Penguins Prospectus is an offseason project by Jason Mackey and Sam Werner that each weekday through Sept. 16 will examine 27 parts of the organization. Players and team personnel will appear according to when they played, coached or managed their first game with the Penguins, starting with Justin Schultz and ending with Marc-Andre Fleury.
Marc-Andre Fleury, goaltender
Catches: left
Height/weight: 6-foot-2, 180 pounds
Age: 31
Date of Penguins debut: Oct. 10, 2003. Fleury, the first overall pick in the 2003 NHL Draft, stopped 46 of 48 shots, but the Penguins dropped a 3-0 decision to the Los Angeles Kings at Mellon Arena.
Read More
2015-16 stats: Fleury went 35-17-6 with a .921 save percentage and a 2.29 goals-against average. In the playoffs he participated in two games, making one start, and allowed four goals on 32 shots in 79 minutes.
Contract situation: Fleury is signed through 2018-19 at a yearly salary cap hit of $5.75 million. Thirteen goalies will make more in 2016-17.
HAT TRICK (THREE KEY NUMBERS)
357: Career wins for Fleury, 18th all-time and third-most among active goaltenders.
20: Shutouts for Fleury the past three seasons … or since Mike Bales took over as goaltending coach.
.752: Fleury’s career save percentage in shootout situations (191 of 254), best among active goaltenders who’ve seen at least 100 shootout shots against.
WHAT WE LEARNED
That nothing lasts forever, even the best stuff. You won’t find a nicer athlete in the Pittsburgh sports scene, yet even Fleury had to be frustrated with the way the season played out.
Two concussions and the ascension of Matt Murray meant he was watching the organization’s playoff run from the bench — and, of course, celebrating the Stanley Cup win in the most awkward way possible.
Credit to Fleury, though: Every word you heard about his relationship with Murray was a good one. He helped. He didn’t become a distraction. He essentially helped train his successor.
After not playing since March 31, Fleury was thrust into duty in Game 4 of the Eastern Conference Finals, in relief of Murray. That went fine, but his subsequent next start did not and that was that. Murray was back in goal for Game 6, and the Penguins took the series.
We learned that while Fleury might be a viable goaltender, it likely won’t be here.
2015-16 HIGHLIGHT
It’s easy to forget how much Fleury meant to this group early on. The date was Oct. 15, and the Penguins were winless in three tries. Fleury even said, “It seemed like we were searching ourselves a little bit out there.” When the Penguins needed badly to pull out of a funk, it was Fleury who made it happen, stopping 22 shots at Consol Energy Center to deliver a 2-0 win over the Senators. Were there bigger games for Fleury? Probably. And clearly there was still a ton of the season left to shake out. But for all the talk about Murray late, it was Fleury early who kept the Penguins from crumbling.
WHAT’S NEXT
General manager Jim Rutherford has committed to starting the season with two top-tier goalies, and don’t expect the Penguins to deviate from that.
However, a good bit of the reason why Rutherford didn’t deal Fleury in the offseason was because there wasn’t a trade he had to make. The Flames, who kicked tires on Fleury, wound up acquiring Brian Elliott for a pair of draft picks. That’s a solid return on the 2015-16 save percentage leader and someone working on a $2.5 million contract.
Injuries happen all the time. When a goaltender on a contender goes down, expect Rutherford’s phone to ring.
Many of you worry, and justifiably so, about the Penguins protecting Fleury — because they have to — in an expansion draft and letting Murray walk. Rutherford isn’t dumb. He’ll get something for Fleury; the challenge here is not selling lower than what he feels he can get. So Rutherford’s playing chicken with the goaltender market.
In the meantime, Murray and Fleury will split starts, with Murray likely getting a few more. It’s not a bad problem to have, especially with a long NHL season. And, if something does happen to Murray — an injury or regression — the Penguins have one heck of a fallback plan.
The sad part in all of this is Fleury’s tenure as a Penguin has more than likely reached his conclusion. He can still play. It just won’t be Pittsburgh that gets to enjoy his goofy high jinks anymore.
Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.