Dave Molinari: OK, let's get this chat started. As always, you guys have raised some really interesting subjects to discuss over the next half-hour, but there's always room for a good question. If you have one, pass it along.
ronesz: Hi, Dave. What is your take on the Geno snub? What do you think, will Geno comment on it? Thanks!
Dave Molinari: For those who might not have been paying close attention over the weekend -- although, really, who could not be smitten with every second of an all-star weekend? -- Evgeni Malkin was left off the list of the top 100 players in NHL history, as presented by the league. He was perhaps the most surprising omission, although a good case could be made for guys like Dale Hawerchuk and Pierre Pilote, among others. It might be a while before we know what Malkin is willing to say about being overlooked, since he's injured and the Penguins don't make players available to the media until they resume practicing with the team. That said, every such list has players who could/should have been included, but weren't, so I don't that being left off will send Malkin into a deep depression.
Andy: When do you think we'll see Letang and who will be the odd man out when he does return? Do you agree that Schultz has been better than Letang on the PP this year and should remain there?
Dave Molinari: We should get a better idea of Kris Letang's status when the Penguins have their first post-all-star practice later this afternoon. The fact that he has resumed practicing with the team suggests that his return probably isn't far off. Whether it will happen when Nashville visits PPG Paints Arena Tuesday night is hard to say at this point. And while Justin Schultz has exceeded expectations in every facet of his game this season, I won't be surprised if Letang ends up back in his customary spot on the No. 1 power play, even if it doesn't happen immediately after he gets back in uniform.
Matt: Dave after he returns from injury, any chance we will see Oskar Sundqvist get called up this year? I think he could be another great young player to come up for the playoffs.
Read More
Dave Molinari: That probably will hinge, in large part, on whether the Penguins' centers are able to get healthy and stay that way. (At the moment, both Evgeni Malkin and Matt Cullen are injured.) Sundqvist, though, is having an excellent season in Wilkes-Barre. He has 14 goals and 19 assists in 39 games, tying him for second on the team in scoring. That would be impressive enough, but before this season, Sundqvist's greatest strength was his defensive game. Adding an offensive dimension, as he has, can only enhance his potential. He's played well enough that management will have an interesting decision to make when it settles on the format of players to be protected for the expansion draft. If they would expose Sundqvist, it wouldn't be hard to imagine Las Vegas claiming him. He's the kind of good two-way center who could contribute in the league for a long time.
Phil the Trill: If the Penguins are unable to trade Fleury shoud they buy out him?
Dave Molinari: It seems reasonably certain that the Penguins have settled on Matt Murray as their goalie of the future, and will take whatever step(s) are necessary to make sure they don't lose him in the expansion draft. Fleury has a limited no-trade clause, which could complicate efforts to deal him (it should be noted that there's no indication GM Jim Rutherford has been shopping him), but there are enough teams in the league that could use a goaltending upgrade that there should be a market for him if the Penguins decide he must be traded.
Laura: Other All Star Weekend story: Bettman seemed to be talking around the point that he/league won't allow NHLers to participate in the Olympics with a break as usual. Do you see Penguins (Crosby, Malkin, etc) still attending even if there were NHL games held during the Olympics & consequences for missing them?
Dave Molinari: Crosby and Malkin both seem to have enjoyed their Olympic experiences (Crosby has two gold medals to show for it, so what's not to like?) and surely would like to participate again in the 2018 Games in South Korea. To my knowledge, neither has said that he would attend under any circumstances -- regardless of the punishment that he might receive for doing so -- but Washington's Alex Ovechkin seems to be the only guy who has taken such a strong stance so far. (If I'm not mistaken, he has the blessing of Capitals owner Ted Leonsis.) My guess is that if Crosby and Malkin really were adamant about playing, even if the NHL didn't agree to send players, they would get permission from ownership. I'm not convinced, though, that either would push the issue to that extent.
Yuck: I felt like I needed a shower after watching Sid and Ovechkin playing on the same line over and over. I was ecstatic to see that there is absolutely no chemistry between the two. Even if they both play until they're 70 there is zero chance of them ever playing on the same team and that made feel a little less icky. Joking aside, the Caps seem even stronger than last year. What do the Pens do, if anything, to increase their chances of ousting the Caps once again this playoff season?
Dave Molinari: Happily for you, it seems, there's not much chance of Crosby and Ovechkin even being linemates, aside from the occasional all-star game. My hunch is that if they did play together for a while, they would develop a feel for one another's game and form an almost unstoppable tandem. That will remain hypothetical, however, unlike the possibility of another Penguins-Capitals meeting in the playoffs. The best thing the Penguins could do to prepare for any playoff series is to be healthy; their roster could use an upgrade or two, but there are no glaring flaws that would doom it in the playoffs. Washington has been very impressive so far this season, though, and likely would have home ice in any playoff matchup with the Penguins. Then again, the Capitals have had that before, and the Penguins generally find a way to prevail. Suffice to say, though, that if they meet again this spring, it should be a competitive, entertaining series.
Andy: Any news on whether we'll see Malkin play tomorrow, or when we can expect him?
Dave Molinari: As noted earlier about Kris Letang, it's possible that we'll get a better sense of Malkin's status when the Penguins practice later this afternoon. He hasn't practiced with his teammates since being injured, though, so it seems like he'd be a long shot to play Tuesday night, even if he's over his unspecified injury.
Andy: Why is Sullivan stubbornly sticking to two lines that all the analytics as well as the eye test are saying do not work? Every stat out there shows HBK has been dreadful, and that Crosby-Rust is not good either. Bonino should be benched and Rust should be moved off the top line and that's obvious to anyone who watches the game. Yet Sullivan is being Bylsma-esque in forcing these lines. What gives?
Dave Molinari: When a team is reasonably certain of qualifying for the playoffs, the regular season is a good opportunity to experiment and settle on personnel combinations that can be used in the postseason. The Hagelin-Bonino-Kessel line certainly hasn't produced this season the way it did during the Penguins' playoff drive in 2016, but that precedent makes it clear that those three have the potential to be a formidable line when they're in sync. And salary-cap limitations routinely prevent teams, including the Penguins, from assembling ideal forward combinations (or defense pairings, for that matter).
Dave Molinari: Every team would like to upgrade its defense (that's why there will be inflated asking prices for defensemen as the trade deadline approaches), but the Penguins won a Stanley Cup last year with a defense almost identical to this one (aside from Ben Lovejoy) so if their defensemen can be reasonably healthy in the playoffs, it should be good enough to allow them to contend again.
Laura: I'm sure there won't be any further quotes from the organization, but how fired up do you think the NHL100 snub will make Malkin for the rest of the season?
Rob: Need to upgrade defense.
Dave Molinari: A lot of athletes will use anything they can for motivation, and Malkin probably was stung a bit by being overlooked, but he's a pro and a veteran. I doubt that he needs something like being left off that list to get himself mentally prepared to play.
Andy: Dave, I was outraged to see that Malkin didn't make the top 100 players list? I mean three Blackhawks among recent players and none of them better than Geno. He has the hardware and two Cups. I don't understand that hate, do you? He's such an obvious choice. This is why people hate the NHL
Dave Molinari: Wow, this is a popular topic today. Obviously, picking the people to appear on such lists is subjective, and a good case can be made for including (or excluding) many candidates. While Malkin has won a number of individual honors and a couple of Stanley Cup, it probably didn't hurt Jonathan Toews, Patrick Kane and Duncan Keith that the Blackhawks have won three Stanley Cups in recent years.
Dave Molinari: Another chat has flown by. Thanks for all the great questions, and let's do it again next week.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.