Andy: This series reminds me of Boston in 2013. Pens trying to play a more open offensive game that they can't play because the opponent is playing defense too well, and they are getting frustrated. Sully has ńo answers just like Bylsma lacked then. Why not just play tough defense first, and try to get bounces for a transition offense when the Ottawa is out of position? In other words, play their own game against Ottawa. Let the Sens attack first. It's not the Pens game but then I don't see them winning this series trying to go on the offensive attack first without the speed and tenacious forechecking they are lacking from last season, Thoughts?
Jason Mackey: The Penguins won the Stanley Cup last year and finished as the NHL's second-best regular season team this year because of their ability to play a speed-based, aggressive game. Why change? They're not going to. I disagree with the comparison to Boston in 2013; this team is much, much deeper, with the stars performing better. In Game 7 against Washington, Mike Sullivan made several adjustments that had a tangible effect. Now, he can't? I'm also not buying that argument. The Penguins do need to play more of their game than Ottawa's.
Andy: Jason, Crosby has not looked the same since the Niskanen hit. He's not going to the high traffic areas and he looks like he's playing more tentative. Noticeable drop off. Do you agree and has anyone asked him about it?
Jason Mackey: Nobody has asked him about it, and I wouldn't expect him to admit that's been the case -- that would essentially be throwing the Penguins' entire medical operation under the bus, plus absolving himself from any sort of blame. However, I do agree that Crosby has looked different and hasn't been the same player he was before the hit. I don't know if they're related. We probably won't until after the season, if then.
Guest: Is there anything Sullivan can do to win this series? I'm not being negative after just one game but I don't think the Pens can win this series the way they have been playing the last three games, getting only one goal a game. Their luck with mediocre goalies from the first two rounds has run out. What did the Rangers do to get 4 and 5 goals over four games against Anderson? We need some other strategies
Jason Mackey: Can Mike Sullivan play defense and cover the forward at the far post? Can Sullivan win one-on-one battles and come out of the corner with the puck? Can Sullivan make it seems like his skaters give a flying you know what at the drop of the puck? He can maybe do the last one, but I don't think the Penguins have been horrible at the skate because Sullivan isn't preparing them or approaching his job with the same intensity. This is a player-related problem.
Read More
Guest: I know a lot of the media calls last night was not to replace MAF for Friday's game. But I think Sullivan should replace him, or because he won't bounce back or because he played horribly, but just because MM plays much calmer back there and the visibly frustrated with the Sens. What do you think?
Jason Mackey: I'm not sure I saw one media member call for Fleury to be replaced, nor do I think it's the correct move. MAF has earned the right to start Game 4. If he stinks at the beginning, then I think it would be perfectly reasonable to yank him, and then all bets are off moving forward. But the guy got you this far. He was OK, and the team in front of him was lousy. Not enough, in my opinion, for the guy to lose the starting job.
Guest: Do you think we'll see Rust, Hornqvist and Schultz playing on Friday? They are sorely missed. Do any of the injuries seem worse than the initially appeared?
Jason Mackey: They don't, and I think you will. I watched all three skated yesterday, and all three were really pushing it, Hornqvist chief among them. I would not be shocked if all three play. With Rust, I don't have this confirmed, but I've seen no signs that would point me to a concussion. More a neck issue. Which is at least marginally better in terms of recovery.
Guest: Reason for the Pens' failure to score goals in this series in your estimation and the reason they are losing: 1) pens own injuries or exhaustion, and failure to play "their (speed) game" at a high level; 2) Pens are being out coached including Sully's failure to put together workable lines for both forwards and defense; or 3) it's mostly Ottawa outplaying the Pens, playing great defense and with a hot goaltender?
Jason Mackey: That's like a nine-pronged question. I do think injuries and exhaustion are real. I also think you're asking Chad Ruhwedel and Mark Streit to play in situations they're not suited for; they could be in over their heads. Workable lines? I honestly don't know what else I would do or could do if I'm Sullivan. Where is the magic formula that he's resisting? As I said above, they have played more of Ottawa's game than their own, I'll agree with that. And it has to change. Much like Game 7, I think the Penguins have gotten away from their aggression. They need more speed away from the puck and to simplify things. Ottawa's packing it in. It's not going to be pretty. Shoot it a lot. Get a ton of traffic. That's not happening, and it won't be remedied by different line combination.
copall: Jason, my main concern for the Pens going forward is their inability to win stick battles in front of Anderson. He gave up some juicy rebounds off of shots from the point, but no one from Pittsburgh was in a position to take advantage. How can the Pens generate a stronger net-front presence?
