Jason Mackey: Hi, everyone. Used to doing these from PPG Paints Arena or on the road. But with Dave Molinari on this trip, I’ll be coming to you live from the PG headquarters on the North Shore. So leave a question, if you’d like.
John: I felt there was a good opportunity to deal MAF in the offseason prior to free agency; sign a capable back up like Chad Johnson and then move on. In retrospect, keeping MAF wasn’t a good move. Do you see him being traded or bought out at the trade deadline or end of the season? They ain’t losing Murray to the expansion draft.
Jason Mackey: Hi John. I don’t disagree with your assessment. I do think they will trade Fleury before the trade deadline. I think the money they’re allocating to goaltending is more than necessary, and I see no reason to keep Fleury over Murray. The only reason would be one made out of emotion, because Fleury is likable. A trade’s your best bet.
SDWC: Are we getting closer to Murray finally being formally tagged as the #1 goalie?
Jason Mackey: I don’t think it doesn’t the Penguins any good on the trade market to tag Matt Murray as the No. 1 -- and thus tag Marc-Andre Fleury as his backup. Until they deal Fleury, you’re going to see this characterized as a timeshare, a platoon, whatever word or phrase you want to use to describe it.
SDWC: Is Scott Wilson taking up a space in the starting lineup that would best be filled by somebody else?
Read More
Jason Mackey: Potentially. I would like to have seen more from Jake Guentzel, but Mike Sullivan believes very much in “roles.” In that vein, you have Sheary-Crosby-Hornqvist-Hagelin-Malkin-Kessel as top-six guys. I could see the case made for Guentzel to replace Hagelin, but I also think Hagelin brings a lot to that line with his speed, chemistry with Kessel and he does other things (PK) that Guentzel does not. Guentzel in the bottom six? That doesn’t fall in line with what Sullivan has done. Eric Fehr a healthy scratch, as will happen tonight, has been long overdue.
PittsburghBill: What’s more of an issue - PK & PP issues or MAF & Murray rotation?
Jason Mackey: Good question. Can I take all three? PP is, what, one for its last 27? PK has been similarly bad. I don’t think the Murray and Fleury timeshare is sustainable, simply because Fleury has little experience playing in a backup/platoon role, and there’s not enough starts for both. I do believe the PP and PK trends will reverse themselves. Not allowing the goalie thing to become an issue is probably a bigger concern for me.
PittsburghBill: If Pens were to trade MAF, who would backup Murray ?
Jason Mackey: Good question, but they could bring someone back in a trade, sign someone, trade for someone else ... true backups aren’t hard to find.
PittsburghBill: What can HCMS do to help the Pens stay out of these track meet games ?
Jason Mackey: Not much, honestly. A lot of it depends on how players play with the puck, the decisions they make, etc. If they’re content on taking chances -- Carl Hagelin described this in Sam Werner’s story today, and I thought it was great -- that result in odd-man rushes the other way, Sullivan can’t do much. What he’s trying to do is reinforce the idea to his team that they’re not trying to trade chances and that they do want to play a pressure defense that results in transition chances.
Alan: has Shultz been the best defenseman this year not named Letang
Jason Mackey: Yes. Justin Schultz is making himself a very rich man when it comes to contract negotiations next summer. I have serious doubts whether the Penguins will be positioned to pay him what he could otherwise fetch on the open market.
JamesinNYC: Do you think the Pens can “flip the switch” to get back to playing D? I understand mid year boredom combined with, and lets face it D requires hard work, flying around is more fun.
Jason Mackey: I’d be hesitant to paint the Penguins as the Harlem Globetrotters just because they scored eight goals in one game. Their offense is dynamic, and their defense can be really good, too. If I was going to describe the Penguins’ season thus far in one word, I’d use inconsistent. They haven’t done anything -- scoring goals included -- for any length of time. That’s issue No. 1: finding some consistency. Not combating boredom that has manifested itself in poor defensive play.
dave: Do you think GMJR should be looking to acquire someone who can help on the PK?
Jason Mackey: I don’t. I think he has greater needs. It’s not the personnel. We saw the same guys have success last year. Carl Hagelin and Matt Cullen have long histories of PK success, Cullen’s back to the Mesozoic Era, I believe. Nick Bonino and Eric Fehr, too. Ian Cole, Olli Maatta, Kris Letang, down the line. They’ve done it before. They just need to do it now.
Big Daddy in NJ: NHL.com ranked the Penguins #1 this week in the league-wide power rankings...do you agree?
Jason Mackey: I guess I don’t disagree. When I look at their roster and compare it to those around the league. they deserve the ranking. It’s a really good, deep team. It’s just been an inconsistent one. And I have a tough time picking a team I’d say is better right now. So, yeah, I’m OK with it.
dave: ...so what do you think GMJR should be looking for?
