Jason Mackey: Hi folks. Just landed. Need to get to a Panera or something, and we'll do this. Lots to talk about. Leave a question. I'll be back at 2 to answer.
The Dude: In competition for the obvious, what do you think of the acquisition of the 2 new defensemen and how much will they help?
Jason Mackey: The Dude abides. ... Lebowski, awesome, awesome movie. ... To your question: I like them. I think Streit could be good for someone like Pouliot. Talked to Derrick about that last night, actually. I like Corrado as a project. I think it's something you can do when you have Sergei Gonchar working for you. As for who plays if everyone is healthy, that's a really good question. I don't have an answer yet.
AJ: Do you have any more information about Letang's injury? He was day to day and a game time decision but now seems to be much further away from returning. If he is out long term, what d-pairings do you see? The Cole/Schultz pairing looked a little overwhelmed yesterday.
Jason Mackey: Hi AJ, if I had more information, I would report it. It does neither me nor the PG any good to purposefully withhold information. Do want to correct one thing: He was never a "game-time decision." He was day-to-day, which is a step below in the Mike Sullivan Hierarchy of Injuries. Does it seem like he's taken a step back? Yes. Do I think things sound fishy? Yes. But I don't have access to Letang's medical charts, and NHL teams aren't required to be even close to forthright with injuries the way they are in other pro sports.
Guest: Jason, have you even ever been to an Arby's? Sometimes some of the stuff you say makes me think you've never even heard of it.
Read More
Jason Mackey: I have been to Arby's, yes.
Guest: The loss yesterday by the Pens was embarrassing, Jason. I barely had the nerve to show my face at work. What the heck happened? I'm ashamed. May leave work early. What went wrong?
Jason Mackey: Sam, is that you again?
1: Can Crosby lead this team to another Stanley Cup, not in general, but this season? It is a Herculean task fro any hockey player to go back to back ? And then what if a Three-Peat?
Jason Mackey: I zero doubts in Crosby's ability to lead this team to a Stanley Cup. That said, it takes a total effort and a positive confluence of events. I can't say for sure whether that will all happen, but I'm 100 percent confident saying Crosby is capable. I'm also 100 percent confident that it's too early to be talking about a three-peat.
Scott: Do you think the coaching staff realizes they screwed up by handing Jarvis Jones the starting role year after year when he did nothing to earn it? Young guys should have to work for playing time. JJ was never asked to.
Jason Mackey: I'd be willing to bet the Penguins coaches were not aware they had screwed up Jarvis Jones' development.
record: A little while back in one of these chats, you claimed that the Grateful Dead had no connection whatsoever with Patty Hearst. What you failed to mention (the TRUTH) is that the Dead and Hearst had the same powerful lawyer William Coblentz. My only question is why did not admit to this? What on earth could you be trying to cover up? I don't think that the Dead's obvious connection to Hearst is necessarily an indictment of their quality as a band, but you must.
Jason Mackey: I did not know that. Thanks for pointing out.
What: What happened to the Carolina Hurricanes? At one point they were a team on the rise and now they stink!
Jason Mackey: Good question. 2-5-3 in their last 10 = not good. There are more factors than I can take the time to name here, but the Hurricanes have struggled to score goals. They're good on the PK. Do some other things well. But offensive firepower is not exactly their thing.
Guest: To a point you made at some point in the past, I guess my biggest complaint with your comparison of Miles Davis to the Grateful Dead is that they are, regardless of influence, from very different genres of music. I think that a more apt comparison for the Dead would be the J. Geils Band. Sure, we all can see the comparisons clearly with their singles, like Love Stinks or Centerfold, but if you get deeper into their cuts and B-sides they are actually a pretty wailing jam band with a very Dead style sound. And the thing is that Geils himself is nearly the same age as Garcia, but was exposed to jazz long before Jerry ever heard it. So, I'm wondering if you knew much about this J Geils band influence on the Dead or have any thoughts of your own on the matter?
Jason Mackey: I did not know about this, and I don't have many thoughts of my own on the matter.
Guest: Also, did Jerry Garcia have diabetes?
Jason Mackey: Believe so, yes.
Guest: In your opinion, did Eric Lindros deserve to be in the Hall of Fame? I mean, I've always seen him as an underachiever whose hype never matched his actual play on the ice.
