Penguins president and CEO David Morehouse knew there would be criticism.
Even though he, along with majority owners Mario Lemieux and Ron Burkle, knew changes had to be made.
So, over a three-week stretch in June 2014, fresh off a second-round playoff series loss against the New York Rangers, they fired general manager Ray Shero and coach Dan Bylsma — both of whom had led the Penguins to the team’s third Stanley Cup in 2009 — and installed Jim Rutherford as the new general manager.
At the time, critics slammed Rutherford’s hiring as everything from “untraditional and illogical” to “safe and sorry.”
“We knew when we made the changes there was going to be criticism,” Morehouse said last week. “We knew we’d be criticized in a number of different areas, and yet I think [Lemieux and Burkle] weren’t afraid of the criticism.”
For long stretches of the past two years, that criticism seemed to be well-founded. Rutherford’s first choice as head coach, Mike Johnston, was fired after just 18 months on the job.
But Johnston’s replacement, Mike Sullivan, fit perfectly in concert with the roster overhaul Rutherford had subtly been implementing over the first two years of his tenure. The result was a complete vindication of the front-office overhaul two years earlier and, more important, the franchise’s fourth Stanley Cup.
“We never had any doubt,” Morehouse said. “We knew there were going to be challenges. We also knew that teams that win championships overcome challenges, so, while we were having the challenges, we knew these are the kind of challenges that build Stanley Cup-winning teams.”
The Penguins had fallen short of that lofty goal in the five years before Rutherford was brought in. Since lifting the Stanley Cup in 2009, they had only advanced to the Eastern Conference final once, and that ended with a sweep at the hands of the Boston Bruins in 2013.
Those playoff shortcomings led the club’s leadership to the decision that a “significant” overhaul was necessary. Exit Shero and Bylsma, enter Rutherford, who had spent 20 years as the general manager of the Hartford Whalers/Carolina Hurricanes franchise.
“We knew that we needed a steady hand, someone that had seen a lot of different things,” Morehouse said. “This is not a situation that is uncomplicated. Coming to Pittsburgh, to the NHL team, is not like going to Columbus or some other places. It is a hard place to manage.”
Even after last season — which ended with another dispiriting first-round playoff loss — the Penguins kept the faith in Rutherford’s plan. A number of injuries, particularly on defense, limited the Penguins depth by the time the playoffs rolled around.
“We also knew that your hands are tied to a certain degree with the contracts you have,” Morehouse said.
“He wanted to make some changes that were going to take more than one year. We thought they’d take more than two years, to be honest with you.”
Rutherford wanted the Penguins to get deeper. Their most dangerous line in these playoffs was arguably the “HBK line” of Carl Hagelin, Phil Kessel and Nick Bonino — which featured neither Sidney Crosby nor Evgeni Malkin.
He wanted the Penguins to get faster. Players such as Hagelin, Bryan Rust and Conor Sheary gave opponents fits with their speed in the just-completed playoffs.
He wanted the Penguins to add a veteran element. Numerous team members have spoken about Matt Cullen’s impact on and off the ice, and defenseman Trevor Daley, despite being acquired midseason, was the first person to get the Stanley Cup from Crosby Sunday night.
“It’s really changed the way we played in Pittsburgh,” Lemieux said after the team’s Game 6 win. “Fast game, we play with a lot of pressure. I think now that we’ve won with speed, I think you’ll see a lot of teams changing the way they play.”
Of course, the most notable personnel change Rutherford made this year was behind the bench, bringing in Sullivan Dec. 12 to replace Johnston. The Penguins were languishing in the middle of the Eastern Conference standings, and, in Rutherford’s eyes, seemed headed for another short playoff appearance.
“The best thing that happened to us in the beginning of the year was Jim Rutherford was willing to make a change when a lot of people wouldn’t have,” Morehouse said. “We weren’t doing that bad. We were still doing pretty well when he made this coaching change.”
Morehouse recalled that when Sullivan was hired to coach the Wilkes-Barre Penguins in June 2015, Rutherford told him, “We’re hiring an NHL[-caliber] coach in Wilkes-Barre.”
A year later, those words turned out to be prophetic. Sullivan is not just an NHL coach, but a Stanley Cup champion.
And the man whose name will be alongside his on the Cup, Rutherford, turned out to be the right man at the right time for the Penguins.
“What Jim Rutherford was able to do is he’s been able to make us deeper, he’s built depth, he’s brought speed and he understood the intangibles in the locker room and the things that make a team a team,” Morehouse said. “I think it’s been extraordinary in such a short period of time.”
Sam Werner: swerner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @SWernerPG.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.