Dave Molinari: OK, let's get this chat started. Folks have submitted a lot of injury-related questions (seems only right, since the Penguins have had a lot of injuries), but if you'd like to raise another issue, this would be a good time to do it.
Kevin: With Jarry not getting sent back down to WBS. Is there reason to believe that this is a move because Murray is not 100% or is it simply for depth in playoffs.
Dave Molinari: The Penguins certainly got a lot of attention when goalie Tristan Jarry was not part of the group that was returned to their farm team in Wilkes-Barre earlier today. That's especially true since Matt Murray didn't start (or back up) either game over the weekend. Whether that means Murray is injured or ill is impossible to say, and speculating about health issues is a pretty risky business. People certainly will be watching to see if Murray participates in tomorrow's practice, though. Finally, it's hard to imagine the Penguins would keep Jarry around simply for depth, when the Baby Penguins look like they could go on a long playoff run and surely would like to have their No. 1 goalie be part of it.
Matt: Dave, other than letang, who else do you see not being ready for game 1 Wednesday night?
Dave Molinari: As noted above, speculating on injuries doesn't have much upside, but at this point, it's hard to imagine that either Chris Kunitz or Carl Hagelin will be available for the opener against Columbus. Kunitz was on crutches when last seen --- that was after the Blue Jackets game last Tuesday -- and Hagelin missed the final 16 games of the regular season. Hagelin has gone on the ice a few times in recent days and that certainly bodes well for him returning at some point in the not-too-distant future, but he surely would benefit from getting in a couple of serious practices before being dropped into a playoff series.
Craig P: Any good injury news for the first round of playoffs?
Read More
Dave Molinari: The Penguins actually have gotten some of that lately, with the return of defensemen Trevor Daley and Olli Maatta. Evgeni Malkin also looks like he's ready to step back into the lineup. It was a bit of a surprise that he didn't dress for either game of the weekend, but I wonder if it was possible -- and I'm just spitballing here -- that the Penguins didn't have the salary-cap space needed to put him back on active duty. Again, that's pure speculation on my part. Just throwing out a possibility. In any case, it's moot now, because the salary cap is a non-issue during the playoffs, and there are no limits on how many players can be on a team's roster.
Chad: Hello Dave, can you please answer this for me. Why wasn’t Sid awarded an assist Saturday night on Guentzel’s goal ? He carried the puck into the offensive zone then passed to Guentzel, it touched Sheary’s stick on the way. Guentzel’s shot deflected off two Toronto players before going in the net. The two Toronto players never had possession so why didn’t Sid get an assist ? This would have given him sole possession of second place in scoring instead of being tied with Patrick Kane. I’ve seen the league correct mistakes like this in the past days later just wondering if you’ve heard anything. I’m sure Sid couldn’t care less about this but it could also have Hart voting implications, 90 points sounds a lot better than 89.
Dave Molinari: I wasn't in Toronto and did not see the goal in question, so I really can't offer an informed opinion. I also wouldn't want to second-guess the rationale of the off-ice officials in Toronto, who presumably reviewed the play closely and came to what they consider a logical and correct conclusion. In any case, I'm not sure that picking up another assist would have much of an impact on Crosby's chances of winning another Hart (as the league's MVP). Voting is just getting underway, but early indications are that Edmonton's Connor McDavid is the favorite for that award. Crosby is playing some of the finest hockey of his career, but McDavid had an exceptional season and fueled the resurgence of the Oilers in 2016-17.
Pinkie Pie: To me, the Pens defense is their biggest question mark heading into this series with Columbus. With Letang out, which player(s) do you think will raise their game to the next level?
Dave Molinari: It's a cliche, but it's also a reality: Letang isn't going to be replaced by any individual, because there is no one else on the team -- and very few in the league -- who have his skills set. That said, I think Justin Schultz will continue to be counted on more than most to help fill the offensive void created by Letang's absence, and Olli Maatta and Trevor Daley will have to elevate their games to the highest level possible to help offset being without Letang. His loss is a huge blow to the Penguins' chances of repeating -- which would be difficult enough under ideal circumstances -- but it does not have to be a mortal blow.
dave: Why doesn't Sullivan want his team to retaliate when they're getting roughed up? I think those hits have contributed to the injuries this season, and they're going to continue until the Pens do something about it.
