Guest: What’s the best conversation (that you don’t mind sharing) that you’ve ever had with Sidney Crosby that wasn’t about hockey? And do you agree with the Matt Murray extension? I would have liked to see him play a few games this season before extending his contract.

Jason Mackey: I’ve had a lot of good conversations with Sidney Crosby not about hockey. My favorite might be talking to him about WWII history and his own desire to go back to school. Sid’s a really passionate person, very caring, too. He doesn’t do anything halfway. That was cool to see outside of hockey and with something else like his house and education. Yes, I agree on the Murray extension. They were going to re-sign him anyway. Just a matter of when. Very reasonable rate.

TSgt Fisher: Is Murray’s new contract a sign that Flower might be traded during the season?

Jason Mackey: They are completely separate issues. The Penguins were going to sign Murray regardless. If an offer comes around for Fleury, sure, he could still be dealt. Probably the same for Murray, for that matter. And teams certainly won’t mind when they look at Murray’s ability, age and cost certainty.

Advertise with us

Guest: Could the signing of Murray expedite in any way Fleury’s potential departure?

Jason Mackey: No. Completely independent issues.

SDWC: What’s the biggest factor contributing to the number of goals given up recently?

Jason Mackey: The PK has been worse than usual. They’ve allowed four on 18 chances, a success rate of 77.8 percent that’s tied for 19th. It’s also been stuff around the goal. Whether that’s not supporting a defenseman who chases the puck (Cole Tuesday) or losing track of a man, the Penguins’ play close to their own net needs to be better.

SDWC: Will Kris Letang dress tonight?

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: No. He’s day-to-day with an upper-body injury. Out tonight.

SDWC: Do you see HBK being split up as a change of pace if they go a couple more games without an even strength goal?

Jason Mackey: Potentially. I think it sends a certain message. I asked Nick Bonino about HBK this morning. Here’s what he said: “Obviously a little snakebitten. We put up 20 shots two games ago. We had chances every game. If those weren’t coming, I’d be upset. Sometimes it’s not working. He mixes the lines up like he did in the third. We have so many good guys here. It’s never a big deal. The puck will go in eventually.” ... But to answer your question, yes, I think if they don’t start scoring, Sullivan will play that card.

Pucks Joey: I think that if they can, it would be best for everybody to trade Fleury ASAP. While the depth is a nice luxury, the reality is that having two starting goalies is an unmanageable situation that will cause more distraction and harm than the benefit of the depth is worth. Would you agree Mr. Mackey?

Jason Mackey: No, I don’t. I don’t know how you make the assertion that it’s unmanageable? How? Who said? They haven’t even tried yet. We should probably at least let them do that before overreacting. I think it can work. Should it? From a business standpoint, I don’t think it makes sense to lose Murray for nothing, which would happen if GMJR stands pat. It also makes little sense to sell low on Fleury, which is what GMJR would be doing if he made a move now. Why not let Fleury play, hope he plays well, juggle two goalies, then get a high pick for a goaltender who is still very good?

Advertise with us

JamesinNYC: So does Murry’s contract have a no move clause?

Jason Mackey: If it does, I’m not aware of one. But this is not the type of thing the team generally puts in an announcement. If there is one, it will likely surface in a couple days.

Bbabybear02: Do you think the Pens will give a pitch for a team to trade for Fleury?

Jason Mackey: If a team needs “a pitch” to acquire a goaltender with two Stanley Cup rings, more than 350 wins, the amount of shutouts he’s had since 2013-14 ... I don’t know what to tell them. They don’t have to “pitch” Fleury. Other teams will simply need to see validation that last season’s concussion issues are behind him.

dave: When Murray’s new contract kicks in next season, won’t they be in salary cap trouble if Fleury is also on the roster?

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: No. Right now they have $60,073,333 in committed salaries for 2017-18. Remember guys like Kunitz, Cullen, Bonino and Daley are UFAs. So, things will change. But they’re not in any sort of trouble. I also wouldn’t bank on Fleury’s cap hit being on the books in 2017-18.

dave: Don’t you think the contract for Murray is a little premature? I think they made this same mistake when they gave Maatta a new contract a couple seasons ago.

Jason Mackey: I think it’s way too soon to say the Olli Maatta contract was a mistake. Way too soon. He’s struggling now, sure, but he’s signed through 2021-22. I’m going to go out on a limb and say things could change between now and then. For both sides. No, I don’t think it’s premature at all. He would have been an RFA, so they would have had to make a decision. Smart term, smart dollars. Makes perfect sense for both parties.

Bbabybear02: Do you think it will be a DIRTY game tonight mostly from the sharks standpoint due to the Pens winning the cup in San Jose?

Jason Mackey: I don’t. The Sharks are not an especially dirty team. And if they’re going to get “revenge” in Game 5 of the next regular season for the Stanley Cup Final ... there’s a lot of misplaced logic there. The Sharks are much smarter.

