The state and local government's proposed plan for alternative arena funding and the NHL bylaws have dovetailed nicely to make it difficult for a new owner to move the Penguins to another city.
It apparently wasn't orchestrated by the two entities.
Allegheny County Chief Executive Dan Onorato yesterday said neither he nor other local or state officials were angling for their "Plan B" to reinforce the NHL's tough stance on franchise relocation or even knew the details of the league bylaw, although he said the effect of the two "sounds positive."
Onorato said he doesn't sense additional pressure to get Plan B done, but that he, Mayor Bob O'Connor and Gov. Ed Rendell have been working under the assumption for some time "that a new multipurpose facility has to be part of the deal" with a new owner because of the proliferation of new, revenue-generating arenas throughout the NHL.
Before it was reported yesterday, Onorato said he and other officials were not aware that a Canadian group that had the highest of the five bids for the Penguins at $175 million or more withdrew after realizing that Plan B might limit its options.
That Canadian group, which has guarded its identity, was believed to be interested in either keeping the Penguins in Pittsburgh or moving them to a city with a better arena option, but probably not Hamilton, Ontario, as earlier thought.
There are four remaining bidders. A decision on which will sign a letter of intent could come any day.
NHL commissioner Gary Bettman has said he would prefer that the Penguins stay in Pittsburgh. A league spokesman said Bettman was not available and that there would be no comment from the NHL.
The new Penguins owner will be obligated to abide by the team's agreement with gaming company Isle of Capri, which will donate $290 million for a new arena if it gets the city's slots license sometime around December.
If Isle of Capri doesn't get the slots license, Plan B comes into play. As long as Plan B is a viable option for a new facility to replace outdated Mellon Arena, it seems the NHL would have the power to nix any relocation plans for the Penguins.
A copy of the four-page Section 36 of the NHL bylaws, dealing with franchise relocations, was obtained from the league.
There are 24 areas of consideration that are to be used in determining whether to allow a team to move, including "whether there is a reasonable prospect ... that it could become financially viable" and whether the club received a "publicly financed arena, special tax treatment, or any other form of public financial support."
A new arena under Plan B would arguably give the Penguins a reasonable chance of financial health, and it could fit the criteria of public financial support.
Also considered under the NHL bylaws would be local fan support, whether local authorities could help reduce operating costs and whether a move would harm the league's image or make travel, scheduling and divisional alignment difficult.
The Penguins, who led the league in attendance increase in 2005-06 despite having the NHL's second-worst record, are expected to get a favorable lease at a new arena. Their Mellon Arena lease expires in June 2007.
Under Plan B, Isle of Capri's competitors, Forest City and PITG Gaming, have made written commitments to the state to provide $7.5 million per year for 30 years toward arena construction if they get the slots license.
The Penguins would commit $8.5 million up front, then contribute $4.1 million per year. The state has $7 million per year earmarked from a slots-backed development fund. Rendell, Onorato and O'Connor also are using $26.5 million in state funds to start acquiring and preparing land in Uptown for a new arena.
The city and county's goal is to have the new arena under construction in 2007 and have it completed in 2009.
It's believed that part of the Canadian group's concern centered on being locked into Plan B without knowing what the actual costs will be, including construction cost overruns and delays that might mean more time spent in Mellon Arena, which is sure to equal financial losses.
Onorato said having a new arena and a lease that "makes sense" to the owners will have a positive effect.
The Steelers and Pirates were responsible for cost overruns at their new facilities in exchange for control over construction, and Onorato said the current thinking is to work out a similar deal with the Penguins' owner. He said that is subject for negotiation.
"None of that has been agreed to until we have a signed document. Right now, that is a discussion item. Nothing has been agreed upon," he said.
He added that he and the mayor are prepared to sit down with the new owner to provide whatever assurances or guarantees are necessary to try to get an arena built as quickly as possible.
"All we can do is put Pittsburgh in the best possible position to keep the franchise here," Onorato said.
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.


Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.