Full disclosure, brutally honest, in general I absolutely hate these “Back to the Future” type hires like West Virginia just did with respect to the football program.
I just don’t think it works.
Admittedly, I am probably scarred because my vantage point is usually through the lens of someone who has covered and followed Pitt up close, so there could be that bias, as well.
Pitt tried this approach at least twice in the last 35 years or so. Both times it ended in disaster.
The first was after the 1992 season when a desperate administration hired the legendary Johnny Majors back to try to save their dying football program. Majors was a link to the glory years and had won a national title in 1976 with the Panthers, so there was a lot of enthusiasm about his hire.
But four years of “Majors: The Sequel” yielded only 12 wins and produced an awful lot of ugly losses. He stepped down and handed the program off to Walt Harris. In Majors’ defense, the program structurally was in shambles, the administration’s commitment to it was questionable. It had funding and facilities issues. They could have hired Bear Bryant in his prime and it would still have been destined to fail.
Read More
Still, it was clear Majors was unable to find the magic touch he had the first time around, and what began as a potential feel-good story and happy homecoming is remembered as one of the darker eras of Pitt football.
The second time in recent memory that Pitt went “Back to the Future” was when it hired Steve Pederson back as athletic director in 2007. Pederson in many ways helped save the football program after the “Majors II” disaster and ushered in a new era of football. He was instrumental in getting Petersen Events Center built, getting a shared football facility on the South Side and getting the Panthers out of the dump that Pitt Stadium had become and into a lease to play games at Heinz Field.
But Pitt was in a different place when Pederson returned than where it was when he took the job the first time, and the school had different needs and had progressed in many areas. Pederson never adjusted, and his second stint was marked with a bunch of bad hires, fires and decisions. He was ultimately fired in 2014.
I bring those two examples up as my defaults, but there are plenty more from around the country where the “Back to the Future” idea just didn’t work out or was an abject failure.
That being said, I am actually going to be more open-minded about West Virginia’s decision to bring back Rich Rodriguez. I actually think it could work out well. I will even say this — I will be shocked if it doesn’t work out well for West Virginia because I think he will get the job done right.
First off, let’s dispense with some of the nonsense I’ve read and heard from Mountaineers fans who are still angry about his departure all those years ago: I think this will work because Rodriguez is a really good football coach.
Forget about his West Virginia roots, that he played for the Mountaineers, coached in the West Virginia Intercollegiate Athletic Conference and all that other stuff. Mountaineers fans should be happy about Rodriguez because he is an excellent football coach.
And he isn’t that old either — he is 61, and it is pretty clear to me that he still has the enthusiasm, passion and energy to do the job. I know this because in his last three seasons, he oversaw Jacksonville State’s transition from FCS to FBS. That is not an easy move to make, and many schools that have tried it have had a tougher time making the transition.
Jacksonville State, though, has won two conference titles in the last three seasons and also won a bowl game for the first time ever last year. In this current season, Rodriguez led Jacksonville State to the Conference USA title and a bid to the Cure Bowl. He has won nine games in each of the past three seasons.
His overall record is 190-129-1, which means he wins a heckuva lot more than he loses. He has had success pretty much everywhere he has been except Michigan, and I maintain that was a horrible fit for him. His personality didn’t fit at Michigan. His coaching style didn’t fit at Michigan. His offensive and defensive philosophies weren’t a great fit in the Big Ten at the time. It failed for reasons that have nothing to do with his competence as a coach.
And Arizona is a tough place to win, and I think all you need to do is look at the history of Arizona football to see that. But regardless, Rodriguez was 43-35 there, had only one losing season out of six, had a 10-win season and Fiesta Bowl bid and got the Wildcats to five bowl games in six years. Consider: Dick Tomey is thought of as one of the all-time great Arizona coaches, and in 14 seasons with the Wildcats, he only got to seven bowl games and had double-digit wins only twice.
Rodriguez’s stint at Arizona wasn’t the stuff of world beaters, but he was actually one of the most successful coaches the school has had in decades. Rodriguez won 43 games in six seasons at Arizona; the school has won 29 games in the seven seasons since he left.
In short, if you are a Mountaineers fan and still angry about Rodriguez because of the way he left — it’s been 17 years; get over it — or you are upset because you think he choked against Pitt in that 13-9 game, fine. I think you are being silly, but I will at least listen to that being the reason you aren’t happy he is back.
But this idea that he is too old or not a great football coach is idiotic on so many levels that you should probably keep that opinion to yourself. And on top of being a great coach, Rodriguez loves West Virginia, loves the university, understands the people in the state and the fans and the football program and will be more motivated to get it right.
West Virginia fans should have been rooting for Rodriguez all along because he is the best coach for the job. Time heals all wounds. I know there are usually mixed results with “Back to the Future” hires, but this one has all the makings of a situation that will not only work out but will work out extremely well.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.