Jason Mackey: Good question. Might be the question that ultimately determines this series. I'll start with the obvious: They need to go there. Winning stick battles is great, but that's running. The Penguins need to walk first. There isn't enough of an urgency, in my opinion, to penetrating the insulated approach Ottawa takes in front of Anderson. Passing the puck and shooting it from distance won't do squat unless Anderson is abjectly terrible, which he has not been. There's honestly not wrong way here. Go to the net. Get in the way. Win stick battles. Hit somebody. Get in the way. Cause chaos. Whatever.
Guest: Jason, uhhhhh what happened last night?
Jason Mackey: Not to spoil it for anyone who hasn't flipped through their DVR, but the Penguins lost, 5-1.
Guest: I was sad to see that Chris Cornell died yesterday. He was the lead singer for Soundgarden and I know that you've expressed your fandom of the Grateful Dead and ICP in this chat, but did you ever follow the grunge scene back in the 90s? Favorite Soundgarden song or memory? THanks.
Jason Mackey: I did, for sure. Never disliked Soundgarden but was also not a fanatic like some, including my wife. Would go with "Fell on Black Days." Favorite Cornell tune period would be Audioslave's "Doesn't Remind Me."
PENS: is scoresese really making a Grateful Dead documentary? about time!
Jason Mackey: He is. There's also one coming out June 2. Not sure if that's it or not. Just saw something about a documentary out then.
7 sTEELERS: Jason, I'm gonna keep this simple...WHAT THE [BLEEP] HAPPENED LAST NIGHT?!?!?!?!
Jason Mackey: The Penguins weren't terribly good at hockey-ing.
beat the sens: I was wondering, baseball has the spitball and corked bat. Football has the deflated ball. But what does hockey have in the way of sneaky cheating techniques? And do the players use pine tar on their sticks like baseball bats?
Jason Mackey: I've never seen or smelled pine tar, although stuff like that isn't regulated as much. There's a tacky stick/tape thingy they use. Don't know what you want to call it, but they rub it on their sticks for tackier feel. I guess the parallel you're looking for is stick curve. I'd be comfortable saying it's less of a thing than it used to be, but that would be my hockey equivalent.
Guest: How do the Pens stop Karlsson? Perhaps roll an extra defender his way? Rough him up? He seems unstoppable right now.
Jason Mackey: I wouldn't pay any extra attention, honestly. I don't think Karlsson has been the difference in this series. Not even close. I think the Penguins need to put Karlsson more on his toes and play less into the Senators' system. Generate more offense basically and change the style of game being played. He's a great player, but he hasn't been their biggest issue.
goalie: Was Fleury just off last night? Is there reason to bench him tomorrow?
Jason Mackey: He wasn't great, but it was a combination of poor play in front of him, Ottawa having a strong start and a few bad bounces. Those four things together. The only thing I'll blame Fleury for is not doing SOMETHING to change momentum, but even that's tough. Their defense was bad. Not one of the four goals was 100 percent Fleury's fault. Extenuating circumstances on all of them.
t: turris seems like a real punk out there. does he have a bad reputation for being an instigator/punk around the NHL?
Jason Mackey: Not that I'm aware of. I Googled "Kyle Turris punk" and nothing came up.
fish: Do you think the Pens have anything left in the tank, or was last night the beginning of the end?
Jason Mackey: Fish ... tank. Sorry. Yes, I think they have plenty left. Honestly, I think last night was more an aberration than a bubbling trend.
Dead Fan too: A lot of people don't realize that Soundgarden formed back in 1984 out on the West Coast, which makes me wonder if something my uncle always says is true. He says that the 1987 Grateful Dead album In the Dark was heavily influenced by the burgeoning grunge sound coming out of Washington state. I can hear hints of grunge on In the Dark, but do you think any of that is true? Did Soundgarden influence Jerry G and crew?
Jason Mackey: Have zero clue. But I'm going to re-listen to "In the Dark" with that in mind. Never thought of that or heard it.
Guest: Could getting Phil Kessel more ice time be the answer to the scoring drought?