Jason Mackey: I don't disagree with you. I've also thought Lindros was one of those mythical figures that everyone just decides they have fallen in love with, then don't want to change for whatever reason. I guess I'm not against him being in the HOF, but I'm not head over heels for him the way some others are.
roger: now that the game at PNC was a total disaster, is the NHL done with the winter classic outdoor games finally?
Jason Mackey: The NHL isn't done with outdoor games. There also wasn't a game at PNC Park, nor was the one at Heinz Field a disaster by any stretch. It also wasn't a Winter Classic. I'm not sure what you're getting at here. If you're hoping the NHL gets rid of outdoor hockey, that's not going to happen. Especially not when 67,318 show up to watch it.
Guest: If Marc Andre Fleury gets traded, will it be the first time in NHL history that a #1 overall pick has been traded?
Jason Mackey: It won't be the first. Yakupov and Hall were dealt this past offseason. Erik Johnson and Rick Nash before that. It is rare, but this won't be the first time.
pens 2017: hey Jason, I know you usually talk Dead music on hear, but I saw what you said about Pantera. Glad to hear you like the hard rock too, man! I've been a fan for decades now. Love them. Anyway, I'm wondering who you would give the "under the radar" team MVP to this year? Kind of like a 6th man for hockey? Thanks!
Jason Mackey: Under the radar? Hmm. That's a good one. You know, I'm going with Tampa. 7-1-2 in its past 10. I'm not selling just yet, even though it seems that's what they're doing. Crazier things have happened.
Guest: Can we beat the LIghtning tomorrow? I have a bad feeling about this. Need to bounce back from yesterday.
Jason Mackey: Yes. I think the Penguins will be fine. ... Even though I know I just said the Lightning are under the radar. The Penguins are a better team, especially on home ice. I think they recognize the importance of a "bounce back," although I'd also argue that they didn't play as poorly as a 4-1 score might indicate, a thought echoed by many actually playing the game.
sorry to see it: Sorry to see you mention eating at Panera, Jason. I live in California and if you read about their 2009 & 2011 class action lawsuits brought on by Panera employees against the company, you might not want to support them. I'm talking about a $5M payout to employees over mismanagement and working conditions. Just try to be more socially responsible, man, both as a newsman and a DeadHead. Anyway, bro, do you think the Pens can go 2-0 over this brief homestand? Thanks. And I'm sorry if I harshed your mellow or ruined your lunch.
Jason Mackey: I'm actually at Crazy Mocha, if that makes you feel better. Yes, I do. Easily. If they play the way they did for much of last night's game, they'll be just fine.
Guest: Do you see it as fitting that the Penguins will close out the regular season in Edmonton?
Jason Mackey: Unless you know something I don't, the Penguins close out the regular season in Manhattan. Hope so, anyway, considering I have flights and a hotel booked.
Guest: Frank Corrado - a future All Star or a minor league bum for life?
Jason Mackey: How about somewhere in the middle?
cool!: Thanks for the chats and I love Panera too! What is your go-to item? I get one of the salads every time. Can't remember the name of it unless I see it on the menu. Will the Penguins regret their recent trades in say a few years. Seems like short term payoff for long term pain?
Jason Mackey: I go with the You Pick Two, french union soup and chipotle chicken. I don't think they'll regret them. Especially not if they go on and win the Stanley Cup. Streit and Hainsey are both UFAs after the season. It's not like they're going to be around for four years at an unreasonable rate. Both of their former teams are taking back significant money. And if the Penguins one day look back and say, "Man, we frittered away all of our draft picks," I have a tough time pinning that problem o the Hainsey/Streit deals.
Guest: I saw that Paul Zeise can do a rubicks cube in like 2 minutes. Do you have any secret talents?
Jason Mackey: I have very few talents, secret or right out there in the open.
Guest: Does the NHL hold a Combine similar to what the NFL does?
Jason Mackey: They do. The Penguins have actually pitched to hold it, although the NHL is pretty happy with the setup it has in Buffalo.
me: The Fehr trade was basically a salary dump, wasn't it?
Jason Mackey: Yeah, it was. Rutherford acknowledged as much last night. The other issue is that Fehr no longer fits their style. He was acquired while Mike Johnston was still the coach and they didn't truly emphasize speed. They pivoted mid-contract for him. Trading Fehr puts him in a better spot and allows the Penguins to get that money back.
