I understand the Pirates have a shiny toy by the name of Paul Skenes and many fans think they should do everything in their power to keep him on their roster as long as they possibly can.
I also understand Oneil Cruz is the kind of potential superstar the Pirates could never afford to sign and thus their best chance at a player who hits 50 home runs in a season is to hold on to him and hope he becomes a better hitter.
I get the sentiment on both players and how the Pirates trading either would essentially feel like they are giving up, but nothing could be further from the truth.
The Pirates should give up — at least on this rendition of a rebuild — and start over. If they do that, there is no reason for them to not see what the market is for both Skenes and Cruz. Obviously the market for Cruz will be less than that of Skenes, but both could attract a very nice return.
I am not saying the Pirates should dump Skenes for nothing, and maybe the proper time to trade him would be the offseason. But there is zero chance they will sign him to a long-term deal when he becomes a free agent, so he won’t be available to them when they are ready to start winning again.
That’s why the Pirates would be stupid not to start fielding offers for him now as opposed to two years from now, when everyone knows they are going to be selling him and thus his value will go down. Right now, the Pirates hold all the cards, and if some team is willing to come in and give them a king’s ransom for him, why would they not want to trade him?
Read More
I think the Pirates could — or at least should — be able to get even more for Skenes than they did for Gerrit Cole because he is four years younger than Cole was when they traded him to the Astros. He also is in the midst of a better season than Cole was having and, most importantly, he has three more years of control, whereas Cole only had one.
The Pirates got Colin Moran, Joe Musgrove, Jason Martin and Michael Feliz for Cole, which, in retrospect, was not exactly a very good haul. Moran was basically just a guy, Musgrove was a good piece and Martin and Feliz were not particularly useful. But that has a lot more to do with the way the players were evaluated by the Pirates than anything else. The point is it should have produced four major league players for one.
Skenes might command three or four top prospects who will bolster the roster in the next two or three years, along with a couple of prospects who are more than a few years away. That should be the Pirates’ goal, not to hang on to Skenes so they can sell a lot of tickets and keep fans happy he is on the roster.
If the Pirates had a chance of signing Skenes to a long-term deal, my thoughts would be different — quite different. But let’s stop with these flights of fantasy like Bob Nutting is all of a sudden going to find it within himself to sign Skenes to a $400 million deal or whatever it is going to take by the time he is a free agent.
My thoughts are the same about Cruz and they go along with the fact he still has value based on potential. Teams might overpay for him based on his talent, his age and the fact he really only has two years of experience. (He has appeared in 335 major league games.) There is some potential still seen in him, and as a result, his value as a trade chip might be as high now as it will be.
True, he could figure it out, all of a sudden start mashing and change his value, but he could also go two more years down the road playing the same way, and then his ceiling and “potential” will be considerably lower.
Also, Cruz has three years of control beyond this one, so if someone like the Yankees were truly sniffing around, I would hope the Pirates front office would be willing to listen and listen closely in the hopes they can make a deal.
The Pirates should not give either Skenes or Cruz away and should obviously make sure they squeeze as much value out of them as they can, but the idea either or both are untouchable is idiotic. There are no untouchables for a team that is facing another three- or four-year rebuild because very few, if any, of the players on this roster will be a part of the team when — if — they finally get good again.
Skenes is the best pitcher in baseball and worth the price of admission on his own, but he isn’t going to be a part of the Pirates in 2028 and 2029. There is no reason not to at least see what teams are willing to give up for him.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.