Aaron Rodgers has had an awful lot of success against the Chicago Bears in his career, so naturally one of the talking points this week has been, “The Steelers need him to play because he dominates the Bears.”

Remind me again if Rodgers is 5-10 years younger than he actually is, whether he is still playing for the Packers and whether the Packers are still one of the best teams in football while the Bears are one of the worst.

OK, so the answers are no, no and no to those questions, which means Rodgers’ history with the Bears is absolutely irrelevant. And while I am at it, the Steelers’ history against the Bears in Chicago (they have only won there once) is irrelevant this week, as well.

Rodgers dominated the Bears when he was on an almost annually Super Bowl-contending Packers team and the Bears were usually bad. He should have dominated them because he was on a far superior team and had a lot of great weapons around him.

Advertise with us

That’s why I don’t care that Rodgers was great against the Bears. It doesn’t matter even a little bit heading into Sunday’s matchup between the Steelers and Bears at Soldier Field.

The Bears and Steelers, unlike the Packers and Bears during Rodgers’ Packers era, are reasonably evenly matched teams, and therefore this game will likely come down to which team plays the best game.

Rodgers is going to be 42 years old and in recent weeks, he has looked a little bit like an older player fading as he gets deeper into the season. He played his worst game of the season in a loss to the Chargers two weeks ago and last weekend, he struggled again against the Bengals before he was knocked out.

The thing is Rodgers showed during the early part of the season he can carry the Steelers offense despite its lack of playmakers. He has shown his experience and knowledge of defenses, decision making and ability to avoid big mistakes give the Steelers a chance to win every week.

That’s why the question before the Steelers coaching staff shouldn’t be about this week; it should be about the long term. The question isn’t, “Should we allow Rodgers to play with an injured wrist this week against the Bears?” It should be, “Which quarterback do we want to start a potential playoff game down the road?”

Advertise with us

The answer to that second question is easy, as Rodgers was brought to the Steelers to give them a chance to break their string of consecutive seasons without a playoff win. He was brought in to take the team deeper into the playoffs than it had been and he has a Hall of Fame resume that suggests he can.

And that being the case, Mike Tomlin should make the decision to give Rodgers this weekend off and play Mason Rudolph instead. He should give Rodgers a week to rest, to heal a little bit more and essentially have an opportunity to get a little bit fresher for the stretch run.

I’m not in the camp that Rudolph is better than Rodgers or that he should take over as the starter as some have suggested. Rodgers is the Steelers’ best option at quarterback for the long haul, but for this weekend, I don’t think he is.

He has a fracture in his left wrist and has taken a lot of hits over the last few games. At his age, healing is a little longer of a process, and I just don’t think it is smart to put him out there at less than 100%.

The Steelers have one of the oldest teams in football and really had some bad luck when it came to their open week, as it came really early in the season. This is a team that would have benefited greatly from a late open week because it would have given it a chance to heal and get refreshed for the stretch run.

Advertise with us

Rodgers has a built-in excuse to take the week off, as he is injured, and that would essentially serve as a second open week for him. I think it would be wise for the Steelers to consider this, especially because they have a capable backup in Rudolph.

The entire reason they brought Rudolph back is he is a reliable player who has proven he can win games for the Steelers in a pinch. The Bears aren’t terrible, but they aren’t elite either and frankly, if you look at their seven wins, I am not even sure how good they actually are.

Rudolph could run the offense. He does a good job of avoiding mistakes and he makes enough big plays to give the Steelers a chance to score enough points to win the game.

The Steelers relied on their defense to win their last game against the Bengals. They can do it again against the Bears. Rodgers needs a week off, and the Steelers would be smart to give it to him.