HB: Would it of cost more to get duchene compared to what it took to land kessel?
Jason Mackey: That's tough to say. I'm not completely sure of Colorado's demands. All I know is they're steep and they were not met. I suppose we won't have a firm answer until the deal actually happens, but I don't think they should be as high as what the Leafs got for Kessel. I think Kessel is a better player than Duchene.
HB: Are the reports true that the Blues wanted sundqvist and picks for the pens to get shattenkirk?
Jason Mackey: I have not heard that. Please feel free to share a link to what you're referring to.
Guest: I personally don't let my kids listen to rock music because of what it did to my life, but despite my hearing loss I am still a fan of hockey and the NHL in general. So I get your writing and I like your chats and attitude. I used to know a guy named Jason Mackey funnily enough back in California when I was working for a few groups as a west coast roadie, but this was in the 70s so I know it is a different guy. Also, he was not a hockey fan. Anyway, I'm curious who you have winning the Western Conference this year and repping them in the Stanley Cup?
Jason Mackey: I'm going with Chicago. I also think a Penguins/Blackhawks Stanley Cup Final would be wildly entertaining.
JamesinNYC: Seemed like a lot to give up Carrado...a salary dump or is Coach a fan of his?
Jason Mackey: Salary dump. The Penguins also have the ability with Sergei Gonchar to take defensemen and fix them. He did wonders with Justin Schultz. They're counting on the same thing here.
Guest: If you go to Arby's so much, then why don't you mention it ever?
Jason Mackey: I didn't say I go a lot. I said I've been there before.
Suzie: Now that the trade deadline is over, what's the first thing you're going to do? (Don't say, "Go to Disney World.")
Jason Mackey: Go on a date with my wife. Suggestions? I'm guessing someone's going to say Arby's.
Jake: Hi Jason! Big fan of your work. My question to you is of the three defensemen picked up at the deadline, who do you see as having the most short term impact, and do you see any of the three being something to consider for the long term?
Jason Mackey: Hey Jake. Thank you for that. I think Hainsey will have the most short-term impact. Streit could, but I've really liked Hainsey's game so far, especially last night. As for long-term, I think that's Corrado. I'm interested to see what he comes out looking like when we get to next season.
JamesinNYC: Is it true that you ratted out the Pens to PETA? Heard you going all tree hugger on the Adam Crowley show. ;-)
Jason Mackey: I said nothing to PETA, the Pens or the NHL. My personal views matter not at all in reporting. It was also the NHL's call, not the Penguins'. If you ask me whether I agree with having live penguins at a hockey game, no, I absolutely don't agree with that and stand by what I said to Crowley and Colin Dunlap on the Fan. It's not worth it. We can be entertained other ways. There's no need.
Guest: Do you think it's buy-in to the coaching staff's game plan that's gone array or just the really bad streak of injuries? The pens have had periods of looking really good but nothing consistent… We're just starting March, now is the time for them to turn it on and "just play". (Which, they are playing and they're not buying in to all the bs all the time, but they seem too lax with the puck. They're not driving play they were last year).
Jason Mackey: I don't think this group lacks buy-in. I do think the NHL season is grueling. You're going to have clunkers. They're still very much in the division race. Could the puck management be better? Yes, I agree with that. I think they could be better away from the puck. Their PK could improve. Lots of things. But it doesn't scream to be no adhering to the coaching staff or anything like that.
Guest: I saw the Patty Hearst question from a guest earlier, I'm confused, did you seek to cover up the matter of the band and Hearst sharing a lawyer or are you claiming simple ignorance on the matter?
Jason Mackey: I'm claiming a combination of ignorance and the fact that this is supposed to be a Penguins chat.
me: Why did they decide to call up Pouliot? Is he better than the other guys they called up?
Jason Mackey: They needed someone for last night, first off. They could have had Gaunce play, but I don't think they were terribly happy with what he did the night before. As Sullivan put it, the Penguins were happy with the "traction" he gained in his game. And sooner or later, you have to give him a chance to prove himself. I think the final 20 games will be proving ground for Streit and Hainsey, to try and earn playoff jobs, and I think they want Pouliot to make his push, too, while Maatta and Daley are out.
Guest: With the play of Carter Rowney, last year's play of Sundqvist… do you think the pens resign Bonino in the summer? I could see Sundqvist being our third line center with Rowney as our fourth. Especially, if say… Matt Cullen opted for another go around?