Jason Mackey: I wouldn't. Not because I don't think Phil's capable, but playing guys more isn't always the solution. You may just tire them out and render them ineffective. I actually thought Kunitz-Malkin-Kessel was decent last night, although admittedly, that's a low bar comparatively. If I was Sullivan, I'd keep that line the same -- or swap Rust for Kunitz if he's healthy -- and tell Phil that I wanted to see 10 shots on goal for Game 4 or he's benched for Game 5. Serious.
NHL: Do the Ducks have any chance to beat out the Preds? It seems like Nashville is just a magical team this year.
Jason Mackey: I agree with you. I think Nashville is playing an exciting brand of hockey. That, coupled with the best goaltender of the postseason ... is pretty darn hard to be. I think they win this one. Great trip for the Stanley Cup Final.
Purdue Fan : Jason, as a Purdue grad I've been a longtime admirer of you and your family, especially your grandpappy Guy Mackey. He was a great leader at the university. But more relevant to the chat...Did Crosby have an off night last night? I was a little worried he might have been favoring his right leg. I hope it isn't an injury. Thanks!
Jason Mackey: We aren't related, although I do own a Drew Brees Purdue jersey. ... Anyway, I know what you're saying. I don't think Crosby was 100 percent. I don't think he's been 100 percent. Is it the Niskanen hit? A leg? Something else? We'll never know. But I agree that he hasn't looked like his usual self in a while.
Guest: I could use something lighthearted to talk about after last night's loss… is it true Crosby is a big fan of the old tv show Friends? He mentioned it in an interview probably a decade or so ago now.
Jason Mackey: I am not aware of this. Can you send along the interview? That's hilarious if it's indeed the case.
Pope: Do you start flower or Murray in game 4? I go with the Flower. The defense is responsible for at least 3 of the first 4 goals last night. Flower may have had bad positioning on the wrap around goal, but there again the D should have been in position to prevent that goal as well.
Jason Mackey: I totally agree, Pope. With every single thing you said. Starting Murray would have an effect on the room, trust me. It's nothing against Matt. I don't think benching Marc would go over well at all.
Pope: What are the chances we get Horny, Shultz and Rust back for game 4?
Jason Mackey: Pretty good, honestly. I think they're close. If they're with the group today -- they practice at 1:15, and I think those three will be with the group -- I I think they'll play Friday.
SL: Hi Jason, always appreciate your insight. Two questions : what time is Pens practice today, and what do you think is going on with our whole team looking snakebit when it comes to scoring more than one goal? Anderson didn't look this good in the Rangers series. Are our boys just exhausted, too injured, or gripping their sticks too tight?
Jason Mackey: Practice is at 1:15. A little bit of all three, honestly. But I don't think "too exhausted" or "too injured." They just need to do more to get in front of Anderson, shoot more, generate offense from closer to the goal, all of that stuff. It's doable, but it's going to require more of an effort than they gave last night.
Pope: Why have the pens started the majority of the games slow in the playoffs this spring? Over confidence? Lack of leadership? Fatigue?
Jason Mackey: Not sure. I think if I had that answer I would offer it up to Sullivan and his staff for some serious cash.
JC: Obviously the 7 Dman thing did not work out yesterday, but do you think Streit found himself in the lineup next game if Schultz is unable to go.
Jason Mackey: Nah, I think they'll stick with six and use 12 forwards. But it's just not Schultz. I think you'll have Rust or Hornqvist back. Probably both. And I wouldn't bump Wilson or Rowney, which you would have to do. Also, I think it's a moot point because I think Schultz will play in Game 4.
Guest: Who is the best player in the Pens minor league system and how good is he/she as compared to other top minor leaguers?
Jason Mackey: Probably Daniel Sprong. Although it's tough to compare him with AHL guys because he spent this past season in the QMJHL, basically scoring a goal a game. Put it this way: It's going to take a lot for Sprong NOT to be with the NHL club out of camp next season. Good chance he earns a top-six job, too. Not many minor league guys are on that sort of trajectory.
Steve: In the conference finals, the last twelve times a team has taken a 2-1 lead in the series, that team has gone on to win the series 10 of the 12 times. Is the writing on the wall?
Jason Mackey: I walked around much of Canadian Tire Centre last night -- not my choice, the press-box-to-media-work-room journey is a long one. I saw no such verbiage.
dave: Do you think Malkin is falling back into his bad habits (bad penalties, lackadaisical play, etc.)?
