NEW YORK — One of hockey’s most enduring adages holds that power-play success is cyclical.

That a unit made up of the same guys, playing against the same penalty-killers, could convert opportunities almost at will for a while then, for no apparent reason, lapse into a run where it goes three weeks without a goal.

“That’s how power plays go, for the most part, in this league,” Penguins center Nick Bonino said. “You don’t see one team go the whole year at 20 percent. You’ll see a team go at 30 percent for a while, then 12 percent for a while.”

That’s perfectly reasonable.

Advertise with us

But it doesn’t begin to capture the wild fluctuations the Penguins power play has experienced this season.

They enter a game tonight against the New York Islanders at Barclays Center with a conversion rate of 18.4 percent, which tied Arizona for 16th place in the league rankings before Monday.

But the Penguins have taken a wild route to get to a power play whose overall numbers — 45 goals on 244 opportunities — are decidedly ordinary.

They have scored three times on 16 tries in their past five games, which is a fairly normal output.

But that came immediately after a nine-game stretch in which they were 0 for 17 with the extra man.

Advertise with us

Which came in the wake of a 20-game run when they scored on 20 of 68 chances.

Which followed a seven-game stretch in which they were 0 for 19.

Which came after they had scored eight times in 30 tries over the previous seven games.

So while there’s nothing strange about a power play that runs hot and cold, the Penguins’ has alternated between scalding and frozen.

Maintaining their recent revival won’t be easy tonight because New York is one of the league’s best short-handed clubs.

Advertise with us

The Islanders have the NHL’s second-ranked penalty-kill, with a success rate of 86.4 percent, and are even more efficient at home, killing 88.8 percent of the power plays they’ve faced.

The Penguins converted 1 of 4 opportunities with the man-advantage in their 6-1 victory Sunday at New Jersey, and it was an important goal.

Evgeni Malkin scored it at 9:14 of the opening period to give the Penguins a 1-0 lead, which spared them having to play from behind against the Devils.

“Against a team like Jersey, usually we have one or two [power plays],” Malkin said. “Not a lot. It’s very important to take advantage of the moment.”

Unlike some extra-man goals the Penguins score, there was nothing especially flashy about Malkin’s. It was the byproduct of good puck movement and a blistering shot by Malkin.

Advertise with us

There are times, however, when the Penguins — who deploy elite talents such as Malkin, Sidney Crosby and Kris Letang when they are awarded a power play — stray from the fundamentals that led to Malkin’s goal and seem more interested in generating something that will earn them airtime on a highlights show.

“With that unit, we have to keep in mind that we have to work hard, and goals will come with our skill,” Letang said. “If you get too comfortable and we start making too many fancy plays, that’s when our power play [conversion rate] starts decreasing.”

There are no style points in the NHL. If the Penguins are to secure a playoff berth, and, perhaps earn a better seed, they will need reliable work by their penalty-killing and power play over the final 17 games.

“Whenever we’re winning those special-teams battles,” Bonino said, “we’re usually winning the games.”

Dave Molinari: Dmolinari@Post-Gazette.com and Twitter @MolinariPG.