Jason Mackey: I think that's entirely possible. A lot will depend on what Bonino does in the playoffs and what he's offered elsewhere. I know the Penguins would like to sign Justin Schultz. That money has to come from somewhere. Bottom-six center is actually a position they have some prospects at. Why not use them and try to re-purpose that money elsewhere?
Guest: Panera Bread? You're even more of a corporate sellout than I thought, Mackey? Why not eat at a local restaurant like Jessy's or Willie's Coffee on 6th?
Jason Mackey: I am sorry to disappoint you. I chose Crazy Mocha in Brentwood, but I'm guessing that still makes me a failure. Somehow.
Tom K.: With a Penguins chat, why do you waste our time with old band talk?
Jason Mackey: I like including everyone. I believe if you're willing to stop by and hang out, you deserve to get a response. I also don't agree with telling people what to ask.
Guest: Seemed like you were a little short with the guy who asked about J. Geils. I'm wondering if you were irritated for some reason?
Jason Mackey: I was not. I simply haven't listened to enough J. Geils Band to levy anything close to an educated response.
Pope: Which defensemen are under contract and return next year? Do you think the Pens make signing Shultz a priority? Does daley return?
Jason Mackey: I think they will get something done with Justin Schultz. Ian Cole, to me, looks like a prime candidate for Vegas. I think they'd like to protect Schultz, Dumoulin and Maatta; they have to protect Letang. There are ways around it with who you sign when, etc. I'm growing more and more skeptical whether they try to retain Daley. A guy like Ethan Prow in the minors. Maybe Pouliot. Maybe Ruhwedel. Seems you can get by with cheaper options there.
Guest: Yesterday on twitter I saw that a bunch of the baby pens were made available for the AHL play offs (including Pouliot) but that Ruhwedel was not because he has to clear waivers? Can you explain the whole process of that please? Do you think the pens are actually in danger of losing him if he was put on waivers to head back to the AHL or they just don't care to risk it? With all the D we have now, there's not much reason to utilize him as the 7th man when everyone's healthy.
Jason Mackey: You're right, but that's also going to be a bit -- like the end of the regular season. A lot can happen between now and then. I believe Ruhwedel would have to clear waivers -- don't quote me on that -- to return to the AHL, but I'm not sure that's much of a concern at this point.
Pope: Who are the top 6 defensemen next year for the Pens? Who leaves? Who is re-signed? Does anyone get exposed to vegas?
Jason Mackey: Really hard to say seeing only a couple games from Hainsey, none from Streit, never seeing Corrado live, the Maatta, Letang and Daley injuries, another playoff to change things. I think Letang, Dumoulin, Maatta and Schultz will be around. Beyond that, it gets dicey.
me: What would you change to get the PP going?
Jason Mackey: I think they should start scoring more. Better yet, start actually getting on the power play. ... I kid, I kid. ... I'd like to see them shoot a ton, honestly. Nothing fancy. No over-passing. Make a point of it. Just fire everything you can at the net. I don't even care if some of it's best. Just simplify things.
Pope: Will Daley and Cullen be back with the Pens next season? One? Both? neither?
Jason Mackey: Cullen is tough. That's going to be his own personal choice, and he's not going to figure that out until the summer. If he wants to play, the Penguins will sign him. Daley is easier to read. For what he'll make, and what they'll probably have to pay other players like Schultz, I think it might make more sense to let Daley walk.
JamesinNYC: I have always been torn with the Sea World protests....there are some positives ...education, appreciation, awareness but I also feel bad for the animals. I have to agree with you the Penguins were unnecessary.
Jason Mackey: I don't love zoos, but I'm slightly more OK with them than driving live penguins to a football field and setting off explosives. What if someone took you somewhere that you didn't recognize, offered no explanations then started setting off explosives out of nowhere? And for what? So we all could giggle and think how cute it is that they're waddling? I just don't get it. You have the glorious history of the Penguins. There's nothing else there to mine?
Pope: Which forwards are in danger of being exposed to vegas?
Jason Mackey: The one I think is the most interesting is Oskar Sundqvist, who's eligible because of his time spent in Sweden's pro league. If I'm an opposing team, I'm taking a long look at a tall, strong center who's good defensively, good on draws and has a pretty decent amount of offensive upside. In addition, of course, to being young and cheap.
