Welcome to Paul Zeise’s weekly mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist answers your questions about sports, life and everything in between. If you want to ask a question, find him on X @PaulZeise or email him at pzeise@post-gazette.com.

Let’s get started:

David: With Oneil Cruz’s defensive liabilities, how about putting him on first base?

Zeise: Cruz is a bad fielder, has no feel or natural instincts to play the field and is shaky on even routine plays. Do you really want that guy at first base, where he is going to have a lot of activity? They moved him away from shortstop to get him further away from the action. He is a designated hitter and the sooner they accept it, the better off everyone will be.

Advertise with us

Scott: It has been widely reported that “Henry Davis is the preferred catcher for Paul Skene’s” and other pitchers on staff. My question is, how is that received by Joey Bart and Endy? I mean, what if pitchers start demanding that “Mangum be the CF” when I pitch. Or “Griffin is my personal SS” Not that I would object to either being the case, but It can’t be great for team chemistry knowing that certain players feel they, and the team, are diminished when certain players are in the lineup.

Zeise: The catcher is different and pitchers need to feel a certain level of comfort with the guy who is calling a game for them. Catchers manage pitchers. And while Davis cannot hit a lick, he is an excellent defensive catcher and signal-caller, so to speak. Not every pitcher has the juice to demand their catcher, but I’m thinking the Pirates will do whatever it takes to keep Skenes happy.

Jason M: It feels like this weekend may be the last time we get to see Sidney Crosby versus Alexander Ovechkin because Ovechkin is rumored to be retiring. If that is the case do you think the Penguins will have any kind of tribute to Ovechkin since he is an all time great and he and Crosby as a rivalry has carried the NHL for almost two decades?

Zeise: I have read nothing that suggests Ovechkin is going to retire. He might, but I have not seen anyone report that in any way. I think what is happening is an old guy is coming to town and some fear it may be for the last time. And unless the Pens are sure he is retiring, I am not sure why they would give him a tribute of any sort as he will be back twice next year.

Jase: With what Dan Muse has done with the Penguins compared to what Mike Sullivan has done with the Rangers, do you think the old "won championship=lifetime contract" crowd will finally shut up?

Advertise with us

Zeise: It is way too early to make this comparison. Sullivan could turn it around in a year or two and then make a run to the Stanley Cup and many of Muse’s best players will start retiring soon. I don’t think it is a fair comparison. I do think what it proves is a change at the top — even when the guy at the top is a really good coach — can be a good thing, a spark. Let’s see if the same kind of spark happens to the team across the river.

Jim: Watching Pitt hoops implode is painful. Is Pitt trying to keep any of these guys or encouraging them to leave?

Zeise: It depends on who you ask. There has been some stuff leaking out that some of these guys wanted too much money and Pitt wasn’t going to pay them. The idea is this roster went 13-20, so how many of these players can be that good? I have to agree on some level, but not retaining Roman Siulepa was a huge blow. He is going to be a beast for the next few years no matter where he ends up.

Amy: Do you really think it is possible for Pitt to build an entire roster that is capable of winning in one offseason? I mean, I know some teams have done it but they had money and haven’t been wallowing around in a decade of ineptitude.

Zeise: I mean, anything is possible, but you are right that this feels like a long shot at best. It feels like they are going to have to hit on pretty much every transfer they bring in. And that means they are going to have to outbid a lot of good teams for good players in order to make it happen.

Advertise with us

Nick: With most of their other teams winning at a high level, why do you think Penn State does not seem to care about either of their basketball programs?

Zeise: Because they are expensive and there isn’t a basketball culture there. I do think they want to care about women’s basketball and used to be really good, but they have seemingly been clueless on how to run a program. The school has always valued football and wrestling and now even ice hockey over men’s basketball, and I don’t think that is going to change.

Greg: Of all of the “old school” events of sports that have faded - boxing championships, horse racing, tennis and even in some ways golf, is the Masters the only one that still is actually relevant?

Zeise: The Kentucky Derby is still a huge event. Tennis is on life support and mostly because Americans never seem to win much at it any more. Wimbledon maybe has some value but I am not sure how much. The U.S. Open in golf is still huge, as is the Masters. But you are right, when I was growing up, boxing, horse racing and tennis were all huge.