Welcome to Paul Zeise’s weekly mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist answers your questions about sports, life and everything in between. If you want to ask a question, find him on X @PaulZeise or email him at pzeise@post-gazette.com.
Let’s get started:
Amy: Will the next coach have the power over personnel decisions like Mike Tomlin had or will it be something he will have to earn? Does this move make Omar Khan the most powerful person in the organization?
Zeise: The Steelers have always been set up as an organization that allows its coach to be heavily involved in personnel decisions. It is the way the organization is structured. I would assume the new coach initially won’t wield quite as big of a stick as Tomlin because Tomlin was the coach for 19 years. That is why it is ridiculous that people act as if he had nothing to do with the flaws in the current roster. He handpicked every single player on this roster, including the quarterback. That is how the Steelers are set up.
Jason M: We have always heard that Mike Tomlin would get a job easily and without hesitation if he left yet we haven’t heard his name mentioned in a single job search. Why do you think that is?
Zeise: I mean, if you listen to Art Rooney II from the other day it is pretty simple. Tomlin made it clear to Rooney that he is taking a year off from coaching. He wants to work on doing things he hasn’t been able to do because he has been coaching for so long. He would probably never admit it but he probably has a little coaching burnout and needs to pull back and recharge.
Read More
Bill: How would it work if Mike Tomlin wanted to work somewhere else? What would the Steelers get in return in a trade?
Zeise: Just like any other trade. Tomlin would find a team that wants to hire him and then they would have to work something out with the Steelers in terms of compensation. I bet they could get a first-round pick for Tomlin and maybe even something more added on top of that.
Harold: Do you think the Steelers will consider moving some of their older players now that Mike Tomlin is gone?
Zeise: I don’t know that one thing leads to the other, but they will have to reconsider the roster and work to make it better and stronger. They have old players on this roster and they could probably stand to rebuild in some areas, but Rooney made it very clear that he doesn’t want to rebuild and isn’t interested in not being competitive every year.
Greg: Can you explain Pitt basketball? They have been terrible for many games but then have games like against Penn State and Georgia Tech which make them look like a Final Four team.
Zeise: Yes, they aren’t very good and every so often they have a good game. I mean, if a couple of players have good games at the same time then they have a chance to win. And Georgia Tech also got overwhelmed and played a terrible game. These things happen. The bottom line is the Panthers are 8-9 and that record is fitting for what they actually are. I expect them to finish something like 15-18. That is just who they are, and they aren’t very well constructed.
Jase: What do you think of this Demond Williams Jr. situation? While I wouldn’t want someone who doesn’t want to play for me, these guys can’t simply do whatever they want and expect no consequences, which NIL and the transfer portal has unfortunately instilled in them.
Zeise: I think it is an embarrassment for Washington to take him back. I think it is ridiculous that he signed his contract and is shopping himself around. But I look at Washington and use that old Tomlin line “we want volunteers, not hostages,” and that applies here. If he wants to play somewhere else, go. I know he had a contract and that brings me to this point — every one of these contracts should have a buyout written into them. That would stop a lot of this foolishness.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.