Star athlete wants more money. Star athlete holds out and refuses to join practices until he gets it.
This is a tale as old as time — or at least as old as professional sports became a big business. Actually, scratch that. I did some research and found instances of players in the 1960s who held out for more money, so maybe it is a tale as old as time.
One of the most famous holdouts was in 1960, when both Sandy Koufax and Don Drysdale held out on the Dodgers because they weren’t happy with how they were compensated. The holdout ended with Koufax becoming the highest-paid player in MLB at a whopping $125,000 and Drysdale getting $110,000.
We laugh at those numbers today because even when you convert them to inflation-adjusted 2025 dollars, the Dodgers would have two of the best pitchers in baseball signed for about $1.2 million and $1.1 million, respectively, or less than what Shohei Ohtani will make in a week.
Nevertheless, Koufax and Drysdale were labeled greedy, and many fans were angry at them for holding out, but they ended up getting a raise and playing that season.
I bring this up because the biggest story of the day — or at least the one that seems to be generating the most outrage — is quarterback Nico Iamaleava holding out from spring practice because he asked for $4 million and apparently wasn’t going to get it.
Read More
Now, what sets this one apart is Iamaleava doesn’t play for a pro team. He is the quarterback of the Tennessee Volunteers, i.e., the University of Tennessee. He is a college player, a student-athlete, someone who is playing college football.
When I first saw all of these posts on social media, I had to scratch my head to figure out what the controversy even was, to be honest.
And by the end of reading it all, my question to anyone who was angry about this is simply: What in the heck did you expect was going to happen in big-time college athletics in the era of NIL and revenue-sharing payrolls?
Why is anybody surprised by this at all? What is anyone even batting an eye or losing a minute’s sleep about this anymore? It is the way big-time college athletics are and will be now that they have morphed into professional sports.
My biggest objection to the reaction, I am being quite honest, is there is still too large of a segment of the population who is fantasizing about the days of amateurism, purity and guys playing for the colors, the tradition and all of that other nonsense.
Let me help all of you who are still struggling with this and put it as clearly as possible: College athletics as your grandfather knew them are dead. They are dead and are never every coming back, and the sooner you accept that, the happier you will be.
Iamaleava’s case may be the first outright “holdout” and may be the one that has caused a shockwave, but he is just doing what every other player is doing — angling for the most money.
I know many Tennessee fans still hold on to the romantic idea that Iamaleava loves to sing “Rocky Top,” wear the orange and play games in front of 110,000 people all dressed in orange and white, but the only color he — and just about every other athlete in this new age — cares about is green.
It is all about the Benjamins, and if Tennessee isn’t going to pay him, he will be switching uniforms faster than you can sing the chorus of “Good ol’ Rocky Top, Rocky Top, Tennessee ... ”
Fans needs to understand the big business of big-time college athletics is exactly that and all Iamaleava is doing is making sure he gets what he feels he has earned. And if we are being completely honest, who really cares about spring football? It is almost meaningless. Nobody is playing a game that matters for, like, five more months, and in between now and then, there will be workouts, camps and a training camp for coaches to get teams ready for the season.
Players now more than ever know their value, they know their worth and they understand they have more power than they ever have. We have seen it at places like Pitt — last season, Gavin Bartholomew did a brilliant job of using rumors of transfer portal pots of gold to wedge a better deal with Pitt — and even Robert Morris.
I mean, Andy Toole took a team to the NCAA tournament, and by the time he got off the plane back at the airport, nine of his players had already entered the transfer portal, all of them in search of a better deal. That stinks for Robert Morris and every other mid-major, but if I told you there is $50,000 for you to stay here or you can go somewhere else where $200,000 is waiting for you, what are you going to do?
This Iamaleava story is no different than players who have entered the transfer portal only to return to their team when they got a better deal. It is no different than players using rumors of them entering the portal to leverage better deals from their schools and it is no different than players actually entering the transfer portal to find more money.
And now that the revenue sharing is coming — meaning teams will have a straight up payroll — I expect it to happen more frequently because, again, players now more than ever know their worth.
The key to surviving this as a fan is to accept it, embrace it and understand it is a business now, first and foremost, so most players aren’t going to share your emotional attachment to your favorite team — well, unless they are paying them the most money.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.