Jason Mackey: I don't. If for no other reason than it's pretty much standard-issue for Malkin to take a few dumb, reactionary penalties. You take the good with the bad. There's been way more good than bad. I don't think Malkin was lackadaisical or has been lackadaisical. Could he be more careful with the puck? Sure. I don't know. Maybe I'm wrong here and should expect Malkin to be more of a defensive force. But when a guy can skate like him, make plays in the offensive zone the way that he can, I'm not looking at him and telling him to be a defense-heavy guy. Frankly, I don't care what he doesn't defensively. Just be smarter with the puck.
Peter Kadar: I've read that Ottawa isn't really doing much on the ice in between games while it seems as thought the Penguins are having practive frequently. Your thoughts?
Jason Mackey: Yeah, it doesn't seem Guy Boucher has much use for morning skates or practices. God bless him. I don't think it's playing a factor, honestly. If anything, I think the Penguins have more stuff to work on than Ottawa right now. I don't think 30 minutes of practice is the reason the Penguins were ineffective last night.
dave: Do you have any theories on the slow starts in the playoffs? Sullivan doesn't seem to have any answers for it.
Jason Mackey: As I said earlier, if I did, I'd try to make some money off of it.
Guest: Who will start in net in the next matchup?
Jason Mackey: I think Fleury.
Mark: Jason, not that it would have mattered but what did you think of the decision to dress an extra defenseman, Streit, instead of the 12th forward, Kuhnnackl?
Jason Mackey: I thought it was a moot point last night, for one. Would have been bad either way. If Sullivan sticks with it and scratches Wilson or Rowney when Rust or Hornqvist comes back, then I'll have an issue. I think it's going to be a one-off, though. And I thought it was a minor detail in the scheme of things.
PortVue in VA: Do you notice an egregious amount of interference not being called in this series, as was common in the Devil's trap heyday? Not to make excuses, that was a thrashing. Speaking of, do you think "Friend of the Devil" loses some luster in slower versions? I think being uptempo adds to the desperation of the character. I'd trade 20 bills for some back checking.
Jason Mackey: Hahaha. Nice Grateful Dead tie-in. And I do like the faster versions of FOTD. Hockey-wise, yes, there have been some bad missed interference calls. That's also hardly unique to this series, sad as it is for me to type that.
TK: When the camera caught Kessel screaming on the bench in game 2, what do you think he was complaining about?
Jason Mackey: Which time? Ha. He yells a lot. Can be anything. From an official, an opposing player, to how he wanted the puck and didn't get it. A lot of things.
PENGUINS: Jason. youre chats are the best. i look ford to them every week. Keep up the good work! Thanks!
Jason Mackey: Thank you!
gamer: Definitely could see MAF was rattled after the soft goals, regardless of the defense. I suggest letting MM start next game to give MAF a day off and state he will start game 5 at home. Nothing to lose here, if MM stinks it up put MAF back in. He deserves to start but also deserves a day off to clear his head.
Jason Mackey: What, then, if Matt Murray pitches a shutout? I think it you start Murray, you need to commit to him regardless. Unless, of course, he stinks. But I think removing Fleury at this point is unnecessarily harsh and unappreciative of what he's done to get this team here, one that hasn't played particularly well at times and would probably be sitting at home if not for Fleury.
Travis: I think Sid's playing with a mild concussion. Also, all of the Pens are showing the effects of too many hits and good checks while not doing the same.
Jason Mackey: I really hope -- and do not think -- the Penguins would do that with an asset the level of Sidney Crosby. Is Sid banged up? I'm sure he is. They all are. He might be a little hesitant, too, to go to those areas, but that's not a medical issue.
Guest: Um, Jason. One of your readers might want to rethink his Pens nicknames. His nickname for Hornqvist is downright inappropriate.
Jason Mackey: It's what his teammates call him.
Mike From South Hills: The discussion to not start MAF shouldn't even be discussed. There are much other things that need improved. Doumolin and Cole were very poor last night. The forwards need to play with passion. It would be nice to see Kunitz do anything offensively.
Jason Mackey: If you're going to be rational, Mike, I'm not sure there's a place for you in the NHL playoffs.
JC: responding to earlier....then who is the 12 forwards if rust and hornqvist is back, who sits?
