HB: Im just triple checking here but jake guentzal is safe from the expansion draft right?

Jason Mackey: Yes.

HB: Can Sprong replace wilson on the 3rd line when hes eligible to?

Jason Mackey: He can, sure. But that’s a lot to ask of Sprong. He’s also more of a RW. And I don’t think the coaching staff has been tremendously unhappy with Wilson.

Advertise with us

HB: Do you and dave watch the other playoff games or are you to busy writing stories about the pens?

Jason Mackey: Oh, no. We all watch. This is our life -- for better or worse. We all take an interest. I don’t think any of us would have started doing this if we didn’t love hockey. (Or whatever sport you cover.)

HB: when/if kunitz gets healthy does he get a spot because i like where the penguins are without him

Jason Mackey: Interesting question. At this point, I think you have to consider him for a bottom-six role.

On the Clock: Should we worry about the Penguins' defense?

HB: Is ruewedal healthy and can take maattas spot in the lineup tonight?

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: He’s not, and he won’t.

HB: is it important for the penguins to win tonight so they can have extra rest especially after how physical this series has been

Jason Mackey: That doesn’t hurt, but it’s important to win because if they don’t, they have to go back to Columbus, and the Blue Jackets will have a lot of momentum/confidence.

HB: the problem with the penguins it seems is slow starts all series long and just through higher skill power they are able to win games for them to have a chance to repeat this has to stop correct?

Jason Mackey: It would be smart for them to have better starts regardless who they’re playing.

Advertise with us

HB: Sorry for all the questions but Dave missed his chat on Monday chat :(

Jason Mackey: It’s OK. I don’t mind. But if you ask seven, I’m not going to be able to spend a ton of time. These things are 30 minutes to an hour. If I spend all the time answering one person’s questions, then others don’t get to get involved, and that’s not fair.

pghgolfgirl: Hi Jason: What can the Pens learn from the Maple Leafs/Caps games that they can apply to the next round against whichever team goes forward?

Jason Mackey: Good question. I would take not that the Leafs are for real. Next round or next year and beyond. Really good young team. I also think you’ve kind of seen a recipe in how to beat the Caps -- not the Penguins were looking for one -- but how a lot of speed and skill can neutralize them. I don’t see the Caps as a team with a team concept that’s as strong as the Penguins’, if that makes any sense.

Justin: Any word or even a hint on a timetable for Murray to return?

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: No and no. But he hasn’t been skating -- at least not when or where we’re able to see ... and along with his other injured teammates -- and I would not look for it to be soon.

SL: Gut feeling: Do you think the Pens will get it done tonight?

Jason Mackey: Yes, I do. I think they take care of business. Strong start. They’re solid from the drop of the puck.

SL: Seems like Hagelin had been skating with the injured guys, but now has stopped. Do you think he has had a set back?

Jason Mackey: I watched Hagelin skate. He was never full exertion. I think people also took what Sullivan said out of context. He said he could return this series. Sure, there’s a chance. Sullivan never said there’s a good chance. He was just asked whether there’s a chance Hagelin could return, and he said yes. There’s always a chance. When I’ve seen him skate, Hagelin has not looked to me like a guy who’s close to rejoining his teammates.

Advertise with us

Rob: While the top line has scored most of the points do you think there should be concern about their sloppy defensive zone play the last two games? Or was that a product of last line change?

Jason Mackey: I think the Karlsson line, as the game wore on, did a nice job against the Crosby line. That said, the Crosby line is worlds better than any combination Columbus could put together. Sid and the Kids simply had an off night. It happens. It’s not the end of the world. I think that line will be better last night. ... As for the defensive issues, to me, those were 90 percent with the defensemen. A lot of stuff around the net. Not defending the rush as well as they would have liked. But mostly around Fleury. They were really bad in that regard.

cao: Jason, Pittsburgh’s 1st line has had problems the past couple of games getting out of their own end, and their 3rd line is simply getting out played. Sheary is getting buried in the neutral zone and down in the corners and Bonino could use a little speed on his wings. Time to tweak the lines a little?

Jason Mackey: Absolutely not. It was one game. One bad team game, too. I think tweaking the lines would be unnecessarily reactionary. Don’t be too quick to forget the stuff that 59-87-43 has done together. This was one bad game. Nothing more. It’s a long postseason. There’s no sense -- especially up 3-0 -- in giving it any more credence than treating it as a learning experience. That’s all it was.

Justin: Seems to me that our best rooting interest in the Caps/Leafs series is it going 7 games. Do you a preference on who you think we match up better against?

