The Penguins have had 23 power plays in their first five exhibition games.
They’ve scored on all but 22 of them.
If nothing else, that leaves a little room for improvement when the real games begin next Thursday.
Still, there are obvious perils in taking any preseason statistic at face value — does anyone expect the Penguins to record three shutouts every five games when the regular-season begins? — and that certainly is true of this power play.
The most obvious mitigating factor for its lack of production is that the Penguins’ No. 1 unit — Sidney Crosby, Evgeni Malkin, Phil Kessel, Patric Hornqvist and Kris Letang — has yet to appear together this fall, although that could change when Columbus visits PPG Paints Arena Saturday for the exhibition finale.
Regardless, it is not the Penguins’ 4.3 percent conversion rate in preseason play that merits attention, but their 18.4 percent success rate in 2015-16. That placed 16th in the NHL.
Read More
“We need to be better than that,” Hornqvist said. “We have to get our power play over 20 [percent].”
That seems a reasonable objective. Eight clubs finished at or above 20 percent in 2015-16, and few, if any, deployed a power play with personnel as menacing as the Penguins’.
Several players noted that the power play became more efficient as the regular season wound down — “If you took a sample from the last 25 games, our power play was a lot better than at first, when we struggled so much,” said left winger Chris Kunitz, who works on the No. 2 unit — and its conversion rate rose to 23.4 percent in the playoffs.
Still, that translated to another middle-of-the-pack ranking, placing the Penguins’ sixth among the 16 teams that qualified for the postseason.
Letang cautioned against taking any numbers strictly at face value.
“When it comes down to being clutch, I think we’ve been good at that,” he said. “The power play is a big thing, but, if you get big goals at big moments, that’s the most important thing.”
He didn’t disagree, however, with those who feel the Penguins’ success rate should rise if the power play performs to its potential.
“We have the type of players to be successful,” Hornqvist said. “We just have to make sure we’re doing the right things and don’t be too cute.”
That has been a recurring issue with the Penguins, who sometimes work the power play as if they expect to get style points for fabricating a highlights-caliber goal. While the most productive power plays tend to be those that get pucks and bodies to the net, the temptation to stray from those basics to make a pretty play can be overwhelming.
“Sometimes, you can get away from shooting the puck and doing simple things that lead to success,” Crosby said. “Everyone wants to distribute the puck to one another. All of us like to have the puck, so it’s easy to overpass sometimes.”
Sullivan and his staff stress the importance of shooting when opportunities arise and try to instill the structure that allows the Penguins’ talented players to exploit situations that develop when an opponent is short-handed.
“Structure allows you to use your skill when the play is there to be made,” Crosby said. “Structure first, and then, with the guys we have, we can make the plays when they’re there.
“Usually, when our work ethic is there and we’re competing and our structure is there, everything else falls into place.”
More than once every 23 tries.
Dave Molinari: Dmolinari@Post-Gazette.com and Twitter @MolinariPG.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.