As Steve Oleksy dined with a few buddies from back home two summers ago, sipping on cranberry soda water while they slugged beers, Oleksy reluctantly agreed to try alcohol on one condition: If it came from the Stanley Cup.
Fast forward to the following June. SAP Center, San Jose. The Penguins are celebrating the franchise’s fourth Cup. Sidney Crosby is doling out drinks.
“It was my turn,” Oleksy recalled, “and I figured, ‘This has to be it.' ”
So he drank, and there’s never been a desire to try more. Oleksy, the same as before he became a Stanley Cup champion, doesn’t feel he needs booze to have a good time.
The point here is that as much of a wild man as Oleksy can be on the ice – did you see that fight with New Jersey’s Miles Wood before Christmas? – he’s the polar opposite off of it, much like many NHL enforcers.
These guys are here to enforce the NHL’s unwritten code, to protect star players, to give their teams a boost at key times, and sometimes that involves punching another human being in the face with their bare knuckles. But that doesn’t mean they have to be jerks. Or nuts. They’re often some of the most well-liked, approachable and caring guys in the room.
Read More
“I think it goes hand-in-hand with them being willing to stand up for their teammates,” Oleksy said. “It’s a great stress reliever sometimes, too. That might be why they’re so even-keeled off the ice.”
Ask Oleksy for a few minutes of his time, and you’re bound to be reminded that you’re not bothering him. You’re never bothering him. He has time. Please, sit down.
Perhaps it’s a testament to the long, strange trip he’s taken to get here, an appreciation that things like an NHL career don’t come easy.
Oleksy actually started out as a baseball player in Chesterfield Township, Mich., about 45 minutes outside of Detroit, before ditching his catcher’s mitt to concentrate on hockey full-time, a sport he admits he probably wasn’t as good at but loved more.
After pursuing his only college offer, to Lake Superior State, Oleksy signed a contract to play in the East Coast Hockey League and found himself alongside 13 or 14 other defenseman who had a similar skill set. Oleksy knew he had to do something to stand out.
“My first fight in camp was a guy who was 6-7, 245,” Oleksy said. “I did pretty well. Couple shifts later, I fought again. Another pretty tough guy. Did well again. From there, my first year I kind of fought heavyweights.
“You don’t want say it’s a pressure-free fight, but those are fights you’re not supposed to win.”
Oleksy wound up with 173 combined penalty minutes with the Idaho Steelheads in the ECHL and the Lake Erie Monsters of the AHL in 2010-11 while learning the tricks of the fighting trade from a guy named Adam Huxley, who fought 27 times that season.
The previous six seasons before this one, Oleksy has averaged 144 penalty minutes while often cozying up to more established fighters, hoping to learn anything he can. It’s something he’s had to do because he has exactly zero experience enforcing anything, ever, outside of hockey.
“My first couple years when I was with Washington, people from back home saw what I was doing, and they couldn’t believe it was me,” Oleksy said. “They couldn’t believe it was the same person.
“I’ve never thrown a punch off the ice.”
Jay Caufield can relate.
The former Penguins enforcer and current Root Sports studio analyst likens a fighter’s role to a goal-scorer’s — that’s what you can add to a team. But at home, Caufield’s married with children and takes great pride in never conducting himself the same way at home as he would while he was at work.
“I was raised to treat people the way I would want to be treated and be respectful of everybody,” Caufield said.
But twist a few words around, and that also meant treating his role with a great amount of respect. When the Penguins got down a couple goals, Caufield didn’t feel a responsibility to fix that. Yet if the game grew physical and somebody did something he deemed outside the bounds of decency, Caufield knew where the responsibility for fixing that fell.
“Every time you’re sitting on the bench and watching a play and somebody hits somebody wrong, you immediately think it falls to you,” Caufield said. “It’s your responsibility, so you help the team.”
Tom Sestito, the current team’s other enforcer, came to the fighting side of hockey unnaturally as well. Sestito was a skill guy for much of his life, but he said he shot up six inches the summer before his first junior season – 2004-05 with Plymouth in the OHL.
“Everyone figured I was a fighter, and I didn’t fight at all,” said Sestito, who scored 42 goals in 2006-07. “I kind of learned as I went. After getting beat up a few times, I figured I would start taking some boxing lessons. Later in my career I actually worked with an MMA guy. He’s really helped me a lot.”
Sestito designed the T-shirt pushing Phil Kessel for President. Like Oleksy, Sestito is approachable, one of the nicest players on the team and beloved by his teammates and coach; in fact, Mike Sullivan routinely refers to Oleksy sometimes as “Steve-O” and Sestito as “Tommy.”
“Usually the guys that are fighting a lot, it’s a job that many don’t want to do,” Sestito said. “But it’s not like they’re bad people. It’s just the job they have to do. You’d like to think everybody’s a nice guy. We as enforcers or people that fight know that our job isn’t very secure, so you just want to be the best team guy you can be in the locker room. I think that goes a long way with other guys.”
Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.