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: I think Toronto is a terrific young team. Probably scary in years to come. For now, I think they’re the better matchup. I just think the Penguins are deeper, and they tend to play better against less physical teams ... although to be fair, Toronto employing Matt Martin and Brian Boyle could pose problems. That series has been extremely entertaining. I would not complain at all if it went seven games. More of that brand of hockey, please. I dozed off three times last night watching Ottawa.

me: There are times when their defense seems to be chasing the puck around their own end. What causes that? Are they not being aggressive enough?

Jason Mackey: It can be a few things. One, it could be communication. That wasn’t very good in Game 4. Another could be just making the right reads and the right passes the first time. Think about it: If a defenseman makes a quick hard outlet pass the other way, with the forward doing what he’s supposed to do, then you don’t have to worry about anything in your own zone. That’s Mike Sullivan’s MO. The more the other team has the puck, the more your chasing. ... And, like you said, not being aggressive enough can also play a part, but you’re walking that line of trying to be aggressive and not get burned.

dave: Do you think Kessel has an injury?

Jason Mackey: I know Kessel has an injury. He’s not 100-percent healthy. Saw him with an icepack on his neck-shoulder after Game 3. Was grabbing at his clavicle at the end of Game 4. But this is playoff hockey. As long as Kessel has a neck, shoulder or clavicle, he’s most likely going to play. The guy has played through a lot of stuff.

Advertise with us

WNCPensfan: Haven’t seen anyone ask what they thought of Sully keeping Sestito up and not reassigning him to WBS. Thoughts?

Jason Mackey: We have not asked, no. He’s insurance. Same as Josh Archibald. And if something might go sideways in terms of physicality, maybe Sullivan uses him. But he rehabbed here. I think they want to keep that in place while affording an option should something happen.

TK: When Ruhwedel gets healthy, do you think he will take anyone’s place in the lineup?

Jason Mackey: No, I don’t. A couple weeks ago, I might have said I thought Maatta or Daley would have a tough time getting their spots back. Those two have been just fine, in my opinion. Forget Game 4. The entire series, they’ve been pretty solid. Weren’t on for a goal against in the first three.

Joe: Sullivan said Hagelin would play in the series and now he isn’t even skating anymore, this seems like the letang injury all over again.

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: He never said he would play in the series. He said there’s a chance. Much, much different. Hagelin’s coming back from a broken foot/ankle. That ain’t easy for a hockey player.

Mike H: Jake Guentzal was crushed a couple times in Game 4 against the boards and seemed dazed. I know CBJ hits everything that moves but what does JG (or teammates) need to do to reduce those crushing blows.

Jason Mackey: There’s honestly not much you can do. Columbus is going to hit you. They’ve made that much apparent. And I remember the hit you’re talking about. Kyle Quincey. Nothing wrong with it. Can’t fault Quincey. ... Moving the puck quicker could/would help. However, they’re still going to happen.

Christian: What is the feeling within the organisation on Gunetzle? From what we have seen he may become the best winger Sid has had in his career. Are they as excited about him as me?

Jason Mackey: Yes, they absolutely are. They love this kid. And have for some time, to be fair. Organization is very happy with Guentzel, Sheary, Rust, Kuhnhackl ... even Sprong and Aston-Reese. In a year or two, you’re looking at a really solid crop of homegrown wingers. It’s been impressive.

Advertise with us

Matt: Now that Buffalo has cleaned house....1)Do you think Eichel forced their hand on this one? and 2) Do you think Botterill is a candidate they go after? Botterill can’t sit around too long in the same role in Pittsburgh too long I wouldn’t think.

Jason Mackey: Any team looking to make an intelligent move in its front office would be wise to call Jason Botterill. ... I’m not sure that’s the route Buffalo will go. I wouldn’t be surprised if Dean Lombardi went there. ... I don’t get the sense that Botterill is unhappy here. Not even close, actually. He’s very happy. Although like anybody in his position, he does want to be a GM one day. ... Sabres just strike me as too much of a train wreck to make a sensible move like hiring Jason.

Rob: What are your thoughts on Bylsma getting the axe?

Jason Mackey: I thought it was way too reactionary. I worry, from what I’ve heard, about Jack Eichel having entirely too much say in organizational matters. I think he’s taking the fall for a bad roster and some suspect personnel decisions. I think it’s probably better for Dan that he got the heck out of there, and I hope he lands on his feet elsewhere. My experiences with him were always positive. He was always very gracious to me, and I appreciated that.

TK: What do you think of Hainsey and Dumoulin? I think Hainsey has been their best d-man in the series. Dumoulin... not so much.

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: Yeah, Dumoulin has struggled a bit. I don’t love the pairing, but I’ll answer your question with a question: Which alternative route would you go? I wouldn’t break up Cole and Schultz. I probably wouldn’t break up Maatta and Daley. I just think Dumoulin needs to be better than he’s been this series.

