NEW YORK — The Penguins knew going in that the New York Islanders have one of the NHL’s premier penalty-killing units.

They also recognized that New York’s power play can be far more lethal than its middle-of-the-road ranking might suggest.

“You just have to look at the talent they have,” defensema Kris Letang said.

The quality of the Islanders’ power play wasn’t just evident in New York’s 2-1 victory against the Penguins Tuesday night at Barclays Center; it was decisive.

Advertise with us

New York got both of its goals on a total of four power plays and needed a total of only 29 seconds with the man-advantage to generate them.

John Tavares opened the scoring at 8:04 of the first period — nine seconds after Penguins winger Patric Hornqvist was penalized for hooking — when his slap shot from the top of the right circle caromed off the stick of defenseman Brian Dumoulin and past goalie Marc-Andre Fleury.

After Letang pulled the Penguins even at 13:13 by taking a cross-ice feed from Sidney Crosby and beating New York goalie Jaroslav Halak from below the right dot, the teams battled for the go-ahead goal until the midpoint of the third period was approaching.

The pivotal moment came at 8:35, when Penguins center Matt Cullen was penalized for cross-checking Ryan Pulock.

“I got knocked down in the corner and got up and just got my stick up,” Cullen said. “It’s a penalty I can’t take at that point of the game.”

Advertise with us

That point was made emphatically 20 seconds later, when Anders Lee camped out in front of Fleury and deflected in a Nick Leddy shot for what proved to be the winner.

The Penguins pressed for the tying goal right until the final seconds of regulation, when Phil Kessel appeared to have a mostly open net from the left side. But his shot was blocked before it reached goalie Thomas Greiss, who had entered the game after Halak was hurt with 4:22 left in regulation.

“I don’t know what to tell you guys,” Kessel said. “I really don’t feel like talking about it, to be honest.”

Despite the loss, the Penguins (34-24-8) retain the first wild-card spot in the Eastern Conference because Detroit was a 5-3 loser in Columbus. They remain one point ahead of the Red Wings.

The Penguins are five points behind the Islanders, who sit third in the Metropolitan Division.

Advertise with us

“We knew how important that game was,” Letang said. “They knew, too.”

The Islanders kept pace with the second-place New York Rangers, and figure to present a formidable challenge for any team they face in the playoffs.

“They have a good transition game,” Penguins coach Mike Sullivan said. “They have a dynamic player in [John] Tavares, who is one of the elite players in the league. They have balance through their lineup.”

The Penguins appear to, as well. They ran up a 35-27 advantage in shots, and would have been able to take home at least a point if they had scored on any of their three power plays.

They created some good pressure and opportunities — “We had tons of shots. We had good net-front presence. We had a lot of chances,” Letang said — but never got anything tangible for their efforts.

Advertise with us

“They definitely make you work, and you can’t make a lot of pretty plays,” Crosby said. “I thought we worked hard, but the execution wasn’t quite there.

“It doesn’t feel good, because that’s the difference in the game. In other games, it may not hurt you. But working hard is not enough. We have to find a way to get at least a goal.”

Dave Molinari: Dmolinari@Post-Gazette.com and Twitter @MolinariPG.