Dan LaCouture was admittedly a better baseball player growing up, but hockey always meant something more to him.

The son of a high school coach in Natick, Mass., his mother often picked him up from elementary school to take him to the rink to watch his father conduct practice. Mr. LaCouture had a poster Mario Lemieux plastering the door of his childhood bedroom — a poster he had the hockey legend sign when Mr. LaCouture joined the Penguins in 2000.

“It was hard for me not to find my way on to the ice,” he said.

But what he didn’t know was that his love for the game came with a hefty toll, that the repeated and sometimes vicious hits to the head that ended his career would also lead to a litany of medical problems that continue to plague him long after his retirement from the National Hockey League.

Advertise with us

Mr. LaCouture is one of several former players suing the NHL for allegedly failing to disclose information about the dangers of concussions and subconcussive head injuries — smaller blows that don’t cause a concussion but have a cumulative effect — despite league officials, owners and even the commissioner knowing the risks the sport entailed.

The plaintiffs in the case are seeking compensation — specifically to cover medical costs — but they’re also aiming to change a system they believe kept them in the dark and ultimately prompted their physical deterioration.

“I had to retire because of concussions,” said Michel Petit, a 16-year NHL veteran who joined the case as a plaintiff earlier this month. “What I went through, I don’t want anyone else to have to go through that. It’s about being loud and clear so the people are aware of what’s going on and how dangerous concussions can be.”

The plaintiffs achieved perhaps their biggest victory yet in late March, when a federal judge in Minnesota denied the NHL’s motion to dismiss the case, citing, among other things, that the league did not convince her that a statute of limitations applied to the players’ complaints.

The case now moves on to the discovery process, where the plaintiffs have sent deposition subpoenas to NHL commissioner Gary Bettman and former Penguins doctor Charles Burke, who currently runs a sports medicine and orthopedic practice in Aspinwall.

Advertise with us

Dr. Burke holds a particular level of interest for the plaintiffs. He was the Penguins’ head physician for more than two decades and oversaw the treatment of Sidney Crosby when the Penguins’ star missed 108 games with a concussion over the 2010-11 and 2011-12 seasons. Mr. Crosby’s recovery was noteworthy not just because of his stature, but because of how it transpired. After returning for eight games in 2011, Mr. Crosby took a big hit in a Dec. 5 loss to the Boston Bruins. What was originally described as a cautionary measure that would force him to miss two games turned into a 40-game absence to deal with concussion-like symptoms again.

Dr. Burke also was a contributor to an NHL and NHLPA-launched study, published in 2011, that examined concussions among the league’s players between 1997 and 2004. The study concluded “more should be done to educate all involved with the sport about the potential adverse effects associated with continuing to play while symptomatic, failing to report symptoms to medical staff and failure to recognize or evaluate any suspected concussion.”

The plaintiffs have criticized the study for being inconclusive and serving to conceal facts required to put players on notice. Dr. Burke, who left the Penguins in 2012, did not respond to multiple calls seeking comment.

In its motion to dismiss, the NHL argued it had no duty to disclose information about the effects of concussions because such knowledge was publicly available. The court, however, was not persuaded by that argument, noting that players lacked things like the injury data the NHL receives from every team after every game.

“While we would have hoped for a different result on this motion, we understand that the case is at a relatively early stage, and there will be ample opportunity for us to establish our defenses as the discovery process progresses,” Gary Meagher, the executive vice president of communications for the NHL, said in an email.

Advertise with us

The case comes on the heels of similar litigation filed against the National Football League by former players who claimed the league hid information about the damages of brain injuries. Several lawyers involved with the NHL lawsuit were also involved the NFL case, which is in the hands of a judge after both sides reached a settlement agreement. After the football litigation received a lot of attention, hockey players reached some of the lawyers involved to see if they had a similar case.

The NHL lawsuit comes with a lengthy legal process, as discovery alone may take the rest of the calendar year to complete.

The players say the league’s failure to inform and protect players came with physical consequences. Michael Peluso, a plaintiff in the case, had at least five concussions in his nine-year career. Mr. LaCouture, who played in the NHL from 1998 through 2008, suffered about 20 concussions and numerous subconcussive injuries.

He never thought much about the ailments’ long-term effects during his playing days, but upon his retirement, Mr. LaCouture noticed some distressing changes. He was increasingly irritable. His sensitivity to light was so severe that he’d get nauseous any time he sat in the front seat of a car without tinted windows. To cope with the pain, he would often turn to alcohol or Ambien, a drug usually prescribed to treat sleep disorders.

While attending a lecture by Ann McKee, a Boston University neuropathologist and one of the nation’s leading experts in neurodegenerative disorders, Mr. LaCouture realized that he had many of the symptoms associated with chronic traumatic encephalopathy (CTE), a progressive degenerative disease of the brain found in people with a history of repetitive head trauma. While the disease is most commonly associated with football, it impacts any athlete who experiences the types of violent head impacts that football players endure.

Advertise with us

“There is clearly growing momentum for the litigation amongst former players who are concerned about the long-term effects of the repetitive head trauma they sustained in the NHL,” said Charles Zimmerman, the plaintiffs’ co-lead counsel. “We hope this case will allow former players to finally hold the NHL accountable for its misconduct so they can receive the care and support they urgently need.”

The plaintiffs’ case extends beyond their assertion the NHL withheld information. They allege the league also encouraged violence — such as fighting — to appeal to fans without properly treating players for head injuries.

The culture created by fighting thrust some into a team’s unofficial role of enforcer, a designation requiring less skill but a willingness to get into fights with opposing players. It’s a punishing job, but players such as Mr. LaCouture accepted it as a way to stay in the league.

Injuries sustained during games or fights were, according to the plaintiffs, met with insubstantial care from team medical personnel. Mr. Petit, the NHL player who joined the case this month, said that when he began his professional career in the early 1980s, a concussed player was cleared to return to play if he properly identified how many fingers someone was holding up.

“It’s not a bruise; it’s more serious than that,” Mr. LaCouture said. “Anybody that comes into the league now who isn’t aware of the long-term effects has got to be living in a cave or something. It is so out there now versus when guys before me or guys my age came in.

Advertise with us

“We were completely, 100 percent unaware. It wasn’t something that was in the locker room that a few teammates knew. Everyone was under the same impression that if you felt a little foggy, it wasn’t as big of a deal. What are you going to do? Are you going to feel like a weakling?”

Craig Meyer: cmeyer@post-gazette.com and Twitter @CraigMeyerPG.

A previous version of this article misstated the nature of Dr. Charles Burke’s departure from the Penguins. His parting was a mutual decision.

The subpoena deposition came from the plaintiff’s attorneys. A previous version misstated their role.