Dave Molinari: I guess that all depends on what you mean by "retaliate." The Penguins are, for the most part, a finesse team, not a physical one. They aren't really built to punish opponents with big hits, especially with Kunitz sidelined. The best way to deter cheap shots, particularly during the playoffs, is to capitalize on the power plays they will be awarded. Do that, and other teams are going to think twice before giving the Penguins a chance with the extra man. At the same time, if the Penguins sputter when they have the man-advantage, Columbus (and any other team that might face this spring) won't have any reason to hold off on pounding them at every opportunity.
copall: Rowney, Archibald and Wilson played really well together going down the stretch. The 4th line trio proved difficult to play against, logging some nice shifts in the offensive zone (and chipping a few goals). Can't expect to keep that line of forwards together when the playoffs begin. Who do you think Sullivan will play on the 4th line once Geno (and Hagelin) return?
Dave Molinari: If the Penguins' top four centers -- Crosby, Malkin, Bonino and Cullen are available -- Rowney presumable would lose his spot in the lineup. It's also possible that Wilson will be deployed above the fourth line, depending on who is available on a given night. Archibald has made a good impression during his relative brief time at this level, and it's unlikely Sullivan would be reluctant to use him. Nonetheless, it's hard to imagine those three being used together if the Penguins are fairly healthy up front. As for the makeup of the fourth line, we should get a much better idea about that -- and some other personnel groupings -- when the Penguins practice Tuesday.
Laura: so how many seasons do you think until Jarry is a threat to Murray's starter position? 1 more? 2?
Dave Molinari: Jarry has had a terrific season in Wilkes-Barre and is one of the primary reasons the Baby Penguins have been so successful. Assuming Marc-Andre Fleury is traded or lost in the expansion draft after this season, Jarry is a worthy candidate to serve as Matt Murray's backup. At this stage of his development, though, there's not much reason to think that he's a threat to supplant Murray as the Penguins' go-to goalie anytime soon. (With the proviso that I would have said the same thing little more than a year ago about the chances of Murray wresting the No. 1 job from Fleury.)
SL: Why do you think Geno said he was feeling good and wanting to play, but then did not play over the weekend? Do you think he's still not at 100%, or just that Sullivan didn't want to risk any new injury during meaningless games?
Dave Molinari: The theory I floated a bit earlier in the chat -- that the Penguins didn't have enough salary-cap space to add Malkin to the active roster -- might explain why he didn't get into uniform, despite appearing to be ready to resume playing. Then again, it's possible that he was not quite 100 percent recovered from his shoulder problem and Sullivan didn't want to risk having him get hurt in a game that didn't matter. As with so many other things, we should get a better feel for Malkin's status during Tuesday's practice.
TK: A few weeks ago, Sullivan said Letang had a "typical hockey injury". Do you think a herniated disc that requires surgery a typical hockey injury?
Dave Molinari: I don't think disc issues are all that uncommon for hockey players, but I do believe that it's relatively rare that they have to be surgically corrected. Remember, the Penguins said that, until about a week ago, Letang seemed to be progressing well via therapy. Until evidence to the contrary surfaces, I see no reason that they shouldn't be taken at their word. I'm not sure what the team would stand to gain by misleading people about Letang's back issue.
SL: Given how physical the CBJ team plays, do you think the Pens will include Sestito in the lineup? (I saw that he was not sent back down to WBS - do you think that means he's a real possibility for the lineup?)
Dave Molinari: There's no question that the Blue Jackets will try to hit the Penguins at every opportunity, but I will be surprised if the Penguins dress Sestito as a deterrent (especially if they have a surplus of healthy forwards).
Dave Molinari: Our time is up, guys. Thanks for all the terrific questions. Let's do it again next Monday, by which time we should have a pretty good idea of how Round 1 is going.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.