Jason Mackey: I don’t think an extra defenseman would hurt. You hate to say it, but injuries do happen and their defensemen don’t have the best histories of staying healthy. I would also like the idea of having a Chris Neil-type. I mean, not exactly Chris Neil but a forward with a little bit of rugged-ness, a guy who’s a bit of a jerk ... just in case. I question sometimes whether this team is nasty enough. I know it’s a speed game, that skill is the most important, but having some element of the team tougher than Ian Cole wouldn’t be the worst thing. No offense, Ian.
Jesse: Jason, how long is your leash on Olli Maatta right now?
Jason Mackey: Not terribly long, at least in the sense that Derrick Pouliot has to play, if for no other reason than to show other teams that he’s a living, breathing, serviceable defenseman, for a possible trade. Someone has to come out. Is it Brian Dumoulin? Maybe. I struggle to see anyone else I’d pull out, even if it’s for a game or two. I think Maatta has been better, but he’d be the first to say he still has a ways to go. Maturing as a defenseman in this league ain’t easy.
Curly: Was watching the a recent game with my 14 year old son and he stated more than asked, “Sid’s the best player ever isn’t he Pops?” I nearly went into my you should have scene Mario diatribe but paused and, for whatever reason. During this pause I thought to myself isn’t it time to truly appreciate the greatness of Sidney Crosby? I’m sitting here watching a hockey god and nearly let my old age tell my kid for lack of a better phrase to quote, “That’s not music...” Anyway, I think hockey fans, especially Pens fans, owe it to themselves to enjoy what we have in Crosby.
Jason Mackey: Curly, that’s a really cool story and cool moment. I’m not old -- 33 -- or at least don’t think I’m old, but I do remember Mario. I think Mario did things that were just ridiculous: the hands, the grace, the domination of a game. I’d be comfortable calling him the most dominant player I’ve seen. However, I can also identify with what you’re saying. If my 3-year-old starts thinking Sid’s awesome, then who am I to argue? They’re both worth appreciating ... and very, very different players. So that’s kind of neat, too. I commend you for seeing it through your son’s eyes and saving the “Dad lectures.” I’m sure we could all benefit by being more like that.
Jhonny Peltra: What do you make of the current Pens third and forth lines? I think scoring is not really there and is only overshadowed by the top two lines. You think an upgrade through trade is in order and if so who?
Jason Mackey: Sorry, Jhonny. I’m not sure I agree there. I think their bottom six is actually pretty solid. I would go: Sheary-Crosby-Hornqvist; Hagelin-Malkin-Kessel; Kunitz-Bonino-Rust; Kuhnhackl-Cullen-Fehr. I’m fine with that, honestly. People forget that 34-7-16 was a really good line for much of last year. Fehr will get going. He’s certainly not the first hockey player to endure a slump. There’s way more good than bad there. As a whole, I wouldn’t be against an addition, but by no means do I think their bottom six is a problem.
Pope: Do you think trading MAF is worth getting back a first round draft pick?
Jason Mackey: Yes, I do. Sad it is to see -- Fleury is one of the greatest human beings any of us media folks have dealt with; he’s as beloved by us as much as you guys -- I think it’s for the best. There’s not enough starts to satiate Murray and Fleury. Both guys fashion themselves as No. 1s and rightfully so. The best thing for all involved would be a trade, and to get a first-round pick ... I’d do it in a heartbeat.
Pope: Looking at the current roster and the players anticipated to not be here next year due to trade (MAF), possible retirement (Cullen) and contracts expiring (Kunitz, Shultz), who do you think the Pens should re-sign and bring back?
Jason Mackey: I would take a run at Kunitz on a one-year deal worth around $1 million and cast him in a bottom-six hole. He’s an effective forechecker and a good locker room guy. Nobody here would be all worked up over Kunitz if he didn’t make $3.75 million or whatever he does. For that price, he should score more than he does, an example of a bad contract under Ray Shero. Schultz is going to get a silly amount of elsewhere. I’d pay Brian Dumoulin and try to retain Trevor Daley. I’d wait and see on Nick Bonino. If it’s reasonable, yes. But I wouldn’t overextend.
Jhonny Peltra: A man with one watch knows what time it is; a man with two watches is never quite sure. ~Pud Galvin
Jason Mackey: Yes, Pud. Yes.
Nate: Will Rust see more time on the top PP unit if he keeps playing the way he has?
Jason Mackey: Yes. You’ve seen Sullivan spot him in at times ... I think for this situation. You have Cullen, Hagelin and Bonino tonight. That’s easy. With Fehr out, who No. 4 becomes is interesting. I think it will be Rust, and I think he adds a lot to a PK with his speed and ability to retrieve pucks. Could be something he incorporates into his game quite a bit as he continues to grow.
Jason Mackey: OK, folks. Looks like that’s it. Thanks for joining. Let’s do this again next week.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.