Welcome to Paul Zeise’s weekly mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist answers your questions about sports, life and everything in between. If you want to ask a question, find him on X @PaulZeise or email him at pzeise@post-gazette.com.
Let’s get started:
Nick: Do you think RB Rico Dowdle will be a better complement to Jaylen Warren than Kenneth Gainwell was?
Zeise: I mean, Gainwell won the team MVP award so Dowdle has a lot of work to do in order to just duplicate, much less surpass what he did. I think they are different running backs, though, so it will be hard to compare. I think Dowdle is a better pure running back and Gainwell is a better all-around football player. So if the idea is going to be to use Dowdle in running situations, he will be more productive than Gainwell was. I think it was a good pickup for the Steelers though not sure why they wouldn’t just sign Gainwell again.
Amy: If Aaron Rodgers doesn’t sign with the Steelers, what is Plan B? Would they really go with Will Howard and Mason Rudolph?
Zeise: Plan B is Jameis Winston!!!! OK, I can dare to dream. I would love Winston to come here, he would make the Steelers actually entertaining to watch. In all seriousness, I don’t think there is a Plan B because it is pretty clear Rodgers is going to come back and be the starter for at least one more season.
Read More
Marty: Are you starting to believe in ONeil Cruz? I know it is a small sample size but he has really hit the ball well the last few days.
Zeise: Yeah, no. We have seen Cruz go nuts for a few weeks and then be terrible for a few months. I need to see a lot more, much more before I am ready to declare that he has turned the corner. I sure hope for the Pirates sake it is true, but he needs to do it more consistently over a longer period of time.
Jason M: Why do the Pirates always seem to have this mascot player that can never play his way out of the lineup no matter how bad he is? I don’t understand it, I really don’t. This year it is Jared Triolo, who is not a good hitter yet seems to be in the lineup every day and I think he even lead off one day. Why?
Zeise: They are a small market team that tries to convince us they were winning with hard-nosed players or something. Triolo is at least a really good defensive player, but I agree I don’t need to see him in the lineup every day. He can’t hit well enough to be an every day player but he is a good dude who plays hard and says all the right things and those guys tend to hang around for a while.
Jason D: I’m done with Pitt basketball. They lost Brandin Cummings, a local product whose brother played here, and Roman Siulepa, by far their best player and prospect. What is Jeff Capel doing? Can you give me any reason to believe they will be better next year with what is left on the roster?
Zeise: Well, Cummings needed to go. He wasn’t helping, he didn’t fit, he didn’t seem happy. It is one of those transfers that is good for both sides. Now, Siulepa is a huge loss if you ask me, but he apparently wasn’t happy with the coaching shake-up. Pitt probably should have worked hard to keep him because he is a beast but the long and short of it is this — I expect a few more guys to leave and that will open up the roster. That was one of their goals, as they want to be able to build a roster that fits together well without having to accommodate current players who aren’t good enough.
Nick L: I loved Ronald Ramon as a player but is this the kind of upgrade Pitt needed in its coaching staff? It seems like we are well beyond the place and time when feel-good stories of former players coming home should even be on the radar.
Zeise: I can’t speak to his ability to coach. He has been an assistant coach for six seasons or so, but I don’t know what his duties were or have been. I am sure he will relate to the players well, I am sure that he can draw on his experiences as a player and he is a different voice than has been in the room, so those are all positive signs. Ultimately, it is about what the roster looks like that will matter.
Chad: What is something you don't like about this region sports-wise? I hate the fact that almost all head coaches are like Supreme Court Justices with lifetime job appointments.
Zeise: Ha ha ha ha that’s great and I entirely agree and will take it one step further: How about this dumb thing where every hire or signing seemingly has to be of the “Back to the Future” variety. You know what I mean — “We conducted a long national search for a football coach and happened to hire a guy from Greenfield who used to coach next door.....”
Jase: Is Penn State Wrestling the best story in sports that has flown under the radar? They've won 5 straight team national titles, and yet they are hardly ever mentioned.
Zeise: It is but it is a niche sport and there aren’t even that many wrestling programs left. That isn’t to diminish what they have done, it is remarkable, but interest in it is very limited. And you find if you look hard enough that all those smaller sports seem to have dynasty teams.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.