Chuck: The Sens use the dreaded 1-3-1 a lot. Very effective when they have the lead. How can the Pens beat it?
Jason Mackey: No. 1, they have to be extremely careful with the puck in the neutral zone. More so than against Washington, honestly. And I think that's something to watch. Puck decisions were not the Penguins friend against the Caps. The 1-3-1 can also be extremely boring. The second thing I'd say is that the Penguins need to be patient. There are going to be times where the safe play is the better play. More dumps-ins than usual, in all likelihood. They're going to need to be OK with that and not force things.
Chuck: A lot of talk in the Ottawa papers about the Crosby slash on Methot back in March. Do you see any carryover from that incident impacting the series?
Jason Mackey: Only with Ottawa, and even then I think it's negligible. The Penguins couldn't care less, I can tell you that. I'm sure the Senators are still hacked off, but these series -- especially now -- get so intense so quickly, my guess is it will be a distant memory by midway through Game 1.
Jason Mackey: I was not. GMJR has no thoughts of leaving. I can't blame Jason for wanting to run his own team. He's ready. He's as smart as they come. If Jim's not going to step away, why just sit there? He would only be waiting around for the sake of a storyline at that point. No surprised at all he left.
Stephen: How will the Sabre's hiring Jason Botterill affect the Penguins? I thought he was going to be "the next man up" after JR retires.
Jason Mackey: He probably was, but Rutherford isn't going to be retiring for a while. At least that's what he keeps saying, and I tend to believe him. The guy's having fun. The team's winning. His family loves it here. Why change? I think Jason probably got tired of waiting around, and not a soul around the Penguins can blame him. He's ready. ... As far as the future, I'd look for Bill Guerin to become GM of Wilkes-Barre, Jason Karmanos to handle more cap stuff, Mark Recchi to slide into more of Guerin's old role as scout/pro assistant, and I think they will grow Gonchar's role to be more like Recchi in terms of development. If Gonchar would rather coach, then they could seek to replace Recchi with a recently retired player. ... Is it too soon to fantasize about Matt Cullen doing this? Probably. Can still play.
Super_Maro_66: Do you agree with NHL. Com writers that Erik Karlsson is the leading Conn Smyth Leader by a landslide?
Jason Mackey: Not by a landslide, but I definitely think he should win it. I know I voted for him. He's a really, really good player, and I think his well-rounded game -- never better than this season -- gives him the edge over Brent Burns. But I wouldn't call it a landslide.
Guest: dang, it Jason. I look forward to this chat. Is everything ok?
Jason Mackey: Sorry. It took us six hours to make a four-hour drive from D.C. yesterday. Bad, bad traffic on 70, the result of a pretty nasty accident. Had to write and wanted to see my family, knowing full well the craziness would start up again soon. Appreciate your patience pushing it today.
uh: Jason, why is your chat postponed? I rearranged my schedule to get in here following the great Pens win last night. I was gonna get a cast off my arm today!
Jason Mackey: No way you re-arranged your schedule for this. If you did, I would suggest re-arranging your priorities. See the answer above on traffic.
go pens: Hi Jeff, I've followed your chats for a while, but never posted. In your opinion, is Mike Andre Fleury's play what can be the difference make for this team not just in the next series but all the way to the Cup Finals?
Jason Mackey: Jeff and Mike? C'mon! Ha. I don't care. Can't speak for MAF. To answer the question, I absolutely think Bill Andre-Fleury has what it takes to lead the Penguins to a Cup. He already has, and he's been their best player thus far in knocking off two of the five best teams in the NHL.
Jason Mackey: Technically Ottawa did have a team in the 1920s and 1930s before moving to St. Louis, but I get your point. Great hockey city. Should absolutely have a team, just like Quebec City.
Guest: How on earth did Ottawa not get an NHL team until the 90s?
Guest: What is Ovechkin's legacy?
