You’d probably never peg former Penguins enforcer and Root Sports studio analyst Jay Caufield as a computer science major, but it nearly happened.

Fox Sports Ohio’s Jody Shelley studied business at Dalhousie University in Halifax, Nova Scotia, before amassing 85 NHL fights from 2001-04 and eventually transitioning into his current role doing color commentary on Blue Jackets broadcasts.

Stu Grimson — “The Grim Reaper” — was one of the most feared fighters in NHL history. Now, he’s a licensed attorney and does color for Predators games on Fox Sports South.

Despite their former profession – protecting teammates with their fists – these guys are now counted upon to provide insight into how plays happen, what players are thinking and what adjustments teams could and should make.

Advertise with us

“It’s kind of funny how that works out,” Caufield said, laughing. “I didn’t realize that.

“I know for me, I know I didn’t have any designs to do what I’m doing.

“But I also know when I played, I always paid attention. When you got your chance, you had to make sure you didn’t make mistakes and knew what you were doing.”

The NFL sends a lot of quarterbacks to the broadcast booth — Troy Aikman, Dan Marino, Phil Simms, Dan Fouts, etc. There are plenty of pitchers on the air in baseball — John Smoltz, Curt Schilling, Orel Hershiser and Bob Walk. Basketball has its share of stars on TV: Reggie Miller, Tracy McGrady, Chris Webber and Charles Barkley, to name a few.

In hockey, it’s the fighters and grinders who transition most often to broadcasting.

Advertise with us

Alan May in Washington. Rob Ray in Buffalo. Kelly Chase in St. Louis. Louie DeBrusk with Sportsnet in Canada. All fought regularly to earn a living.

Then there’s the hard-to-play-against crowd. They weren’t exclusively fighters, but they also weren’t afraid of a scrap or two.

Matthew Barnaby (2,562 penalty minutes) used to work for ESPN. Ken Daneyko (2,516 PIM) currently calls Devils games. Brad May (2,248) works alongside Ray in Buffalo.

Mike Milbury (NBCSN) wasn’t exactly the speed-and-skill type, with 49 goals and 1,552 PIM in 754 NHL games.

“The secret to good broadcasting is having a guy who you can imagine sitting on a barstool next to and talking to about the game,” said Alan May, who works for CSN Washington and fought 31 times in 1989-90. “They’re great storytellers. I think that’s what all these guys really have in common.”

Advertise with us

That and having an aptitude and appetite to learn, as Caufield pointed out. To see the ice, there was no other option.

“We all had to figure out how to make a role in the game and be relevant on teams,” Alan May said. “Not everyone started out as that type of player. Some guys were all-star goal scorers and defensemen. You got to teams, and you had to figure out a way to make it. I think you became an incredible student of the game at the same time.”

Finding their niche

Being an NHL enforcer is also akin to being a personal psychologist to the stars, Shelley said.

While their impact was rarely quantified by goals or points, how comfortable they could make those around them mattered.

Advertise with us

“We had to understand what everyone else was going through,” Shelley said. “As enforcers, you kind of keep the pulse of the team. You find a role where you know your value can be felt other ways. Try to understand a Claude Giroux, a Joe Thornton or a Rick Nash. Try to help them in a way because they’re going through things that they’re not going to tell their dad or their coach, but they’ll trust one of their teammates.”

Caufield went to the University of North Dakota and had finished his business degree when he decided to pursue a second major. (His wife was in law school at the time and pushed him to do it.)

But then former Penguins general manager Craig Patrick — with the Rangers at the time — signed Caufield, and the pursuit of a second major ended there.

“If I didn’t do that, I would be taking a computer science course, and everything would have been obsolete right now,” Caufield said.

Shelley started to think about broadcasting late in his career. While playing just 89 games for the Flyers from 2010-13, Shelley started chatting up broadcasters such as Bill Clement, Jeff Rimer, Bob McElligott, Keith Jones and others.

Advertise with us

It wasn’t until Shelley practically begged current Blue Jackets president of hockey operations John Davidson — himself a former broadcaster — to join his staff that Shelley truly gave TV a chance.

“I thought I wanted to be in hockey ops, like every other player on the planet,” Shelley said. “[Davidson] looked at me and said, ‘We have nothing for you. You should try broadcasting. It’s amazing. You’ll love it. The lifestyle’s awesome.’ ... He’s been right.”

A big adjustment

The first time May was on-air — on NHL Network, broadcast across North America — he couldn’t believe how quickly the training wheels came off.

“The hardest part is because of the camera there,” May said. “You’ve got three words that you’re fighting for in your brain, trying to get out of your mouth at the same time. There’s no rehearsal. You’re live the first time you do it. You’re kind of thrown to the wolves. It’s not like you got to go to the American League and get ready for it.”

Advertise with us

Then again, these guys said, the same mentality that helped them thrive as enforcers has come into play here. Essentially that they didn’t grow up wanting to fight people for a living, it’s what they had to do to find and keep regular NHL work.

May joked that enforcers “are always the guys who learn to jump off a cliff or jump out of an airplane real early and just do the unthinkable.”

In this case, that means thrusting themselves into a new job or a new experience where their voice is valuable.

“Nobody takes these jobs for granted,” May said. “We all want to learn as much as we can and do the job as well as we can.

“Our hard work will never be doubted. I think every one of us, nobody can say that people outwork us. That’s a big thing that we all take pride in.”

Advertise with us

To do the job effectively, it involves taking notes, attending practices and morning skates, talking to players and coaches and poring over stats, among countless other things.

As former players, they also have the unique perspective of knowing what current players are thinking. It’s a frame of reference no broadcasting school can provide, but it’s also one that guides what these guys say and how they say it.

“We all know what it’s like as players when it’s going sideways,” Caufield said. “You don’t want to make too many negative comments, but you have to be honest about what’s going on so people take you seriously. You want to be respectful of the player.

“That’s the thing that I think was always in my mind as soon as I started doing it. I wanted to make sure that anything I would say I was comfortable with how I said it and how a player might appreciate it.”

Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.