FORWARDS

No single player can replace Sidney Crosby — if so, he would be a Hart Trophy finalist, like Crosby — but big-ticket players such as Evgeni Malkin and Phil Kessel will have to do more than most to compensate for his absence. Malkin scoring with less than two minutes left in regulation was a good start. The Penguins entered Game 3 with the most prolific offense in these playoffs; simply being without Crosby for most of the game didn’t excuse their inability to score until regulation was winding down. LW Chris Kunitz had a strong game, playing the body and scoring a goal that was disallowed because of goaltender interference.

Grade: C

DEFENSEMEN

Advertise with us

Justin Schultz had been overdue to score a goal in these playoffs, and probably couldn’t have picked a better time, as he beat Washington G Braden Holtby with a slap shot from the slot with 65 seconds to go in regulation to tie the score, 2-2. His colleagues on the blue line didn’t block nearly as many shots as in Game 2, but were solid throughout in even-strength situations, limiting the Capitals to one goal while playing five-on-five. Trevor Daley’s holding penalty at 2:40 of overtime created the power play that led to Washington’s game-deciding goal.

Grade: C+

GOALIE

Marc-Andre Fleury was the Penguins’ best player, as he has been so many times since the start of Round 1. His play was the primary reason the Penguins had a chance to pull off their improbable comeback in the final two minutes of regulation, stopping 29 of the 31 shots Washington threw at him in the first two periods. He appeared to be screened on Kevin Shattenkirk’s game-winning goal at 3:13 of overtime, which came on Washington’s second shot of the extra period. With the series now, 2-1, in the Penguins’ favor, his strong play will become even more critical.

Grade: B+

Advertise with us

SPECIAL TEAMS

Losing Crosby obviously was a major blow to the power play — to say nothing of several other facets of the Penguins’ game — but its failure to take advantage of nine minutes with the man-advantage was a major factor in the Penguins playing from behind for most of the game. Special-teams play, already a pivotal variable, will take on added importance if Crosby is out of the lineup. The penalty-killers had another decent showing in regulation, giving up one goal (on a five-on-three) in four short-handed situations, but also yielded Shattenkirk’s game-winner in overtime.

Grade: D

COACHING

Starting a game without a difference-maker such as Kris Letang is difficult enough; losing one like Crosby just over five minutes into the opening period is even tougher. His departure forced coach Mike Sullivan to re-configure several of his forward lines, and he had to shuffle personnel even more after Conor Sheary departed in the second period because of an injury. The forward combinations he deployed were well-balanced and logical, and finally paid off when the Penguins got those two late goals on Holtby. The next-man-up mentality is ingrained in his players, but the onus will be on Sullivan to reinforce that if Crosby is removed from the mix.

Advertise with us

Grade: B-

Dave Molinari: Dmolinari@Post-Gazette.com and Twitter @MolinariPG.