The Penguins have won three games in a row and own a share of first place in the Metropolitan Division.
Heck, their 8-5 victory Monday night against Ottawa at PPG Paints Arena lifted them to within one point of Montreal, which sits atop the overall standings.
But being 16-7-3 isn’t enough to hide some significant flaws in their game, if only because the numbers those shortcomings reflect are simply too large to miss.
Like the average of 3.04 goals that the Penguins have given up through their first 26 games.
And the penalty-kill success rate of 78.4 percent that puts the Penguins in the bottom five in the NHL.
The Penguins short-handed unit has given up 19 goals in 88 short-handed situations, and certainly didn’t gain any luster when Ottawa scored three times in five tries with the extra man.
Read More
“We’re a talented team offensively and we’re good off the rush and stuff like that, but we can’t get into these track meets all the time,” goalie Matt Murray said. “You can win in a track meet with a team like us, but winning consistently is what’s difficult when you’re giving up that many chances.
“I think everybody knows we need to tighten up a little bit, but you see today that most of [the goals-against] come on the penalty-kill. We need to tighten that up a lot.”
The defensive issues have been masked, to some extent, by a volatile offense, which had its most productive outing of 2016-17.
Bryan Rust was the headliner, recording his first career hat trick and an assist, but he was just one of five players to record multiple points.
The Penguins have made a habit of overcoming two-goal deficits, and did it again after the Senators built a 4-2 advantage in the second period.
Mike Hoffman scored the Senators’ fourth goal on their 16th shot at 7:08 of the second, prompting Penguins coach Mike Sullivan to replace goalie Marc-Andre Fleury with Murray.
Murray allowed just one goal on 18 shots the rest of the way, although Sullivan suggested the switch wasn’t an indictment of how Fleury had played.
“It was more about trying to change the mindset of the 18 skaters in front of him,” Sullivan said. “Obviously, we responded the right way.”
The turnaround began with a goal scored on a Senators power play. Unlike the other three, however, that one was scored by the Penguins.
Center Matt Cullen collected the puck at his blue line, then charged up the ice before throwing a backhander by Ottawa goalie Craig Anderson while Justin Schultz was serving an interference minor.
“That’s a big point in the game,” Murray said.
Of course, its significance was magnified by the Penguins penalty-killing problems.
They rank among the bottom five in the league, even though their personnel and scheme are pretty much unchanged from last season, when they killed 84.4 percent of the penalties they faced to place fifth in the league.
“The group, as a whole, lacks a little confidence right now,” Sullivan said.
Understandably so, considering how many times opponents have scored with a man-advantage this season.
The reassuring — or, is it troubling — thing is that they aren’t that far removed from being one of the league’s top short-handed units.
“We know that we can be better,” Cullen said. “Because we have been.”
The Penguins know they can play more stingy overall defense, too. It just hasn’t happened very often this season.
“We all know what it takes to win, as far as how you have to play defensively,” Cullen said. “We haven’t been up to that level consistently enough yet.”
Dave Molinari: Dmolinari@Post-Gazette.com and Twitter @MolinariPG.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.