Welcome to Paul Zeise’s weekly mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist answers your questions about sports, life and everything in between. If you want to ask a question, find him on X @PaulZeise or email him at pzeise@post-gazette.com.

Let’s get started:

Mike S: If the Steelers win, it will mean a playoff bid and another year of Mediocre Mike Tomlin football. Given that and given what you wrote about a loss meaning it gets blown up — shouldn’t Steelers fans root for the Ravens for the good of the franchise? And this is a serious question, by the way, I want them to lose because I can’t take Mike Tomlin football any more.

Zeise: There were at least five or six of you with some version of this question so here goes nothing...

Advertise with us

I don’t tell people how to root. I would say that the chance of change is greater if the Steelers lose than if they win against the Baltimore Ravens. And I would also say there is no guarantee that a loss would force Art Rooney to do anything dramatically different, so you might as well root for the Steelers to win. There is no way a loss to their biggest rival should be celebrated, especially since it does not mean that Tomlin is definitely getting fired.

Jon: Why doesn't Mike Tomlin’s fan club ever bring up he has a losing career playoff record? Seems only fair if they are going to brag about no losing seasons.

Zeise: It is one of those inconvenient facts about Tomlin they want to ignore. Yes, he never had a losing season, but he has a losing postseason record and that’s a part of his resume. I think people always want to use facts to support their argument and leave out facts that hurt it. Tomlin is a good coach and has had a good run but he is way overrated by many of his media fan boys. He has benefitted as much from the Steelers organization being as stable and well-run as they have benefitted from his coaching.

Lee: Do you really think that Mike Tomlin could be fired with a loss to the Ravens?

Zeise: No. I think it could turn into a mutual parting of ways, though. It would make it very clear that it is just time to move on. It is time.

Advertise with us

Oliver: Why were you surprised the Steelers lost a must-win game even to the Browns? This is who the Steelers are and always will be UNTIL THEY FIRE MIKE TOMLIN!!!

Zeise: Because the Cleveland Browns are awful. That’s why. I know they have had some success against the Steelers at home in recent years but I never thought they would beat the Steelers with everything riding on it. To me, if you lose to Shedeur Sanders, you deserve all the criticism you get.

Bernard: Is Harmon the most important player on the Steelers defense? Watt is obviously critical but there is quality depth on the OLB corps whereas the DL is quite thin.

Zeise: He appears to be. They are so much better against the run with him than without him. I don’t know that there is another player who seems to be irreplaceable on the defense — and that includes T.J. Watt.

Chad: Do you think too much emphasis has been placed on the Steelers winning a playoff game instead of the bigger picture, or is it a "walk before you run" deal?

Advertise with us

Zeise: I think it is walk before you run, actually. It would be nice to get back to talking about Super Bowls but one step at a time. This team can barely win a playoff game anymore. It is generally not fair to judge a team based on winning the Super Bowl, but making the playoffs and winning a game from time to time is a low bar to clear.

Lee: Is the NFL so greedy that they need to put all of their games on subscription services? I can’t even find them any more and I am not going to pay for them all just to watch games. This is really making me hate the NFL and not ever want to watch even on normal TV.

Zeise: It is the wave of the future. Network television is dying, cable television is dying and this new market is very lucrative. The NFL should pick a streaming service and stick with it and they could print money. It isn’t fun for consumers but by the same token it is the way television is going to be viewed in the future.

Chris: Do you think Aaron Rodgers has another year in him?

Zeise: I personally think he could play another year but I have to believe he is done. His body language all season has suggested he knows he should be fishing or on a beach or whatever he will do in retirement.

Advertise with us

Carolann: Given that DK Metcalf has had issues with this fan before that a monetary penalty made more sense than a suspension? It seems very harsh to not have him for the two biggest games of the year.

Zeise: No. Absolutely not. You cannot have players fighting fans under any circumstance. Dk Metcalf needs to grow up and move on. This goofball in Detroit is not a threat to him or his family. If you allow players to start engaging with fans in a physical way, all hell will break loose. The message was sent with a swift, stern suspension.

Jase: Is the current apathy over Pitt's athletic programs the result of years of mismanagement by former athletic director Heather Lyke? I believe a case can be made.

Zeise: Heather Lyke is gone, and while some of her legacy is a lot of debt and two long contract extensions with expensive buyouts, it is Allen Greene’s show now. And he has to show us all he can make bold moves and push the programs back to relevancy. Lyke in some ways set the athletic department back, but it is time to stop blaming her for every issue.

Luke: How is it possible that Pitt’s basketball teams are this bad? I used to go to all the men’s games and most of the women’s games. Now, I have no interest in ever going to the Petersen Center again.

Zeise: The women’s program has made some bad coaching hires and plays in a tough conference and gets lost. That program needs to be blown up and rebuilt from scratch by a coach that knows how to build a program, but that means investing money into it and I don’t see that happening. The men’s program is just about as mediocre as mediocre can be. They need to figure out if they want to be good at basketball or not, because what we are watching is a disaster.