Key advice culled from the Penguins’ 8-5 win over the Ottawa Senators on Monday at PPG Paints Arena: Don’t start Marc-Andre Fleury or Matt Murray three games in a row.

Coach Mike Sullivan tried that with Murray a couple weeks back, and he wound up nearly getting hurt in the Penguins’ worst performance of the season. This one nearly cost the Penguins a game.

Fleury wasn’t terrible — he wasn’t great, either — and Sullivan lifted him after 27 minutes, 8 seconds and a fourth goal allowed on 16 shots.

The goalie change turned out to pay major dividends, though. Murray entered and stopped 17 of 18 shots, giving the Penguins offense a chance to kick it into gear.

Advertise with us

“Anytime you’re forced to change goalies, it gets everybody’s attention,” Matt Cullen said.

And the Penguins responded the way Sullivan had hoped.

“It was more about maybe trying to change the mindset of the 18 skaters in front of (Fleury),” Sullivan said. “Sometimes when you get in those situations, you make that type of a change, maybe you could provide a spark for the group or change the mindset a little bit.

“We responded the right way. We played hard. I thought our five-on-five play was pretty strong tonight.”

What does this mean going forward?

Advertise with us

That Murray is likely to start the Penguins’ next game, Thursday in Florida. It makes the most sense to play Fleury Saturday in Tampa, too.

Because if you don’t, and come back with him next Tuesday, that’s eight days between starts.

Sullivan, so far, has tried to avoid that much lag time, although sometimes it’s unavoidable. Of course, if Murray pitches a shutout against the Panthers, he’s not going anywhere.

The funny thing about these goalie changes is they don’t always work. If a team doesn’t have it, it’s like trying to jumpstart a car without tires.

Tonight should also stoke the “they play better in front of Murray than Fleury” narrative, and it’s kind of hard to shoot it down. Other than I do think they tend to press a little more when Fleury’s in net.

Advertise with us

We know this much about tonight: The Penguins woke up when their coach sent a message, and their defensive problems are not isolated to who’s in goal. They run much, much deeper than that.

“That was kind of a wakeup call for the rest of the team to push a little bit harder,” Bryan Rust said of the goalie change. “That’s what we did.”

Play of the game: Cullen’s goal

Trevor Daley and Rust apply pressure. Turnover. Cullen accelerates and gets it. Dion Phaneuf is flat-footed. Goodbye. Cullen, off to the races, even holding off Erik Karlsson, goes to his backhand to roof one past Craig Anderson for his sixth of the season — pushing him ahead of his 16-goal pace from a season ago.

Also, how brutal that Anderson had to stick around for a touchdown? Mike Condon couldn’t get into a Penguins game WHEN HE WAS ON THE OTHER TEAM.

Advertise with us

The Penguins penalty kill has had its share of struggles (see below), but Cullen’s goal injected some life, gave the unit a rare reason to smile and delivered a sense the Penguins could come back.

It was also a really, really pretty goal for anyone, let alone a 40-year-old.

“I didn’t know if I would be able to get all the way to the net,” Cullen said. “I was getting ready to shoot, but I was happy I was able to get all the way in there and make a move.”

Lowpoint: Penalty kill bottoms out

Things are not good for the Penguins penalty kill right now. They allowed three goals for the second time in the past six games, two in the second period and one in the third.

Advertise with us

They’ve killed just 25 of 37 power play opportunities over their last 11 games, a success rate of 67.6.

“The group as a whole lacks a little confidence right now,” Sullivan said.

I wrote about this a few days ago. At the beginning it was only failed clearing attempts. Now, the penalty killers are getting yanked all over the rink.

The same guys, mind you, who were doing this a year ago.

“We’ve got virtually the same personnel that we used for quite some time now, with a very similar scheme,” Sullivan said. “They’re familiar with the scheme. They’re familiar with the concepts. They’re very good penalty killers. For whatever reason, it’s been a struggle this year, most specifically as of late. Sometimes you start squeezing your stick, you try a little bit too hard, and you can almost exacerbate the issues.

Advertise with us

“We just have to simplify the process. We’ll sort it out. We know we have good penalty killers. We believe in the scheme we have. We’ll try to make some tweaks. For me, the most important thing is I think we have to instill some confidence in these guys that they are good and they can be a very good penalty kill when they’re on the ice.”

Dave Molinari wrote about more of the Penguins defensive issues in his game story here.

Player of the game: Bryan Rust

Rust recorded his first career hat trick. He finished a ridiculous Evgeni Malkin feed in the first, then scored on a penalty shot and an empty-net goal in the third period.

“There aren’t many nights that happens,” Rust said of the hat trick and finishing with four points. “It’s nice to have that happen.”

Advertise with us

Despite playing an integral part all game, recording five shots and eight attempts in 12:38, Rust said he was most nervous while awaiting his penalty shot.

“My heart was probably racing faster than it did all game,” Rust said. “That’s kind of my go-to move. I just stuck with it.”

Here’s Sam Werner’s sidebar on Rust, who recorded the first hat trick for the Penguins since Patric Hornqvist did it on Feb. 26 against Arizona.

Malkin and Kessel contributed three-point nights. Sidney Crosby also scored his 17th goal of the season, again avoiding back-to-back games without a goal.

Numbers of note

Advertise with us

11: Home point streak for Malkin, who finished with a goal and two assists. He has five goals and 18 points during this particular run.

22: Goals for the Penguins in their last four home games.

3: Consecutive games with a goal for Justin Schultz. It’s also the number of multi-game efforts in a row for Ian Cole, who picked up another two assists.

13: Wins out of 49 under Sullivan in the regular season where the Penguins have been down by two goals.

46: Shots on goal for the Penguins, who held a 72-62 edge in shot attempts. That’s 40-plus shots on goal in three of five and six of 13.

Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.