Napper: I remember last year a goal was disallowed when it hit a Pens player on the bench. Were the coaches allowed to challenge the goal Columbus scored in game 3 that came back into play after bouncing off the opened door to the players bench?

Jason Mackey: I’ll be honest: I did not know that happened.

SL: Do you think Sheary has an injury? He doesn’t seem to be playing like himself lately, and was given a maintenance day recently, right?

Jason Mackey: Yes, he did. I think he’s fine. I’ve observed nothing out of the ordinary on Sheary. I think he’s putting entirely too much pressure on himself. That’s why I think he’s been playing not as well as he had been. I think he needs to relax a little bit ... which I know is much easier said than done.

Advertise with us

TK: What does Scott Wilson bring to the team? His offensive skills are lacking, to put it kindly.

Jason Mackey: I don’t disagree. I would not object to them giving Josh Archibald a shot. I like what he brings with his speed and PK ability.

Joe: A lot of fans feel like the media likes MAF as a person so much that they can’t offer a fair evaluation of his play, Do you agree with that?

Jason Mackey: No, I don’t. I like MAF a lot. Great guy. And he stunk early. Struggled to grasp this situation. I wrote as much. I can’t speak for how other media members handle their business or what they think. But I think I’ve been fair with how I’ve covered him.

Biff Bifferangadang: Boy, I really think the Pens need to end this one tonight if they want to have success in the second round (if they get there). Although injuries happen in any game against any team, I’m just waiting for a crushing injury or two from this Blue Jackets team. Plus I’m concerned the physicality could take a toll in the next series the longer this one goes on.

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: Thanks for your comments, Biff. If I were a Penguins fan, I would feel the same way. End it ASAP.

Phil philloupoupoulos: Who’s singing the national anythem tonight? Would be cool if Christina Aguilera or Daya could sing to fire the crowd up.

Jason Mackey: Jeff Jimerson. My prediction: The crowd won’t need any additional assistance getting fired up.

Wilma Flintstone: Have you seen Dino?

Jason Mackey: Have not. You?

Advertise with us

Concerned Fan: I think game 4 showed how much the team misses Letang...just not sure they can get by both BJs and Caps without him.

Jason Mackey: I think every game shows how much they miss Letang. How could they not? I disagree with the second part of your comment, though. This team is absolutely good enough to beat the Capitals without Letang. ... If they play the way they’re capable and not how they played in Game 4.

TK: When Ruhwedel’s healthy, why not substitute him for Dumo? Ruhwedel has speed, and Dumo seems to get caught flat-footed a lot.

Jason Mackey: Well, one, Ruhwedel’s not healthy. Two, I would on Dumoulin’s being better soon. Heck, I don’t think he was even bad. He was one of a few defensemen who struggled. I’m nowhere close to comfortable taking him out of the lineup. I think that’s big-time reactionary.

Matt: In light of the Marte news, you always see players in NFL and MLB get busted for substance abuse (drugs or PEDs). In your opinion, what makes NHL different in this regard? I am sure it happens, but it doesn’t seem like you ever hear of players getting busted. I am sure they have a similar testing protocol in place.

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: Let’s put it this way: The NHL does not have the most stringent policy. Many would like that to change. I would encourage you to read this from Sportsnet’s Mark Spector, a great writer and better guy.

Barney Rubble: We found him!

Jason Mackey: Whew, thank goodness!

Evgeni Rust: If Kunitz does not come back for the playoffs, is his Penguins career done?

Jason Mackey: I think so. I wonder whether he would take “Cullen money” to play here, and I think that’s the only way the Penguins would keep him. Also if Cullen actually retires, and I have doubts whether that will happen. The Penguins also have a lot of good, young wingers: Sheary, Rust, Guentzel, Sprong, Wilson, Kuhnhackl, Aston-Reese ... add in Hagelin, Hornqvist and Kessel who all get for-sure spots, and there’s not much need, especially if you want to keep Rowney.

T.J. Oshie: Assuming Pens will ride Fleury to the end with Murray’s injury...do you think though Jarry gets a look if Fleury starts falling apart, or does he only come in with an injury?

Jason Mackey: Only with an injury. Jarry has played one NHL game, and it was meaningless. It’s not an indictment of Jarry. He just doesn’t have enough experience.

me: They all talk about getting off to better starts in these games, but they never do. Any idea why that keeps happening?

Jason Mackey: Well, Columbus is trying, too. That’s one. Two, it’s just talk. What they say to us means nothing when it comes to actually playing the game. Three, I think this is a team that has a tendency on relying on its skill. Sometimes that can produce slow starts and the mindset that, “Ah, we’ll be fine. We’ll score enough.” Most of the team they can do that, but it’s not a good habit to fall into.

