FORWARDS
Pro hockey is a bottom-line business and the Penguins won the game, but there is no excuse – or adequate explanation – for going 37 minutes without a shot, as they did for all of the second period and most of the third. In the process, they squandered a 3-0 lead, only to be saved when Jake Guentzel scored his league-leading 10th – and first since Round 2 – with 3:37 left in regulation. The Penguins entered the series with an obvious advantage at center and got three goals and three assists from guys at that position, but generating 12 shots barely is adequate for a period, let alone a game.
Grade: D
DEFENSEMEN
The Penguins only allowed one even-strength goal, but it had the potential to be a costly one. With the Penguins protecting a 3-2 lead – and barely remembering their most recent shot on goal – Nashville’s Austin Watson worked free from Olli Maatta behind the goal line and set up Frederick Gaudreau for the tying goal. All told, though, the defense held up reasonably well, considering that most of the game was played in its end. Trevor Daley, making his Stanley Cup final debut, accounted for four of the Penguins’ nine shot-blocks.
Grade: C
Read More
Love our Pens coverage? Consider subscribing.
Support journalism. Subscribe today.
GOALIE
Matt Murray finished with 23 saves and, while it hardly was an onerous workload, he was called upon to do a lot more than his Nashville counterpart, Pekka Rinne. He was shaken up when teammate Ron Hainsey fell on him during a goalmouth scramble in the first period, but stayed in the game. Murray didn’t record a shot on goal, but neither did 10 of the guys who played in front of him. The key difference: Murray wasn’t expected to.
Grade: C
SPECIAL TEAMS
The Penguins produced one of the most wretched five-on-three power plays in hockey history … until Evgeni Malkin hammered a slap shot past Rinne at 15:32 of the first period, 102 seconds into their two-man advantage. He scored on the Penguins’ only shot during that time. That was the only one of three power plays on which they scored, though, and Nashville got its first two goals while Ian Cole and Malkin were in the penalty box, serving penalties that appeared to be unnecessary.
Grade: D
COACHING
Mike Sullivan and his staff made some important decisions, like dressing Guentzel instead of Carl Hagelin when a spot in the lineup had to be cleared for Patric Hornqvist, but video coach Andy Saucier made the most important call of the game when he told Sullivan to challenge a goal Nashville’s P.K. Subban scored at 7:13 of the opening period. A video review determined that Nashville winger Filip Forsberg had been offside – barely – and the Predators lost a goal that would have put them in front in a game they had dominated to that point. Sullivan reconfigured his lines several times when they couldn’t generate a shot on goal, but it seemed to make no difference.
Grade: C
Dave Molinari: Dmolinari@Post-Gazette.com and Twitter @MolinariPG
On the Clock: Good Predators defense or bad Penguins offense?





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.