NHL teams falling all over themselves to court Harvard’s Hobey Baker Award winner Jimmy Vesey, a group that includes the Penguins, would be wise to dig through the award’s history and familiarize themselves with names such as Scott Fusco, Lane MacDonald and Marty Sertich.
Who, you ask?
All three won the award, which is named for the former Princeton player and World War I veteran. None of them, for various reasons, played an NHL game. As irony would have it, Fusco and MacDonald also are Harvard alums. It’s not an indictment by any stretch, but winning the Hobey Baker as college hockey’s top player certainly does not guarantee a long and prosperous NHL career because for every Paul Kariya (1993 winner, 989 NHL games, 402 goals) or Neal Broten (1981, 1,099, 289), there are twice as many who didn’t make it.
The Penguins met with Vesey Monday in Boston, and they’ll have been joined by nearly a third of the league by the time everyone has made their pitches. The Boston Bruins, Buffalo Sabres, Toronto Maple Leafs, Chicago Blackhawks, New York Islanders, New Jersey Devils and New York Rangers also are running in the Vesey derby, with the first three of those probably a cut above the others.
Vesey grew up a Bruins fan in North Reading, Mass.; his father, Jim, works as a scout with Toronto; and he’s good friends with 2015 Hobey Baker Award winner Jack Eichel, who is entering his second year in Buffalo after a 24-goal rookie campaign. Vesey and Eichel train together in the offseason.
The pitches that Vesey, 23, is listening to won’t center around money. He can make just $925,000 over the next two years, a number that’s dictated by the NHL’s collective bargaining agreement, with $2.85 million more available in potential bonus money per season.
Read More
What teams will try to sell Vesey on is the opportunity to play a key role right away and a chance to win, two things that could resonate when delivered by Penguins brass. The only shame is that the Stanley Cup is in Europe, stripping the Penguins of the ability to really drive home their points.
Chris Kunitz is in the final year of a three-year contract that carries a cap hit of $3.85 million. If the Penguins look to bring Kunitz back, it won’t be for the top-six role in which he has been accustomed to playing, nor will it be for anything close to what he currently makes.
That leaves an eventual opening on Sidney Crosby’s left side, and there are few better places for a skilled and smart young winger to be. The Penguins also have a strong reputation for recognizing, developing and integrating college talent. Five forwards — Phil Kessel, Carl Hagelin, Conor Sheary, Bryan Rust and Matt Cullen — from their 2015-16 Cup-winning team went the NCAA route, along with defenseman Ian Cole.
The Penguins also are perpetually searching for a top-six winger to play with Crosby or Evgeni Malkin, something that could easily be attractive to Vesey.
Vesey’s camp already is looking ahead to his second contract and examining interested teams’ payroll structure to gauge Vesey’s long-term earning potential should everything pan out the way they hope. The Penguins have only four forwards — Crosby, Malkin, Kessel and Hagelin — under contract through 2018-19, when Vesey would be looking for that new deal.
That, of course, would mean that Vesey doesn’t meet the same fate as other Hobey Baker Award winners, perhaps such as Chris Marinucci, the 1994 recipient out of Minnesota-Duluth. Marinucci totaled 13 NHL games and scored once. Or Andy Miele, another left winger, who won it in 2011 out of Miami of Ohio. Miele has played in 15 NHL games with zero goals. David Emma (1991) was a two-time All-American at Boston College, scoring 73 goals from 1989-91, but that translated into just five goals in 34 NHL games.
The average NHL career for a Hobey Baker Award winner is just 299 games or 3.65 seasons. That’s a little ahead of current Penguins center Kevin Porter (2008, Michigan, 247 games). The average career goal total is just 57.2.
So while Vesey could turn out to be Broten, Kariya or Chris Drury (1998, Boston University, 255 goals in 892 NHL games), the Penguins — and others — probably should maintain realistic expectations.
Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.