4-1 Game 2 win. He came unglued over 3:28 of the third period, watched a 1-1 game balloon into a three-goal deficit, then got the hook. In came 22-year-old backup Juuse Saros to mop up.

“They made the most in that time frame and got themselves a lead,” Predators coach Peter Laviolette said.

Advertise with us

Penguins coach Mike Sullivan called it “an inner belief that we can score goals.” True against anyone — and certainly true against Rinne.

It’s easy for the Penguins to survive a defense whose best breakout option is “throw the puck to the middle of the ice and hope” when the other goalie allows four goals on six scoring chances. It’s easy for them to survive getting their heads caved in at 5-on-5 that way, too. The Penguins capitalizing on their chances — the third-period eruption doesn’t happen if they can’t exploit bad pinches and win puck battles — but the pucks that beat Rinne were all, to varying degrees, saves he should’ve made.

“When you lose a couple games and get pulled, you’re not happy about how things went,” Rinne said. “But you have to put those things behind and focus on the things you can control, and that’s Game 3.”

Blame the rest of the Predators for helping make the Penguins’ chances high-quality. Credit the Penguins for earning them. Nashville’s skaters, to a man, are taking more than their share of the blame. The respect they have for Rinne is obvious; defenseman Roman Josi said they take it personally when Rinne gets pulled. Ryan Ellis said the same.

“That’s 100 percent accurate. I’ve said it three times now — it’s not what Pekks is doing,” Ellis said. “It’s our team. It’s the guys in front of him.”

Advertise with us

Captain Mike Fisher, twice, said they “had to be better” for Rinne. “There’s no question. We know we can be,” Fisher said. “There’s just a few breakdowns in a few minutes of a couple games. That’s been the difference.”

So, sure, the Predators gifted a great team a few prime chances. If the prime chances still lead to stoppable pucks, though, it’s the goalie’s job to ... stop them.

And Rinne, for all his greatness in this postseason and those three Vezina finalist nods, has a lot of poor hockey in his recent past. An outstanding March was preceded by an .888 save percentage in February. Last season, he put up a .908 over 66 games and allowed more goals than any other goalie in the league. In 2013-14, he was at .902. In 2012-13, .910.

This isn’t just about his struggles against the Penguins (though that has to be noted, too. It’s a 10-game sample, but his .865 career save percentage against them is 31 percentage points worse than the next contender. The Penguins have made a lot of goalies look bad over the last 10 years, but he takes the cake).

That said, more than anything, this is about a career .919 goaltender regressing to the mean in spectacular fashion after a few hot weeks. Add up his career, and you’ve got three outstanding seasons counterbalanced with some real messiness. We all should’ve known something like this was at least feasible.

Advertise with us

Jake Guentzel, teammates discuss his Game 2 performance

The bright side for Nashville, if there is one, is that Rinne is capable of swinging back in the other direction. He’s clearly capable of greatness. Ask the Chicago Blackhawks, the St. Louis Blues and the Anaheim Ducks about that. The issue for Laviolette, though, is that he’s almost out of runway.

There’s no time to wait for Good Pekka Rinne to reappear; part of that is because of Saros, who’s young but highly regarded and had a .923 save percentage in 21 appearances. Laviolette, while praising Rinne’s body of work, had two opportunities to commit to him for Game 3 and opted out.

Most of all, if the Predators take heart in the way they’ve played for 95 percent of the series, they should also realize the likelihood of the Penguins continuing to play this poorly is really, really low. We’ve seen Sullivan push the right mid-series buttons too many times not to expect something better, and soon.

And even if that doesn’t come to pass — if the D-corps is too limited to create sustainable possession and Sullivan’s team has to survive on mistakes — then the question turns into: Why should we expect anything better from Rinne?

Sean Gentille: sgentille@post-gazette.com, Twitter: @seangentille.

Advertise with us

Love our Pens coverage? Consider subscribing.

Support journalism. Subscribe today.