Jason Mackey: If they return, I'd go:
Jason Mackey: Guentzel-Crosby-Sheary ... Rust-Malkin-Kessel ... Kunitz-Bonino-Hornqvist ... Wilson-Cullen-Rowney. ... I like the third line to set the tone as far as being physical and getting to Anderson.
CR: Hey Jason, it looked like to me that weaving the puck seemed to open up the Sens 1-3-1 a bit, but our puck handling and passing wasn't up to par to pull it off. Fatigue, lack of on-ice groove, or just a bad night? I live in Nashville and want to see a Cup series with our Boys! Go Pens!
Jason Mackey: I don't live in Nashville, and I want to see a Stanley Cup Final with the Predators. Going east-west and weaving is a risky way to beat the 1-3-1. If things are a tad off, you're screwed. All things considered, I think the Penguins have been fine in their approach navigating the 1-3-1. Problem is, other things -- defensive play, generating offense down low -- have lacked.
JD: What is going on in the faceoff circle? Pens seemed totally off last night, including their best guys
Jason Mackey: Until last night, they have been about five percentage points better in the playoffs than the regular season, with Game 2 around 62 percent, if memory serves. They stunk last night, but it's one game. Not a trend. I wouldn't worry too much about it. Plus, I find faceoffs to be a relatively meaningless stat.
gamer: So if MAF is still rattled and they go down 3-0 and we can't make it back up the hill because we're worried about an insult. This is business and he definitely needs a day off imho. So then if MM excels you would be afraid of that and keeping him in Game 5? I'm sure MAF would take one for the team, he did last year and we won the Cup!
Jason Mackey: Fleury is a quality human and a team guy. I have no doubt he'll support the decision. And if MM excels, heck no I wouldn't take him out; you play the guy who gives you the best chance to win. Take context out of this. There were so many more issues last night than Fleury. He's been exemplary these playoffs. Why are we pulling Fleury, then, and not rejiggering the defense? Just saying.
Mike: Jason, who has had success against the Senators, and can we go to school on them? Thanks!
Jason Mackey: Crosby and Malkin have crushed the Senators during their careers. Game 4 would be a good time for that to again continue.
JD: I thought Streit was effective at getting shots through, something the other Dmen don't seem to do, especially on the PP. If Schultz is back, is it Streit who goes back to a healthy scratch?
Jason Mackey: I don't disagree with you, but I don't think he's worth the spot if Rust and Hornqvist come back; you'd have to scratch a forward -- Wilson, Rowney or both -- that I think would be a better option. And if Schultz is back, absolutely Streit is a healthy scratch.
Pope: Is Sprong a LW or RW?
Jason Mackey: RW.
SL: Your gut feeling: Do you still think the Pens will win the series?
Jason Mackey: Yes. In six.
Guest: On the postgame show last night, Millbury and Roenick both said Murray should start tomorrow, and even said Sullivan will definitely go with Murray. I dont have a question but thought it was interesting they were so adamant and sure it should/would happen, considering it doesn't seem like anyone else thinks it should.
Jason Mackey: Looks like it'll be Fleury for Game 4. Don't know if I could take less seriously what those two say.
BK: I know now for a FACT that Phil Kessel's ire is mostly directed at Chris Kunitz, who has one goal since just after Valentine's day. I get that there are injuries. I get that there's a lot more to their inability to score 5 on 5 lately than #14. That being said, when you see 71 and 81 openly frustrated while the team seems suddenly unable to score, isn't it time to switch things up? If he's unable to contribute on offense, he should be taking runs at Phaneuf at every opportunity, yet he doesn't. I know you're tired of me bashing Kunitz, but the treatment he gets from the staff is comical now. ANY other option would be a better one.
Jason Mackey: Hi Billy. I'll say this: If Rust comes back, I'd put him with 71 and 81. And with Kessel, I don't want him hitting Phanuef or anyone. That's counter-productive. I'd tell him to shoot the puck every single time he had it. I don't care where he was on the ice.
Pope: If Sprong is Top 6 next season, then what are your projected top 2 lines?
Jason Mackey: Let's go: Sheary-Crosby-Sprong ... Guentzel-Malkin-Kessel
Jason Mackey: OK, folks. That does it. Have to get ready and head to Penguins practice. Will talk to yinz from there. Thanks, as always for participating. Fun one today!




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.