When Jim Rutherford played goalie for the Penguins from 1971-74, the team lost more games than it won.
Those were the early days of the franchise, when just making the playoffs was cause for celebration. Winning the Stanley Cup was truly pie-in-the-sky stuff.
So when Rutherford saw an estimated 400,000 people pack Downtown June 15, he found a new meaning for what Pittsburgh’s sports teams mean to the city.
“I had an appreciation for what a great sports town it was,” Rutherford said. “Obviously didn’t get the appreciation of winning a championship and seeing it firsthand.”
A few pickup trucks away from him was Mike Sullivan, a native Bostonian who had only moved to the city a few months back. Sullivan’s playing career never landed him in Pittsburgh, so he got to know the city as he guided the Penguins to the Stanley Cup last spring.
“To be in the back of a pickup truck and to see the appreciation that the fans showed to our players and our team, it was overwhelming,” Sullivan said. “It was emotional. There were people hanging out of parking garages and out of buildings. For that volume of people, in a relatively small city, to show the support that they showed for this team, I know — to a man — every guy that went through that experience was so appreciative of the fan support that we get here in this city.”
Read More
For their combined efforts of guiding the Penguins to their fourth Stanley Cup championship — especially in a year that seemed poised to end in disaster a few months prior — Rutherford and Sullivan have been named the Dapper Dan Co-Sportsmen of the Year.
“It’s a great honor,” Rutherford said. “It’s even more special to me to share the award with Sully. Because he was a big part of the turning part of getting to where we needed to get to last year.
“When you look at where we were and what we needed to do turn it around, he came in and he got the ship going in the right direction. That’s special to me that I share this award with him.”
When Rutherford hired Sullivan to replace Mike Johnston on Dec. 12, 2015, the Penguins really were in dire straits. On the outside of the playoff picture, nine points adrift from first place in the Eastern Conference. They even lost the first four games Sullivan coached, and dropped as far as 12th in the conference.
Still, Rutherford could see immediately that Sullivan — whom he hired to coach in AHL Wilkes-Barre/Scranton at the beginning of the season — was pulling the right strings.
“I could see right from the start with what he was trying to do and with his communication, approach to the players, that this was going to get better,” Rutherford said. “To what extent, we had to wait and see. But there was no concern.”
For his part Sullivan said he didn’t put any big-picture ideas on the table right away, necessarily, but was mostly focused on alleviating some of the pent-up pressure inside the Penguins’ dressing room.
“How do I effect some change to the mindset or the psyche of the group?” Sullivan said. “Because any time a coaching change is made, it’s usually because expectations haven’t been met and it makes for a very difficult environment for everybody to go to work in.”
He worked to try to take away some of that weight, because he recognized the talent Rutherford had assembled had a chance to be good — really good, even — if, as Sullivan put it, they could just play more instinctively.
While Sullivan took over on implementing his culture and system, Rutherford went to work tinkering with the roster to make it truly championship-caliber. He had already brought in winger Phil Kessel, maligned and misunderstood in Toronto, in the offseason, and followed that up by acquiring defensemen Trevor Daley and Justin Schultz, as well as winger Carl Hagelin, during the year.
As the Penguins stampeded into the playoffs — going 16-2-0 in their last 18 games — both Sullivan and Rutherford knew they had something potentially special on their hands.
“Once there was a little daylight [in the playoff race], where I felt very comfortable we were going to make it, I knew as long as we were going to make it, we had as good a chance as anybody,” Rutherford said.
The potential, at least within the dressing room, ratcheted up another notch when the Penguins took down the rival Capitals in the second round of the playoffs.
“I think the players, their belief went to a whole other level, that we’re a really good hockey team and that we’re capable of beating anyone when we play the game a certain way,” Sullivan.
The Penguins didn’t just beat anybody last season, they beat everybody. A 3-1 victory in Game 6 of the final in San Jose clinched the franchise’s fourth title and sent everyone — from players to the front office — onto the ice at the SAP Center in a flurry of hugs and high fives.
“When that final buzzer went and everybody was congratulating everybody,” Rutherford said. “That was very special.”
The Penguins are hoping for another moment like that this spring, and in the years to come. When Rutherford was hired in 2014, he said he would likely only hold the job for a few years. But he signed a contract extension through 2019 this summer, and has since amended those original plans to get rid of any firm timetable for his future.
With the Penguins firmly in contention for another Stanley Cup, Sullivan doesn’t appear to be going anywhere anytime soon, either. If all goes well, this duo could end up helming the Penguins for years to come.
“As long as my bosses, the ownership and [Penguins CEO] David Morehouse feel I can help the team, and I feel I can help, I’m healthy, I’ll continue on as long as I can,” Rutherford said. “How long that is, I don’t know.
“I don’t have any timeframe in mind. I feel really good. I’m treated very well here, and I love the city.”
As the Penguins’ parade through Downtown last spring proved, the feeling is mutual.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.