WNCPensfan: Read an article recently about the NHL ratings tanking this year. I am from South Carolina and currently live in North Carolina and absolutely love the Pens and the NHL. What can the league do to attract more fans? It’s by far the most exciting sport to watch in person.

Jason Mackey: I could write a book on that one. Offer a better TV product. Enforce the rulebook. Don’t have a playoff format that sends one of your top four teams home after the first round, like what’s bound to happen with Columbus. Fewer and quicker reviews. Take headshots out. Accentuate skill. I could go on.

SL: If kunitz gets healthy, does he take Wilson’s spot?

Jason Mackey: Yes, I think he does. And I’d have no problem with that. He’s horribly expensive for that spot, but you can’t do anything about that now. Kunitz would be an excellent bottom-six guy for about $1-$1.5 million right now. Only problem is that’s not even half of what he actually makes.

WNCPensfan: How would the product be better on TV? “End zone” camera angle? Agree on playoff format.

Jason Mackey: I have no problems with the camera angles, although I also wouldn’t object to trying new stuff. My issue with the game and attracting fans is that they don’t take enough logical steps to try and do that. How can I sell hockey to someone whose exposure has been limited? “Hey, check this out to watch guys block shots and hit each other in the head! The playoff format ... oh, just wait until you understand this thing. We discourage our best teams from playing on!” It’s asinine.

Mike H: The announcers on Tuesday thought Bobrovsky’s strength was pucks shot along the ice while vulnerable up high yet the Pens rarely went high. Do they know “something else” or are they trying to set up rebounds?

Jason Mackey: Good question, Mike. They might. I don’t know their scouting report on Bobrovsky. Two things. I wouldn’t discount the idea of misfires. Also, I think their issues last game were much bigger than shot placement.

SL: Thanks for all your great insights. I also really liked your suggestions for improving the game. Can you write that book, or make some sort of petition that we could all support to bring attention to those needed changes? What would it take for the game to be changed, do you think?

Jason Mackey: An act of God? I don’t know. Ha. I should whip that into something, though, you’re right. Maybe an off-day blog post or something.

PapaMC: Earlier you said you have doubts Matt Cullen will retire. is this based on speculation or any off-the-record conversations you’ve had with him? I think he’s got a few more years of good hockey left in him.

Jason Mackey: Matt has said nothing definitive on or off the record. He’s told me he’s an in-the-moment guy. Doesn’t want to think about anything too far ahead. I get that. It’s probably why he’s been able to play as long as he has, and who I am to argue? I know how he will make his decision, though. Is he healthy? Is he playing well? Does he have a chance to play somewhere that’s competitive and that he and his family enjoys? Right now the answer to all of those, as far as I know, are all yes. The Cullens absolutely love it here. He has a great setup.

WNCPensfan: I disagree on the blocked shots and physicality of the game. I could argue the NFL has been hurt by getting rid of big hits etc. Now, I know its dangerous but these are grown men that know the dangers before “signing up.” Fighting is also a big part of the game that most people like. Especially the non-playing/non-skating fans. Much like Nascar......people watch for the wreck.

Jason Mackey: I have no problem with hitting. I have a problem with illegal hitting and hits to the head.

John: Agree with you on the comments on making hockey a better product. The playoff format is ludicrous. Plus never understood the fighting part.

Jason Mackey: If I want to watch two guys fight -- I don’t -- I could watch boxing. (I don’t.)

TM: If this team is good enough to win the cup without Letang, doesn’t that diminish his importance to this team?

Jason Mackey: I don’t think so. I think it says they have a deep roster, which they do. There’s no way you can look at Letang and say he’s not a huge asset to the team. But there’s also nothing you can do. You can’t trade him. And you wouldn’t want to trade him. He’s too good. But the team around him is pretty darn special, too.

Mike H: Earlier you said you did not know that the puck hit an open door (on a CBJ goal) but you didn’t answer the second half of his question (unless I missed it). Was it reviewable?

Jason Mackey: Oh, sorry. I don’t think it is. Coaches, as I understand it, can only challenge for offside and goaltender interference. I suppose the officials could look on their own.

Mike H: I had read (can’t remember who suggested it, maybe Rossi) that if hockey wanted to be more appealing, maybe the league should prohibit players laying on the ice to block shots. I guess the idea is more shots get on net and possibly more scoring. Is that something you would favor?

Jason Mackey: Absolutely. Let the skill shine through. Let them skate and create, make plays.

Jason Mackey: OK, folks. That does it. Thank you, as always for participating. Let’s do this again next week!