Jason Mackey: General talent who couldn't get past the second round. A ton of individual success, not so much when it comes to the team. I could write more, but that's what it boils down to for me. I think he's an incredible player, but the lack of winning in the postseason is rather incredible. Or tragic.
5/8/77: 5/8/77 - Jason, were you alive for that legendary show? Get this - tickets were $7.50. Imagine what they would be today. I saw Kid Rock and Korn headline a show in the last few years and it was over $50. I assume you are a 5/8/77 fan and I gotta know what you think of that show, man! ALL TIME GREAT
Jason Mackey: I like it. I think it's a little overblown, though. Again, not that it's bad, but I'd put at least 5-11-77 and 2-26-77 ahead of it from that time period alone. Those ticket prices are crazy. Especially when I think about what I'm going to drop on Phish and Dead & Company this summer. I was not alive for 5-8-77.
Guest: How much of a per diem do you get for food on the road? Do you get more in an expensive city like NY than you do in an inexpensive city like Nashville? I'm doing a report on sports reporters for school. THANK YOU
Jason Mackey: No worries. I love talking about this stuff. Email if you have more questions (jmackey@post-gazette.com). We try to keep our food to an average of $35. This is outside of transportation and hotel; the PG takes care of both. I'm talking just food. And for me, that's plenty. I don't like to eat lunch the day of a game. I'd rather get a nice dinner the night before, then just do breakfast, mid-day nap and dinner at the rink.
Guest: How devastated did the crowd seem at the end of the game last night? On tv I heard booing toward the end and then complete silence after the final buzzer.
Jason Mackey: That about captured it. It was part devastation, part disbelief. I can't even imagine what it must feel like to be a Capitals fan right now. I'll admit, I really started to believe that this was going to be the year they did it. Shows what I know.
ALERT: NO need to fear, Penguins Fans! Guy Boucher couldn't coach his way out of a paper bag! The Pens sweep the series easily.
Jason Mackey: Is there a way to have difficulty sweeping a series?
Guest: Is it true that the Ottawa Senators have only been around since 1992? I swear I saw them play the Pens here in the late 80s. Is that right?
Jason Mackey: They returned in 1992. They actually were around in the 1920s and 1930s. I don't know if that's when Matt Cullen played for them or not. Will have to check hockeydb.com.
Guest: I don't know that much about the Ottawa team. Who is their best player? Turris?
Jason Mackey: Erik Karlsson. Defenseman. And it's not close. He's probably the best in the league. Hardly leaves the ice. Playing with two fractures in his foot. Should be the Norris Trophy winner. Just an incredible player. Dave Molinari wrote on him and the Penguins' respect for him. Piece should be online shortly.
Bill : Mackey, in my estimation, you are a very legitimate and trustworthy reporter. How would you handle a liar like Trump if you were charged with covering his antics? I feel that many journalists today do not hold him accountable for his lies. I know this is a hockey chat, but as a fan of your work I am curious what your thoughts as a journalist are on the things that really matter in this world, and here's a clue - the things that really matter are not NHL or Grateful Dead although I am a fan of both and did follow the dead for about 2 summers when I was younger. I never actually liked Jerry but I thought the other members were superb and balanced out his somewhat inconsistent performances. Take '73 for example. He was awful all that year. Now, also, any thoughts on how Ottawa's defense can try to neutralize Crosby?
Jason Mackey: Please no politics, Bill. This is sports. This should be fun. I'm not into alienating half of our readers over political affiliation. ... Ottawa's best asset will be its 1-3-1. The Penguins spent time today on how to stay patient and eventually beat it. Careful with the puck. Take a hit to make a play. Dump it in. Play with a lead. Score on the power play. Entering the zone with speed. There are going to be several keys to neutralizing the 1-3-1.
Guest: Has a goalie ever scored a goal? Are they allowed to?