Advertise with us

Bbabybear02: Do you have a concern with Fleury’s Playing time?

Jason Mackey: None whatsoever. Do you mean whether he will get enough starts? He’ll get plenty.

Guest: Do you think Jagr will ever be welcomed back by the organization? I visited Pittsburgh last year and one of the bars had his jersey up but had traitor and other not nice things listed on it. Does the organization still have contempt for him the way the fan base does?

Jason Mackey: Funny you should mention Jagr ... might want to buy a paper Sunday. I would argue not the entire fan base hates Jagr, only a portion. I don’t think his relationship with Mario is very good. The last Jagr talked to Mario was when he was coming back from Russia. His likeness, I noticed this week, is not in either dressing room, a crazy omission if you think about it.

Dog: Who, in your opinion, is the better goalie? Fleury can make some impressive acrobatic saves, however, he seems to consistently let in softies at inopportune times. Murray’s sound positioning allows him to make the save he should make, but he doesn’t have the athletic ability to make all the save Fleury would.

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: Can I get back to you in 10 years? It’s tough to say now. Fleury has the resume. He’s done it. So it’s hard to say Murray is the better goalie. But I think with Murray’s talents, and the stone-cold-ness he has about him, plus his work in the playoffs, I think if he’s able to replicate that over the length of Fleury’s career, I think he will be better. But now, it’s tough to discount what Fleury has done.

dave: For the past few seasons, I think Malkin has often seemed disinterested when he’s playing. He lacks passion, makes poor decisions with the puck, and commits dumb penalties. I think he can be dominant when he wants to, but it just seems like he doesn’t care sometimes.

Jason Mackey: Oh, I think Malkin absolutely cares. I think Malkin cares too much. If you ask guys in that room, one of the things they’ll tell you is how emotional Malkin can be — good and bad. I disagree that he’s disinterested. I will say he sometimes takes some dumb, reactionary penalties that put his team in a bad spot. I also don’t think Malkin has been completely healthy for awhile now, and that might explain a thing or two.

Jason: No way you trade #29 this early in the season. Are people smoking crack? You wait until a team is desperate then you make a move.

Jason Mackey: Yeah, people. Crack kills.

Advertise with us

Jason: Because this team is a lot deeper than in the past wouldn’t it make sense to have Makin and Crosby on the top line when he returns? Sometimes Mallon seems half asleep out there and you know Crosby would push him every shift.

Jason Mackey: You really think Malkin needs someone on the ice to push him? C’mon. For whatever reason, Crosby and Malkin have never meshed together as well as the fan base has hoped. Different styles, I guess. I’m fine with the Penguins keeping them apart. What I think Malkin has is a shooter on his wing. I thought Scott Wilson might be that guy. He’s been getting chances. But the kid needs to bury some of them. Soon.

me: So will Pouliot play tonight since Letang’s out?

Jason Mackey: That is correct. Here’s my pregame blog post.

Bbabybear02: I actually meant is he getting too many starts. Do you think he is playing too much?

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: Not at all. I like Mike Condon, but Fleury should play every game so long as he’s physically able. Obviously until Murray gets back.

Guest: Why is Scott Wilson playing with Malkin? I know Wilson’s coming off an injury, but I don’t think he’s ever shown much scoring ability.

Jason Mackey: Except, perhaps, in the preseason, when he led them in goals and points. He’s shown a lot of offensive ability. All throughout camp. Practices and games. Not sure what more you would want the kid to do. That doesn’t explain the lack of converting his chances into goals; he needs to do that. But I don’t question for a second Mike Sullivan putting Wilson on Malkin’s wing. Wilson has a great shot, a deceptive shot, and Malkin needs that.

Bbabybear02: Do you think the 0-4 loss to the Canadians is because Fleury had a bad game or Montreal is just that much better this year

Jason Mackey: I think it’s because the Penguins were playing horribly in front of Fleury. I’m not putting that game on Fleury at all. The Penguins were awful as a team. If not for Fleury, it might have been 10-0.

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: While we have a bit of a lull ... I’m amazed at how serious everything is. What happened, y’all?

Bbabybear02: Will we see a different San Jose Sharks team tonight then the Stanley Cup Final?

Jason Mackey: A little bit, but not too much. The guts of it are still there -- Thornton, Pavelski, Burns, Jones, etc. A really skilled team. A lot of shots. They want to push the pace. Fun to watch. Sharks have gotten off to a pretty strong start, too.

Bbabybear02: Do you think the Penguins need to play more Outdoor games?

Jason Mackey: Sadly, I think the outdoor games in the NHL have been over-saturated. And I feel like they’re offering the same product, the same teams. I wish there were fewer and those that did happen were more innovative. I wish the Penguins played at PNC Park, too, but I know that’s never going to happen.

Advertise with us

Guest: Well, they’re coming off a really bad performance. Reminiscent of the NJ or Calgary games last season.

