I hate All-Star Games.
I have found them to become boring, uninteresting and just not a very good brand of whatever sport they are for.
Quite frankly, the only thing worse than All-Star Games are all the idiotic “skill competitions” and festivities built around them. Even the NBA All-Star Game dunk contest, once the crown jewel of skills competitions, long ago lost its luster and has turned into a bunch of guys attempting to do basically the same dunks with slightly different twists.
Monday night was the Home Run Derby, and even that was hard to watch. For one thing, most of the big names sat it out. And for another, the format was hard to follow and by the end even harder to care about.
All of that being said, I can’t wait for Tuesday night’s MLB All-Star Game. Well, let me be more accurate: I can’t wait for the first inning of the game because I want to see Paul Skenes face three of the top hitters in the American League.
Unfortunately, like everything else, Major League Baseball managed to potentially screw this up for all of us, as well.
Read More
I mean no disrespect to Steven Kwan, Gunnar Henderson or Juan Soto, as all three are tremendous players, but nobody is paying a dime to watch Skenes face any of them. Yes, it will be fun to see Skenes on the mound in an All-Star setting, but none of those matchups excite anyone.
The show everyone wants to see is this: Skenes vs. Aaron Judge in the ultimate power arm vs. power bat confrontation. I want to see Skenes dial back and find 102 MPH three times and see if Judge can catch up to one and hit it a mile.
The fact that Bruce Bochy, the manager of the American League team, doesn’t understand that this is the at-bat we all want to see tells me he is either clueless or one of these guys who actually thinks the outcome of the game matters.
I also blame MLB commissioner Rob Manfred, who is clueless on most things, for not stepping in and telling Bochy, “You will change your lineup and have Judge bat third” because, again, this is a contrived competition and a fan event.
Obviously, Skenes vs. Judge could still happen if one of the first three batters gets on base, but it isn’t guaranteed. And both Bochy and Manfred dropped the ball completely on this because it is something that should have been guaranteed.
It also could have been guaranteed had Torey Lovullo said, “Skenes will pitch to at least four hitters no matter what.” But that didn’t happen, either. If Skenes went 1-2-3 in the first, for instance, what would it hurt for him to come out to pitch to Judge to lead off the second and then get taken out of the game?
That won’t happen, though, as the Pirates and Lovullo made it clear Skenes will only pitch one inning.
“He is pitching one inning, and that’s it,” Pirates manager Derek Shelton said on his radio show. “We were very clear with Major League Baseball about that.
“We play New York in September or October, so you will get a chance to see them face each other then.”
I do love that Soto is calling his shot and guaranteeing that Judge will get to the plate in the first inning, though. That at least adds a little bit of spice to his at-bat against Skenes, but it doesn’t mean much of anything unless he gets a hit.
"I'll make sure [Judge] faces him," Soto said Monday. "[Skenes] is just incredible. It's incredible to see a guy like that put in the performance he's been doing. You know, as a young guy, he's just coming up and showing his stuff, and it's very electric stuff. But we will see how it goes."
Honestly, there are still a few ways that Skenes could control his ability to face Judge in this game. He could hit one of the first three guys or walk one of them on purpose.
I am rooting for this scene to happen though:
Soto walks up to the plate, Skenes looks at him, then looks at the ump and points to first base and intentionally walks him to face Judge. Then, he points to Judge and directs him to step up to the plate and get ready to roll.
Could you imagine the buzz for that? Could you imagine how much fun that would make the confrontation and how much more interesting it would make what will mostly be an uninteresting exhibition of baseball played by a bunch of guys who don’t want to be there?
Dare to dream, I suppose.
The MLB All-Star Game is supposed to be a showcase of the best against the best, and in this case, that will be — or would have been — Skenes and his 100-plus mph fastball vs. Judge and his 34 home runs, many of the “towering” variety.
Major League Baseball had the perfect chance to make that happen on the big stage and might very well have dropped the ball.
Paul Zeise: pzeise@post-gazette.com and @paulzeise on X




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.