Jason Mackey: Yes and yes. Mike Smith was the last to do it, in 2013. Ron Hextall did it twice. Marc-Andre Fleury's would probably retire on the spot if he ever scored. Here's a list: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_goaltenders_who_have_scored_a_go...
Guest: I think that if you had to choose a STAR OF THE GAME for Captials it would be Holtby. I know people say Ovechkin is Hall of Fame worthy maybe one day after he retires, but honestly I think Holtby has had the more consistent career at least in terms of playoff stats. Thoguhts?
Jason Mackey: I respectfully disagree. I think Ovechkin's is the premier goal-scorer of the post-lockout era. I think he's incredible. However, if we're going to start the best-in-series discussion for the Capitals, I'm going with Evgeny Kuznetsov. Man, is that kid going to be a force for years to come. He also has a really good sense of humor. Fun to talk to.
Marnie: Will we see the same line-up against the Senators (Wilson/Rowney rather than Hagelin/Khunhackl) at least to start the series?
Jason Mackey: I have a hard time seeing Mike Sullivan take Scott Wilson or Carter Rowney out the way that line played. If Carl Hagelin is injured, I may just stash him, let him heal, then react accordingly if someone struggles. If Sullivan does make a move -- an argument could be made for Hagelin, even at 80 percent, being a big help in breaking the 1-3-1, I'd yank out Wilson before Rowney.
!: Is it a problem that WAS had 8 more shots on goal than PIT in the 2nd period OR does that not matter? I know we scored 1 that period and they did not, so...
Jason Mackey: In Game 7? I don't have a problem with that at all. I thought the Penguins were terrific for the bulk of the game. I'm not going to bury them over shots on goals allowed in the second period. Plus, I can't remember more than two or three that were terribly high-quality.
Guest: Patric Rust came up huge last night. His goal in the 2nd Period was all this team needed ultimately to beat WASH. How good is Rust?
Jason Mackey: Patric Rust tortures goalies. But only in elimination games. ... Serious, I'm continually amazed at how Bryan Rust continues to do this in keys situations. It's impressive. I also don't know how to explain it. Just freaky.
citizen: Getting to root against the Senators?!?!?! This will be easy for me; I root against my Senators all the time. They are always voting for dumb laws that hurt me. Am I right?
Jason Mackey: Doh.
LZ#1: Some DeadHeads in my apt complex Monday were blasting this awful jam band and I went to their door and totally "harshed their mellow" in their words by asking them to turn it down. They informed me that they were celebrating the 50th anniversary of some dead show in NY and that they would not turn it down. So, long story short I complained to our landlord and now they are all giving me the stink eye in the laundry room. So, what is so significant about this DeadHead anniversary, because I actually like those guys and would like to bury the hatchet. Please explain, you are the only DeadHead I know who has any ability to at least try to explain why that band is so eternally popular. I myself am a Zeppelin fan and always will be. Period. Thank you.
Jason Mackey: 5-11-77 was one of the most iconic shows in Grateful Dead history because of the quality of recording, the musicianship that night, the setlist, a lot of things. It was at Barton Hall/Cornell University. Great show. I think it's kind of the one that everybody gravitates to out of habit, but it's still very good.
roger 1: Look, I'm not a conspiracy theorist, but do you think that the NHL "encouraged" the Pens to drop game 6 in the manner that they did in order to "force" a game 7 and get some extra juice (ratings) for the NHL Playoffs, especially since the game would be in DC and DC has been in the news so much lately? Any info on that?
Jason Mackey: It would be so complicated to rig a hockey game that, if the NHL ever tried, I have no doubt it would screw it up in a very, very obvious way. So, no.
Guest: Any favorite things to do or see in Ottawa? Seems like a cool city!
Jason Mackey: Downtown is great. I loved it. Parliament Hill, etc. Just wonderful. Only problem is the rink is actually in Kanata -- way away from Downtown. We're staying close to Downtown, though, so I'm sure we'll do some additional sight-seeing on the off-day.
