One can only hope this decision isn’t fumbled and bumbled the same way Kris Letang was left off Norris Trophy ballots and Team Canada’s World Cup of Hockey roster in the wake of producing 15 goals and 53 points in his final 46 regular season games of 2015-16.

Justin Schultz to the All-Star Game? Don’t laugh. Take the top defensemen in the Metropolitan Division and ignore what you know about each, the opinions you’ve formed and who plays for which team, and Schultz absolutely deserves consideration.

If not a plane ticket to Los Angeles at the end of the month.

Tied for first among Metropolitan Division defensemen first in goals (7). Fourth in assists (16). Third in points (23). Tied for second in plus/minus (plus-22). Second in Corsi For Per 60 minutes of ice time (CF60 of 61.8). Third in Shots Against Per 60 (SA60 of 28.42). Tied for first in Scoring Chances Per 60 (SCA60 of 8.28).

Advertise with us

Pick your pleasantry. Traditional or advanced. It’s hard to hide. And Schultz’s co-workers aren’t shy about endorsing his candidacy.

“Look around the league,” Trevor Daley said. “I don’t think there’s a guy playing the way he is.

“When a guy’s playing that well, you have to recognize it. You have to show some love.”

Ian Cole, Schultz’s defense partner more often than not this season, certainly would like to get involved.

“I might need to get a fan vote going,” Cole said. “Get him in there John Scott-style. Go hire one of those computer companies to vote for Justin Schultz 100,000 times a day or something.”

Advertise with us

Small problem: That computer program Cole mentioned probably couldn’t do much. Fans will likely vote Sidney Crosby as captain of the Metro. Beyond that, a panel within the NHL’s hockey operations department selects the remaining 40 players.

In the eyes of those who watch him every day, Schultz has done plenty to belong above or along with Ryan McDonagh and Nick Holden of the Rangers, Carolina’s Justin Faulk, Zach Werenski of Columbus or even Letang.

Pick through that stack, and there’s black eyes with everybody but Schultz. Faulk is a minus-9. He’s also hurt. McDonagh has two goals. Werenski is a plus-7 on a team that’s won 14 games in a row, many of them handily. Letang has missed a dozen games, has two goals and is a minus-3 on a really good team. Holden’s advanced numbers are rotten (CF60 of 50.21, SCA60 of 9.36).

Last year three defensemen went — Faulk, Letang and McDonagh. Crosby, Evgeni Malkin and Phil Kessel are all somewhat expected among the forwards. Adding Schultz for one of those two spots is something few Penguins would question.

“What he’s done is very much appreciated in here,” Cole said. “Everyone in here can definitely see how much he’s stepped up as the season has gone along.”

Advertise with us

Schultz won’t be broken up if he’s overlooked.

“I don’t think about that at all,” Schultz said. “I’m just focused on here and this team. We have plenty of players who can go before me, for sure.”

Being called an elite defenseman can be a tough group to break into. Oftentimes that sort of attention is earned a year or two late and hangs around a year or two too long. Like a good guard in football.

Letang tried to downplay his own place in this group but said he could see Schultz, the way he’s been playing, eventually garnering more attention league-wide and being compared to players such as Brent Burns, Erik Karlsson, Duncan Keith or Drew Doughty.

It’s a group that should absolutely include Letang, whether he wants to say it or not.

Advertise with us

“His performance right now is off the charts,” Letang said of Schultz. “He’s playing at the top of his game. If he keeps going and improving his game, and keeps playing that same way, he’ll get recognized in that mix for sure.”

You’d hope, anyway.

Schultz has 17 points in December, the best month for a Penguins defensemen since Sergei Zubov in 1996. It’s been magnificent, and there’s good reason to believe it’s more than a mirage. Look at Schultz’s ascension since the trade last season. Steady improvement.

The coaching staff challenged him to improve his play away from the puck, how he used his stick to defend, his willingness to go back for pucks and take a hit to make a play. Schultz has changed it all while keeping his offensive instincts fresh.

“I think his confidence is at an all-time high right now,” coach Mike Sullivan said.

Advertise with us

About the only thing left to change is perception from the outside.

“From the outside looking in, I’d say the same thing: Why doesn’t ‘Tanger’ get the same attention that he deserves?” Daley said. “When you have the best player on the planet on your team (Crosby), he’s going to get a lot of attention. But trust me, what ‘Schultzy’ has done doesn’t go unnoticed for the guys in this room.”

Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.