FORWARDS — Grade: C-

The Penguins’ No. 1 line of Matt Cullen between Scott Wilson and Carter Rowney was their most effective forward unit for much of the night. That’s a credit to them, but an indictment of those above them on the depth chart. One thing the Penguins did well throughout the game was to pass up shooting opportunities to feed the puck to a teammate. There are times when being selfish is the way to go, and one of those is when you’re having trouble scoring a goal. Senators goalie Craig Anderson, undoubtedly, was grateful that the Penguins didn’t test him more often.

DEFENSEMEN — Grade: C

This group turned in a generally solid performance, but when there aren’t many goals in a game, the mistakes that lead to them are magnified. That’s why Brian Dumoulin’s giveaway that led to Jean-Gabriel Pageau’s goal that put the Senators up, 1-0, at 14:32 of the second period went down as a pivotal moment in the game. That was countered by Ron Hainsey’s stellar effort on Evgeni Malkin’s goal, when he dumped the puck into the Ottawa end and chased it down, allowing Chris Kunitz to launch the shot that Malkin deflected in. Senators winger Bobby Ryan got behind Olli Maatta on the game-winning goal.

Advertise with us

GOALIE — Grade: B

Marc-Andre Fleury wasn’t as busy as he had been in some games this spring, and turned in another fairly strong showing. But while he hardly can be blamed for Pageau’s goal, which was made possible by a sweet assist from Ottawa winger Bobby Ryan, Fleury has no margin for error when his teammates struggle to to manufacture a single goal. He didn’t have much of a chance to stop Ryan on the game-winner, as Ryan got behind the Penguins’ defense and drove to the net before flipping a backhander under the crossbar to raise Ottawa’s all-time playoff overtime record to 6-1.

SPECIAL TEAMS — Grade: C-

The game never would have gone to overtime if the Penguins had been able to get anything out of their power play, which failed to score on five tries – including a 45-second five-on-three – during regulation. There were times when it generated decent pressure, but others when it struggled to get across the Ottawa blue line. In what shapes up as a low-scoring series, getting goals from the power play could be decisive. The penalty-kill was solid, denying the Senators on both of their tries with the extra man.

COACHING — Grade: C

Advertise with us

Mike Sullivan and his staff had their players well-prepared for dealing with Ottawa’s 1-3-1 defensive alignment, as the Penguins were able to navigate through the neutral zone reasonably well for most of the game. Whether the coaches are responsible for the Penguins not appearing to match Ottawa’s urgency for much of the evening is conjecture. If Sullivan can have them more motivated and focused from the start of Game 2 – and more willing to put the puck on goal – it should enhance their chances of evening the series before it shifts to Ottawa.

Dave Molinari: Dmolinari@Post-Gazette.com and Twitter @MolinariPG