Guest: Ottawa is pretty far north, but do you think that they have a real chance to knock off the Pens? I honestly think that truly the Pens can go in WITH ALL THIS MOMENTUM and take out the Senators in 4 games. Prediction from you?
Jason Mackey: I saw Penguins in six. Two trips to Ottawa for us. I don't see Ottawa winning, but I also have a tough time seeing the Penguins sweep. I think the Senators are better than a lot of people in Pittsburgh are going to give them credit for.
Guest: I was watching the movie where Vince Vaughan and Kevin James go to a Blackhawks game together and Kevin James gets to go on the ice to take a shot for a prize. Do you know if they filmed that on location at an actual game or if that is all green screen and CGI? I ask you because I know you were at a game where they filmed a Segal movie, but I can't remember if that was a real game or if you were out in Hollywood when that happened? GO PENS
Jason Mackey: I don't know. And it was a Jean-Claude Van Damme movie (Sudden Death) that I was there for the filming of.
HB: I like what Carter Rowney brings to the pens I hope they keep him in the line up against the senators.
Jason Mackey: As I said before, I think Rowney had an excellent game Wednesday. I'd keep him in, for sure.
!!!!!: Hey, where are all the "TRADE MARC ANDRE" fans this morning, Jason? I guess they all forgot that they said that. What can you tell those fair weather Marc Andre fans now?
Jason Mackey: Ha. It's none of my business to tell fans how to think. I just write about the team. And in terms of Fleury, he's written a better story than I could ever dream of. Awesome stuff.
tim: MAF is the man. He was in the Caps heads all night like a Limp Bizkit song that you just can't shake. And just like Durst the caps will be thinking that today is just one of those days when they don't want to wake up because everything stinks and they just want to justify breaking stuff. Have you ever seen a goalie win the psychological battle like that before in a Game 7? Unreal.
Jason Mackey: I didn't think I'd wake up today and hear the Caps compared to Limp Bizkit. So there's that.
Guest: Radio today was saying Ovechkin is very good, probably HOF, but not an all-time great cuz he can't get his team to Finals. Do you think this is accurate? Who has had a better career Ovechkin or Malkin?
Jason Mackey: I think Ovechkin has time, so I'd want to hold all judgement until he's over. If he doesn't win a Cup and Malkin wins two or more ... then absolutely Malkin has had the better career. Points are a pittance compared to Cups, and Ovechkin, I'm sure, would tell you exactly that.
HB: Who do you have out west the ducks or the predators?
Jason Mackey: I like the Ducks in seven.
TJ: Monday was the 40th anniversary of the Dead at Barton Hall! It was an amazing show and I wasn't there but my cousin's friend was and everything about that show is why I love the Dead. Do you have a favorite nugg from that show?
Jason Mackey: Scarlet > Fire. Then and always.
HB: I respect Ron cook but like I said last week he writes a piece doubting the Penguins and they win. Feels Good Man!!!
Jason Mackey: I will make sure to convey your feelings to Ron.
TEAM1: You had to love the toughness you saw last night from the Pens. Can you say a few words about how the Pens leadership really brought home the W? Thanks.
Jason Mackey: Believe it or not, it really doesn't make any difference to me whether the Penguins showed toughness Wednesday or whether they folded like a table. I get paid the same either way. I do think there is excellent leadership around the team. Whether it's Mike Sullivan, Sidney Crosby, Evgeni Malkin, Chris Kunitz, Matt Cullen or Marc-Andre Fleury, on down the line, the Penguins have a group of guys who perform in big games. I think Wednesday was another of many examples that should demonstrate how good of a coach Mike Sullivan is. I continually find it more and more nuts that this guy had to struggle to get a head coaching job.
HB: Maybe the caps need to pull a penguin and fire Trotz mid season.
Jason Mackey: I think that only works for the Penguins.
Jason Mackey: OK, folks. Thanks so much for participating. A lot of great questions. Let's do this again next week!