Jason Mackey: Agree there. Tuesday was every bit as bad as either of those two.

dave: I think it’s frustrating that they’ve been shooting themselves in the foot lately. Especially with the dumb penalties.

Jason Mackey: Imagine being Mike Sullivan. He doesn’t want to flip out because he’s a composed guy and you don’t want to show yourself to your team as a basket case. But you can tell he just wants to lose it. Hopefully he owns a punching bag or something.

Mcsst9: What are the chances the Pens trade Murray, and not Fluery? Everyone seems to forget that Matt Murray has played 34 NHL games, only 34 more than Tristan Jarry who looked fantastic in the preseason.

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: You bring up an interesting point. I was actually talking about this with Dave Molinari earlier. Dave brought up to me how attractive Murray’s contract might be to other teams. I hadn’t thought about it like that. Not only is Murray young with a Stanley Cup on his resume, a great demeanor and a ton of talent, but he’s controllable for the next three years. The only thing is I really doubt Jim Rutherford would be willing to move him. The return would have to be gigantic.

I was surprised wh...: I was surprised when Roots Sports showed Sprong in the box besides Sid the other night. Is he rehabbing in Pittsburgh? If not, what’s his current status?

Jason Mackey: Yes, he’s been around. He’s rehabbing in Pittsburgh. We see him occasionally. He’s out until the early part of 2017. That’s what we expected.

Mcsst9: and on that note...do the likes of Crosby, Malkin, Letang put up an argument on Fluery’s behalf?

Jason Mackey: Not that I’m aware of, but they could. I’m sure GMJR would listen, too. But his charge is not to placate those guys. It’s to do what’s best for the Penguins as a whole. Unfortunately, it’s probably to trade Fleury. If you can get younger, better and cheaper goaltending, but you have to hurt someone’s feelings, are you really going to NOT do that?

Advertise with us

Mcsst9: you are right, but to trade away your franchise goalie, arguably during his prime, and to replace with a rookie seems risky. Now if Murray had 84 games under his belt, or 184 and the results were there, then it would be an easier sell to me. Thanks for fielding my questions/comments.

Jason Mackey: Gladly. Thank you for participating in the chat. I understand the concern, but my rebuttal has been something like this: The dude won a Stanley Cup. Are we really thinking he’s going to lose it against Columbus in November? I’m willing to buy the idea that Matt Murray, at this point, is for real. That doesn’t mean I rush to trade Fleury; I’m going to wait for the right deal. But I think Murray is going to be a very good NHL goalie for a long time.

Andy: Which of the young forwards playing regularly, like Kuhn, Wilson, Sheary, Rust, do you see the Pens protecting from the expansion draft...if any?

Jason Mackey: I like him a lot, but if you said I could only protect three, Kuhnhackl would be the odd man out. Two, probably Wilson. I like Sheary and Rust the most; I think they best fit the Penguins’ current team concept.

Krugerrand: I would think a team in need to trade for a top notch goalie would be a playoff caliber team that wouldn’t want to trade away their best players. Does that mean one of the goalies gets traded primarily for prospects? Does that impact which goalie could end up traded? (or is my initial premise wrong?)

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: No, I think your premise makes sense, and I think the answer could be draft picks. A package of prospects for Fleury could absolutely get the deal done. Draft picks, too, for that matter. I don’t get the sense the Penguins are looking for NHL-ready players, if they’re looking for anything at all. They’re fine at the NHL level.

mth172: Will they turn the old Consol signage and lettering from the walls outside the arena over to Wendell August Forge to turn into commemorative ticket stubs and Christmas ornaments like the old Mellon Arena roof?

Jason Mackey: I don’t know, but I doubt it. Little different in terms of history. Plus, it’s just signage. Not like anything is getting demolished like Mellon, God rest its wonderful soul.

mth172: Who takes the Calder this year? Matthews or Laine? Last night was an amazing game showing the young talent, like an encore to the Team NA world Cup. Kinda ironic how a fan base against expansion into the South has a savior in Matthews

Jason Mackey: Last night was awesome, wasn’t it? Those kids are special. I like Matthews. Part of me doesn’t want to discount Matt Murray, either, but I think the Fleury situation may prevent him from putting up numbers on par with what Matthews will do as a skater.

Advertise with us

Matt in Monessen: Bonino hasn’t looked great. Is it because he’s now the second line center? Or are my eyes deceiving me?

Jason Mackey: He seemed to not be too irked by that role in the playoffs, no? On my list of Penguins concerns, Bonino isn’t even close to the top. Heck, he’s not even on the list. He’s been fine. That line has been OK. Not great, just OK. They’ve been getting chances; it’s just a matter, now, of finishing them. But I’m certainly not going to peg any of their struggles on Bonino.

Jason Mackey: OK, folks. That does it. Home for me for a bit. Then back here tonight for Penguins-Sharks. Thanks so much for participating!