Count me in the extreme minority in this town, but I don’t give a rip when Paul Skenes gets called up from Indianapolis to the Pirates. It is going to happen, and when it does, it will be one of the most anticipated debuts in a long time, not just for the Pirates but for Pittsburgh sports in general.

I could make a strong case that it will be the most anticipated debut for an athlete in Pittsburgh since Sidney Crosby, and that was almost two decades ago.

Don’t get me wrong — I am as excited to see Skenes as anyone else, but he doesn’t solve the Pirates’ biggest problem, which is hitting. That’s why I have consistently said I am far more interested in when Nick Gonzales, Jake Lamb or even Ji Hwan Bae are going to get called up than Skenes because those three might actually help them in an area they need help in.

And the other thing is this: The Pirates rotation has been just fine without him, which is easily the biggest and most surprising development of the season. The rotation has been so good, actually, that the desperate cries from some for Skenes to get called up are a bit silly.

Advertise with us

Yes, Skenes would help (maybe), and yes, he would be an upgrade on at least one or two of the current starters (maybe), but this group as a whole has given the Pirates a chance to remain competitive until their offense gets on track.

Nobody — not even Derek Shelton — thought the Pirates rotation would be this good, but it has held up so far and hasn’t given any indication that it is going to slow down anytime soon. Skenes will obviously enhance it, but for now, the Pirates are getting a really competitive start pretty much every game.

Shelton said on his weekly radio show on 93.7 The Fan that he had high hopes for the rotation, but he wasn’t sure it was going to be as good as it has been. He said the most impressive piece has been the amount of innings the starters have pitched and their ability to go deeper into games. He knows at some point they will have to manage those innings to keep them all healthy for later in the season, but as of now, he is going to let them pitch with few restrictions.

Mitch Keller turned in one of the best performances for the Pirates this season Monday, as he threw a complete game in a 4-1 win over the Angels. Keller threw only 109 pitches and controlled the Angels hitters by inducing ground ball out after ground ball out. Keller has been a bit inconsistent, but he has been an innings eater and more often than not, he gives the Pirates a chance to win because he rarely has the blow-up game.

Jared Jones has been a phenom and right now is one of the three or four best pitchers in the National League. Nobody saw him getting this good this fast, but he has been as dominant of a rookie as the Pirates have had — and really most teams have had — in a long, long time.

Advertise with us

Bailey Falter started slow but has become a reliable pitcher, and Martin Perez has a 3.15 ERA in his seven starts. Also Keller, Falter, Perez and Jones are all on pace to get to about 180 innings or something close, which is impressive if all four of them reach that number because it means they have been extremely effective.

Clearly, that pace will slow down, as one of them will have to move to the bullpen when Skenes arrives. They will also be able to go to six-man rotations and skip starts to preserve innings on some of their arms. But nevertheless, the group as a whole has gotten the job done, and if they continue to do that, the Pirates will be able to hang around all summer long.

And then there is one of the most pleasant surprises: Quinn Priester, who is slated to start Tuesday night’s game against the Angels. Priester really struggled last season and was eventually sent back to the minors, but he was called up a few weeks ago when Marco Gonzales went down with an injury. Priester has started three games and he has gone 16⅓ innings and has an ERA of 3.31, a 1.29 WHIP and he has struck out 11 while walking only six.

Shelton said Tuesday that Priester’s progress has been impressive and it shows that he is learning how to become an effective major-league starter.

“He is more aggressive,” Shelton said. “That would be the mindset when you first come to the big leagues. It is one of those things, ‘Do I belong here? Do I have to make the perfect pitch?’ Now, we are just seeing him trust his repertoire.”

Advertise with us

Priester has a lot more to prove before he has officially arrived as a starter, but he is clearly on a good track so far, and it seems like he has fixed some of his issues from a year ago.

The rotation was supposed to be a team weakness, and instead, so far, it has been a team strength. That, as much as any “box checking” Skenes has to do in the minors before his promotion, is the reason the Pirates can be cautious and patient with their 2023 first-round pick.

Paul Zeise: pzeise@post-gazette.com and @paulzeise on X