Jason Mackey: Oh, sorry. Never mind. We have more questions. Hold tight.
SL: When is Conn Smythe decided? Does it always go to someone in the winning Cup team?
Jason Mackey: After the Stanley Cup winner has been determined. It's voted on by the Professional Hockey Writers Association (PHWA). It doesn't always go to the winning team, but it usually does.
Andy: I think Malkin should be guaranteeing more wins and Ron Cook should be writing more negative stories about the Pens if they want to keep winning
Jason Mackey: Man, Ron's taking a beating here. Can understand why, but he's paid for his opinion, not to predict that Pittsburgh teams will win everything all the time.
Andy: People seem to think Ottawa will be a cakewalk for the Pens. I actually think they have a great chance of beating the Pens. Playing confident, with speed, defensive structure and some good offensive players. I think they are dangerous and the Pens didn't look particularly good against them this year. What are Sully, the players saying about this series?
Jason Mackey: They're saying a lot of things, Andy. Anything you're wondering specifically? They're aware of the challenges Ottawa will present. They're guarding against a letdown. They know they need to play like they did in Game 7 against the Caps.
Andy: Who should be playing against Ottawa, meaning who would be most effective? Speedy guys? If so, why not reunite sheary w Sid and Jake? That first line was killing it in the regular season. Ottawa is not a heavy forechecking or physical team like CBJ and Caps
Jason Mackey: Interesting point. I don't like Sheary on the third line ever. I have a feeling we could see 59-87-43 and 17-71-81 as a top six in this series.
Matt: Other than Hagelin and Daley, are there any other lingering injuries.? Thought Ruhwedel played well.. keep his spot until Daley is healthy?
Jason Mackey: That's it. We'll see more tomorrow. I've been so-so on Ruhwedel. Daley isn't close. I would explore using Mark Streit. I kind of what to see what he has in a less than high-pressure environment.
Brazilian_Penguin: Any word on Karlsson? Seems like he barely practiced today. Terrible news for Ottawa if he can't play.
Jason Mackey: He'll play. It's playoffs. Read nothing into practice.
SL: Did anyone ever ask Nisky how he felt being 'de-friended' by tape on Flowers mask, after concussing Sid?
Jason Mackey: I don't think anyone did. That's a miss by us in the media.
Brazilian_Penguin: Hey Jason, Do you feel like Hagelin will still be benched for game 1 or HCMS will bring him back?
Jason Mackey: It's not so much benching. It's Hagelin's health. Much will depend on that. I think there's a good chance he could sit out Game 1 to try and heal.
RPK: The Pens fore-checking in game 7 had the Caps' defensemen on their heels. Will it be more consistent in this series as compared to the first two?
Jason Mackey: One would hope. Different team, though, in Ottawa. Need to be aware of that.
cao: Should the Pens stick with a 4th line of Cullen, Rowney and Wilson?
Jason Mackey: I think so. At least for Game 1, then go from there.
Party Hard: Hi Jason, do you think Pascal Dupuis will ever have a front-office role with the team? Maybe a player to front office liaison like Billy G in the earlier parts of his front office career?
Jason Mackey: I think it would make sense, given how much his former teammates like him, but I don't get the sense this is something Dupuis is terribly interested in doing.
Cody: Hey Jason, what are your thoughts on the resurrection of Marc-Andre Fleury's season and what does it do for the trade value going forward? (Assuming that's the road the Penguins take).
Jason Mackey: I would still assume Fleury gets traded, and it's interesting to think what this run has done for his trade value. I think it has increased dramatically. Can they get a first-round pick for him? I don't know about that, but I do think the Penguins can get something substantial for Fleury, where that wasn't the case midseason.
Matt: Prediction on the series ?
Jason Mackey: Penguins in six.
Jason Mackey: OK, guys. That does it. For real this time. Have to write some stuff now. Thanks for participating. Let's do this again next week.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.