The Penguins won the Stanley Cup with a goaltender who might be the NHL’s rookie of the year.
In 2017.
And Matt Murray helped his team to earn that championship while playing behind a corps of defensemen that, Kris Letang aside, was widely regarded as ordinary. At best.
That unit, however, had a synergy that allowed it to exceed all reasonable expectations and to become a major, reliable contributor during the Cup run.
Whether the group can replicate its performance next season — or whether it even will get a chance to try — remains to be seen, but nothing can take away what it accomplished this spring.
Here’s a look at goaltenders and defensemen who played significant roles for the Penguins during the just-concluded season:
GOALIES
Marc-Andre Fleury — He should be the most intriguing story this offseason. Fleury was the Penguins’ best player for much of 2015-16 and would have been their No. 1 goalie in the playoffs if not for getting a concussion March 31. But Murray, 22, is nine years younger and, now, battle-tested. With the threat of losing Fleury in an expansion draft next year, general manager Jim Rutherford might look to trade him this summer, although Fleury’s contract allows him to name 12 teams to which he cannot be dealt. Dallas and Calgary, among others, likely will inquire if he goes on the market. Then again, Rutherford could opt to keep him, even if Fleury would request a trade, because the value of having two high-quality goaltenders was proven this spring.
Matt Murray — He appeared in 19 playoff games, six more than during the regular season. Murray’s mental toughness is among his greatest assets, and his place as the Penguins’ long-term goaltender seems secure.
Jeff Zatkoff — A classic good soldier who filled the No. 2 and 3 roles at various times capably and without complaint, he is headed for unrestricted free agency and likely will seek a team where he can get more playing time. And, possibly, money.
DEFENSEMEN
Ian Cole — After a forgettable regular season, Cole elevated his game during the playoffs, doing his finest work when the stakes were highest. He likely is the Penguins’ most fearless and effective shot-blocker.
Trevor Daley — One of Rutherford’s key acquisitions, Daley added speed and skill. Losing him to a broken ankle in Game 4 of the Eastern Conference final created a huge hole on the blue line, but the Penguins managed to fill it.
Brian Dumoulin — He rivaled Murray as the breakout performer in these playoffs. Dumoulin’s arc of improvement has been steady, and he was effective on the No. 1 pairing. Not only solid defensively, he scored a couple of big goals.
Kris Letang — Despite a few high-profile hiccups during the playoffs, he spent a lot of time playing at levels few defensemen can reach, at both ends of the rink. There might well be a Norris Trophy or two in his future.
Ben Lovejoy — His work against Washington’s Alex Ovechkin was one of the most impressive individual efforts during these playoffs, when Lovejoy played the finest hockey of his career. He’s eligible for unrestricted free agency and never will be a star, but finding a way to keep him with the Penguins might be best for all concerned.
Olli Maatta — Coming off major shoulder surgery, Maatta had a thoroughly disappointing season — until Daley’s injury gave him a chance for redemption, and Maatta made the most of it. Odds are that 2015-16 was an aberration, and that Maatta will continue to develop into a force all over the ice.
Derrick Pouliot — He has real offensive talent, but it hasn’t translated to a top-six role in the NHL yet. If the Penguins begin to question whether Pouliot, 22, can live up to the potential that made him a No. 1 draft choice, he could be an attractive trade chip, but there’s a real risk in giving up on young defensemen too early.
Justin Schultz — Has there ever been a quicker image makeover? A few months ago, he was a healthy scratch and lightning rod for criticism in Edmonton. Now, he’s a champion after doing a nice job on the No. 3 pairing. It’s unlikely the Penguins will match his $3.9 million contract to retain his rights, but both sides would be well-served if a deal to keep him here can be struck.
Tomorrow: The forwards.
Dave Molinari: Dmolinari@Post-Gazette.com and Twitter @MolinariPG.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.