Conventional wisdom holds that sometime between now and the NHL expansion draft next June, the Penguins will trade goaltender Marc-Andre Fleury. It’s a perfectly logical conclusion, which explains how it became conventional wisdom in the first place.

After all, Fleury has a no-movement clause in his contract. Under expansion-draft rules, unless he waives that, Fleury would have to be the goalie the Penguins protect in the draft that will provide players for the new franchise in Las Vegas.

That would force them to expose Matt Murray, who many believe has the potential to develop into a franchise goaltender, in that draft. Good luck finding a betting parlor in Vegas willing to lay decent odds on the new club passing on a chance to grab Murray.

Now, Penguins general manager Jim Rutherford could try to work out a deal with his Las Vegas counterpart, George McPhee, to have McPhee claim another player from the Penguins, but McPhee would have no obligation to agree to one.

Advertise with us

For now, the issue is moot, because Rutherford said recently he has had no such discussions.

“There’s a lot of ground to cover before we get to that,” he said. “Our focus is on winning, not what we’re doing in the expansion draft.”

The primary argument for trading Fleury is age. He is 31, nine years older than Murray.

And while Fleury has played perhaps the finest hockey of his career over the past year or so, there’s every reason to believe Murray still will be playing long after Fleury retires.

What’s more, although Murray remains something of a work-in-progress — he is, after all, just 22, with limited experience in the NHL — he was a major factor in the Penguins’ drive to the Stanley Cup this spring, so there’s not much concern about his ability to perform under pressure.

Advertise with us

Still, Rutherford’s insistence that management has not decided whether Murray or Fleury will be its go-to goalie should not be dismissed as a smokescreen to conceal his intentions.

That’s because it has not been established that Murray is Fleury’s superior, or that he will be any time in the next few years.

That is a critical consideration, because the Penguins’ focus is on collecting as many Stanley Cups as possible, not on who will be their No. 1 goaltender a decade down the road.

Sidney Crosby is 29 and Evgeni Malkin 30. The window for those two to play at a championship level shouldn’t be closing anytime soon, but it isn’t going to remain open forever, either.

If Rutherford and his staff conclude that Fleury is the goalie who gives the Penguins the best chance of winning another Cup or two, parting with him becomes a lot tougher to justify.

Advertise with us

The best-case scenario for the Penguins would be to have Rutherford work out a deal with McPhee to retain both goalies, but even that might be only a temporary solution.

After all, it is hard to say how Fleury and Murray would co-exist as equals, essentially sharing the No. 1 job, for an extended period. Both, understandably, view themselves as Alpha goalies, worthy of being the guy their team counts on.

If the Penguins are lucky, that’s an issue that will be settled on the ice, not by an expansion draft.

The week ahead

Wednesday – at Anaheim. The Penguins have a chance to the sweep season series for the third time in past four years.

Advertise with us

Thursday – at Los Angeles. If he can get healthy, Kings goalie Jeff Zatkoff should get the start against his former teammates.

Saturday – at San Jose. No matter how this game turns out, it won’t be as enjoyable for the Penguins as their last visit to SAP Center.

Dave Molinari: Dmolinari@Post-Gazette.com and Twitter @MolinariPG