Guest: any chance you can do these more often than once a week? I really enjoy getting your perspective on the team in such an interactive way.
Jason Mackey: I think we may increase the frequency during the playoffs or during the stretch run. Believe me, I like them, too.
TK: After the season ends, how long is it before they have to declare who they're protecting in the expansion draft? I'm wondering how long the window will be for them to do something with Fleury.
Jason Mackey: Teams have to submit their protected lists by June 17. So a couple weeks after the end of the playoffs.
Guest: I'm really troubled by Sullivan's use of players. Kunitz just kills the first line. Hornqvist works better with Sid than Geno, Bonino and Keseel have not worked like last year. It's like he's either stubborn or doesn't seem to know what to do. Have you guys addressed these issues with him and what's his response?
Jason Mackey: Have we addressed these issues? Are we supposed to inform Sullivan that he's using his players wrong? How about we ask questions and report on what he's thinking or doing? Then using numbers and facts to provide context. ... Anyway, my argument for this sort of thing usually is: Who else would you put on Crosby's left wing with Sheary out? Wilson? Guentzel? When Sheary comes back, which could come Friday, Kunitz will become a fourth-liner again. Personally I like Guentzel with Crosby better than anyone else. Especially with Crosby and Sheary. ... Malkin, in my opinion, has been plenty productive with Hornqvist, although I would like to see a more recent sample of Kessel with Malkin.
Pope: any chance the pens can look to sign Duchene this summer? Losing Fluery and possibly Kunitz, Cullen, Bonino & Daley off the books should help. If Cullen and Bonino do not return and Sundqvist is the 4th line C, we could use a 3rd line C...
Jason Mackey: You present a really good question now that Duchene didn't move. I wouldn't rule it out, but I also think the Penguins would like to sign Schultz. What's he get? Plus, they're going to lock up Sheary and Dumoulin. Those will cost $$$. Is there enough left over to fit Duchene. I have some doubts there.
TM: Fans and even some media are in panic mode about the Letang injury, speculating it is a concusion, or even worse, especially after Jim Rutherford's vague response yesterday about not knowing how long Letang will be out. Do you sense panic among the organization?
Jason Mackey: I wouldn't say panic. Is everyone on the same page with where he's at? That's where I'd be concerned. Rutherford's response was weird because it clashed with Sullivan's nothing-to-see-here sort of updates we've been getting daily. The fact that he didn't skate yesterday seemed somewhat uneventful until Rutherford's response. I'll say this: They're pretty good about announcing if it's a concussion. (Which, to me, is crazy because all hockey teams, not just the Penguins, are super secretive about injuries ... unless it's your brain.) But the Penguins have typically gone UBI, LBI or concussion for injury distinctions.
Guest: I was a reporter before too. Your job is to get the truth behind the bull that is being put out there, not just to report without any insight what Sullivan has to say. Go out there and the tough questions and try to get some insight about why this team looks like it's going to fold in the first round right now, including Sully's bench management. That's one problem that can be corrected, unlike injuries and that might help the team play better
Jason Mackey: Cutting through the BS and maintaining workable, daily relationships with folks by treating them with the same professional courtesy you'd like to get are two totally different things. ... Think about it: If Sullivan likes the way they played last night and you didn't ... what do you want me to do? Challenge him to a fight until he says what you want to hear? He's entitled to his opinion, and let's face it: He knows more than both of us combined. It's my job to report on things, to ask questions (yes, tough ones) and provide facts or numbers to illustrate what is or isn't happening. It's not to be insulting or purposefully confrontational of Sullivan, his players or anyone around the organization.
Tom Chorske: With 10 NHL games under his belt, how has Carter Rowney looked?
Jason Mackey: I think the first three were better than the last seven. But that's also not uncommon for guys making that transition. It also hasn't helped that he hasn't received a steady stream of playing time. When Conor Sheary comes back, I think Rowney could get sent down. I think it might not be the worst thing for him to take this experience, learn from it and fix a few things.
Tom Chorske: Please put Sullivan in a headlock until he promises to guide the penguins to a cup this year.
Jason Mackey: Yeah, and give him a noogie or something. Sounds like that's what my job's supposed to be. And who are we kidding, it would be a crime to mess with that hair. ... On that note, folks, I'm out of here. Thanks for hanging out, as always. Time to take some time away and re-introduce myself to my family. Be well.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.